Gransnet forums

Health

Can you be cured of depression?

(45 Posts)
Bridgeit Thu 28-Dec-17 22:40:31

I would say it can be controlled, but that one must always be aware that they are prone to be affected by it depending on certain circumstances that can trigger an episode. Understanding the triggers is key to depression management

Anniebach Thu 28-Dec-17 21:30:15

Yes wot, I don't mean a sherry ?, but Alcohol is a depressant and heavy drinking causes deeper depression and certaintly lessens the effects of medication. You will learn this at an Al anon meeting or a rehab centre

NfkDumpling Thu 28-Dec-17 21:20:23

It may be worth considering Eglantines suggestion to move to a rented accommodation nearby just until after DS's exams. Use that as the excuse. It will give DS a peaceful study environemt and may give DH time to consider his situation while you'll still be on hand to help him, but not be his whipping girl. Best to talk it through with his counsellors and doctors. The change has to come from him. Until he wants it, you can't really help him.

wot Thu 28-Dec-17 21:09:50

Annie, I didn't realise that alcohol can cancel the beneficial effects of anti depressants.

Anniebach Thu 28-Dec-17 21:01:00

There are many types of depression,

Reactive depression which happens when life throws you a blow,

Clinical depression can be serious, many causes, but this is a depression where some sufferers cannot get out of bed, doesn't bathe, doesn't eat, can be unaware of what is going on around them

Bi polar or manic depression is very serious, often leads to suicide when a low strikes but when a high strikes this too can cause harm, promiscuity, burns up energy but doesn't need sleep, thrills such as shop lifting .

No, I am not an expert, I had to attend meetings with a psychologist when I worked at the drop in centre

Fennel Thu 28-Dec-17 18:31:13

I think there are different types of depression.
The kind that most of us have at some time in our lives is extreme sadness because of a life experience, which can lift quickly, or last for a long time.
Then there are various kinds of depression due to chemical changes , eg old age, post puerperal. Probably what is now called bi-polar comes into that too.
With bi-polar, people sometimes use alcohol to try to prolong and make more intense the 'highs' , in fear of dropping into the 'lows'.
But we still have much to learn about it.

Anniebach Thu 28-Dec-17 17:45:18

So true Luckygirl, we haven't really advanced in understanding of mental illness

Luckygirl Thu 28-Dec-17 17:41:55

If someone with a serious depression does not seem to respond to suggestions that might improve their condition, it does not mean they are being awkward or obstructive - it is one of the characteristics of the illness that sufferers cannot find the impetus to do things - even things that they know might improve their situation. They do not "choose to make their condition worse"; they cannot help themselves. It is the nature of the illness. When you are depressed, it takes a massive (and sometimes impossible) effort to do anything constructive; just as someone with a broken leg cannot walk - no-one thinks it is because they are not prepared to make the effort.

GillT57 Thu 28-Dec-17 12:36:53

Depression is an illness like any other in many ways, but different in others. As the counsellors said, it is a selfish condition, and to put it bluntly, if your DH cannot or will not help himself, but instead chooses to make his condition even worse by refusing to consider things which may alleviate symptoms, and persists with things such as excess alcohol consumption which make it far worse, then there is really little you can do to help him. What you can do is help yourself, and your son, and perhaps your step children need to be informed of his true condition. If he is able to turn on the charm for them, but make the lives of you and your son miserable, then you need to seriously reconsider the future, living with someone who uses his illness as a weapon is too awful to consider.

Eglantine21 Thu 28-Dec-17 12:14:54

Cancel the trip, use the money saved to remove yourself and your son from this situation for this year which is important to him. He can't study or concentrate in a corrosive environment. Please put him first.
He doesn't have to move schools. Rent close by.
What youre doing now isn't working for anyone. You can't change your partner. The change has to come from you.
My best wishes to you.

vampirequeen Thu 28-Dec-17 11:59:02

I don't think you can get better but you can live better. It all depends on your will to fight. Everyday is a battle. Some days you win and some days you lose but you hope that you have more win days than lose days. That said, you have to want to fight.

It's all very well the counselors telling you to steer him towards exercise and mindfulness. If he chooses not to or isn't ready then he won't do it and will view it as nagging and a lack of understanding.

I am concerned that he can control it when he wants to. Are you and your DS the only people who see him at his worst? I know that it's possible to put the smile on for others but this seems odd. He's making the ones who would support you, doubt you by being OK with them every time he sees them.

Was he a controlling man before he became ill?

Whatever the reason, you have to put you and your DS first. Living with someone with depression is difficult at the best of times. Your situation is driving you into depression too and that's not fair. Perhaps it's time to make plans to leave so that, if the time comes, you are ready to go.

mollie Thu 28-Dec-17 11:58:46

It sounds like an awful situation for all concerned and it’s hard to imagine why your DP doesn’t want to change things by giving up alcohol and trying exercise etc. The truth is nothing you can do will make a bit of difference until he wants to change and makes the effort. I have a similar problem but a different issue with my OH and the changes that have been successful have all been the ones he’s embraced wholeheartedly. Nothing I have tried to persuade him helped and really only added to the stress.

seasider Thu 28-Dec-17 11:41:59

Thank you Fennel and Annie. I went on a course to understand the condition better. The counsellors said I should steer him to things like exercise, yoga and mindfulness. OP thinks it is a load of rubbish ! They also said depression is a very selfish condition and some people choose not to get better as they enjoy the attention. It is so frustrating and I am losing patience.I have stopped "covering" for him when he fails to attend social events. I have tried to explain to his older children (my stepchildren) but they don't really understand as he makes the effort with them ! I went to the doctors for something unrelated and happened to.mention DP's depression. She asked me how I felt and I burst into tears as she was the first person to ask me how I actually felt about it sad

Anniebach Thu 28-Dec-17 10:51:51

Seasider, you can't , nothing will change untill he seeks help for his drinking , so sorry for you, it is such a feeling of helplessness watching someone you care for destroying themselves . In fact I ache for you. X

seasider Thu 28-Dec-17 10:44:03

I know Annie but how do you stop a grown man ?

Fennel Thu 28-Dec-17 10:43:36

Alcohol is a depressive.
Years ago I lived with my ex who had similar problems. Eventually diagnosed as bipolar and on lithium for the rest of his life. But he had to want to change.
He did "get better", as a result of eventually making a huge effort.
Thinking of you, seasider.

Anniebach Thu 28-Dec-17 10:39:26

drinking alcohol will cause depression and anxiety cancelling out the effects of the anti depressants

seasider Thu 28-Dec-17 10:37:26

It is difficult Liz and DS is constantly being criticised when he is just a normal teenager and not a bad lad. I just wish there was a miracle cure!

Liz46 Thu 28-Dec-17 10:27:01

I know you are worried about moving your son but maybe he would be happier in a calmer environment? It's a hard one but it does sound as though your DP is making your life difficult.

seasider Thu 28-Dec-17 10:22:41

DP suffers with anxiety and depression which is getting worse. He was off work for six months and had CBT and increased medication ( he has taken fluoroxetine for years). He is back at work in a less stressful role but no better really. Teenage DS and I walking on eggshells all the time. The mood swings are horrific. He constantly criticises everything, drinks to excess and refuses to partake in any of the suggested coping strategies. Christmas was ruined really. Very close to walking out but this is an important academic year for DS ( he would come with me)
We have the trip of a lifetime booked in a few months time but tempted to cancel now while I will lose only the deposit. DP always stressed before holidays but enjoys it when we get there. I feel I have done all I can to keep things together but I have had enough.