Gransnet forums

Health

Is this attitude common?

(130 Posts)
Juno56 Fri 11-Sept-20 11:44:56

I don't post much (more of
a lurker?) but I had to ask for opinions because I am quite perturbed.
I had coffee this week with a good friend whom I would have said I knew well. The conversation got around to the "joys" of getting older and "you know you're getting on a bit when....". I said: "when the bowel cancer test kit comes through the box a few days after your 60th birthday ?". I was amazed when my friend said that she had never returned her test. Not only that, she had never responded to a breast cancer test invitation and had only ever had one cervical smear test because she found it all too embarrassing and distasteful! She changed the subject, we finished our coffee and parted soon after but it set me thinking, is this attitude common? I wondered what GNers thought.

Greciangirl Sat 12-Sept-20 09:48:17

I do all the relevant health checks including Bowel testing kit which is so easy.
But compared to a colonoscopy it’s a breeze.

I had one once, and never again.
It was very invasive and quite painful.
I can only conclude that I wasn’t given enough pain relief.

NotSpaghetti Sat 12-Sept-20 02:10:27

Bluebelle, you don't get shingles because you haven't had the vaccination. You will only get shingles from the varicella-zoster virus. It's the same virus as chickenpox so anyone who had chickenpox is susceptible. The virus can enter your nervous system and lie dormant for years.

It's well known that both radiation treatments and chemotherapy can activate dormant virus.

Elrel Fri 11-Sept-20 23:52:02

At 80 I began to feel I should have a mammogram and a cervical smear ‘just in case’. I had them both regularly whenever they were offered. I hadn’t arranged either then lockdown came along. Maybe I won't bother.

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 22:57:48

however she now has shingles because she didn’t want the shingles jab ??‍♂️

Bluebelle, if she'd had treatment which meant her immune system was compromised then she wouldn't be allowed to have the shingles vaccine.
Annoying but that is the advice.

grannyrebel7 Fri 11-Sept-20 22:17:56

I take any test that is offered to me. However I have a friend who never goes to the doctor's or has any of these tests. She's very overweight but seems to be ok in every other respect but I suppose you never really know unless tested.

Furret Fri 11-Sept-20 21:44:30

I knew two women, quite well, who died from breast cancer and refused a screening test.

etheltbags1 Fri 11-Sept-20 21:43:44

I took my test and found I had bowel cancer stage 3. I've been lucky so far nearly 6 years later I'm still ok but I will take up any tests I get

Greeneyedgirl Fri 11-Sept-20 21:35:35

There seems to be good evidence that mortality from colon cancer is reduced by screening, especially with the new FIT test.
With breast cancer I don’t think it is as clear cut, many women are diagnosed and treated for DC that will never progress. If one life is saved, and if it is you. I guess you will think it’s worth it.

52bright Fri 11-Sept-20 21:32:27

A very interesting thread. My own dad was a reluctant visitor to the doctor and when he eventually was referred at aged 56, he walked out of the consultation when he realized he was going to be examined by a female doctor. When things got worse and he was admitted for surgery, he ended up with only two years left. My mother always felt that if he had accepted treatment earlier he might have llived longer.

However, my beloved sister, similar age, attended for tests from the first moment she knew something was wrong, She underwent several radical operations and any treatments he was offered. The result ...she sadly died in a similar time space to my father. I suppose we all must do what we think is best for us ...and live with the consequences.

I am currently waiting for tests myself. I do feel that early checks help with early detection so in my case I am going with trying to find out and treat if necessary but I totally understand why others might make a different decision.

Galaxy Fri 11-Sept-20 21:19:52

You seem a lovely friend. We have to remember that people make different choices to us and we may not always know the reason behind those choices. flowers

Juno56 Fri 11-Sept-20 20:48:26

Thank you all for your replies. They have made me think beyond my disappointment and dismay at my friend's choices. I think she is mistaken but they are her choices to make.

NotSpaghetti Fri 11-Sept-20 20:40:50

I don't do them either geekess and janeainsworth and also know a doctor who doesn't have mammograms because of unnecessary surgery.

I almost had unnecessary surgery some years ago and consider myself very lucky to have avoided it.

Some of us have made considered decisions.
We are not scared or ostriches or squeamish. Mostly we have read the research papers and come to a decision based on our own circumstances and the current medical information available.

wildswan16 Fri 11-Sept-20 19:03:04

I always use mine - the thing to remember is that if you do it every time then any problems are picked up early enough to be easily treated and sorted.

Not doing it just means by the time you notice a problem it may be too late or require very invasive treatment. (Which also costs the NHS an awful lot more.)

Hetty58 Fri 11-Sept-20 18:53:00

I never have any tests and I'm quite happy with that decision. I don't worry about my health either.

grannyqueenie, your mum did have a point. There's a lot of unnecessary treatment based on the test results.

Doodledog Fri 11-Sept-20 18:52:41

Elegran

If Juno's friend does develop cancer in her breast, cervix or bowel, she will soon discover just how much more "too embarrassing and distasteful" any of those are than a few minutes doing a test. Silly pseudo-sensitive woman - too concerned about being tasteful to take care of herself! I wonder if she finds it too distasteful to wash under her armpits or wipe her arse?

Without knowing Juno's friend it is impossible to know whether she is 'silly' or 'pseudo-sensitive' (whatever that means), both of which are judgemental and subjective terms anyway.

People have all sorts of reasons for not wanting tests, and it is up to them whether or not to take them up.

A friend of mine is a GP, and she doesn't and never has had a routine mammogram, as she says that the number of false positives is so high that women often have unnecessary surgery and/or invasive tests because of findings that would never develop into anything dangerous.

I do have them done, and have had two separate false positives - one was a mark near my nipple which scared a very young GP and the other showed up on a mammogram and turned out to probably have been caused by the mobile unit moving when the photo was taken. I will continue getting them when I'm called, but I can see (and respect) her point of view.

Women who have been assaulted in the past can be traumatised at the thought of certain tests, too, which is also understandable and entirely unconnected to sensitivity, silliness or questions of taste. Have a bit of compassion?

Oopsminty Fri 11-Sept-20 18:52:36

Most people in my world will have any test going

However due to a very rare error , a 68 year old male friend of ours had the bowel test

He was a fit active man and played a mean game of squash

Traces of cancer were discovered. Surgery followed which went awry

He ended up with a colostomy and developed depression

Two years on he is in a facility and on a daily basis regrets his decision

Of course these things do happen. It's a risk. He may well have had a long protracted death from the cancer.

Nothing is certain and I would never criticise anyone opting for no treatment

MissAdventure Fri 11-Sept-20 18:52:02

My mum was the same.
Perhaps I get it from her, although I do reluctantly go for tests. Eventually.

grannyqueenie Fri 11-Sept-20 18:47:41

I’ll take any tests/screening I’m offered!
My mother’s attitude was to smear test or mammograms was “I don’t want anyone poking around, they’ll only go and find something!” No amount me saying that was the whole point would change her mind. Sadly I think lots of folk take the same head in the sand view.

MissAdventure Fri 11-Sept-20 18:46:16

Yes, true.
Still, it's for each person to decide for themself, as frustrating as it can be.

Elegran Fri 11-Sept-20 18:36:15

If you are diagnosed while the cancer is still tiny, there is less pulling around etc than if you wait until it is large and aggressive and its offspring have moved in to other parts of your anatomy.

MissAdventure Fri 11-Sept-20 18:11:43

There is plenty more investigations, tests, and pulling around if you're diagnosed, though.

TwiceAsNice Fri 11-Sept-20 18:08:28

Have had mammograms and smears regularly and have done several bowel kits. I think I’m due another one next year? Neither a mammogram or smear are particularly pleasant but better that than cancer surely

MissAdventure Fri 11-Sept-20 17:48:56

It has to be an individual choice, depending on so many factors.

BlueBelle Fri 11-Sept-20 17:42:41

I do have the test but I also totally understand your point geekesse and especially as you have said you carefully considered it and have made your decision My family member did not carefully consider it they just didn’t want to do it they were not embarrassed just didn’t want to, no idea of their thoughts or reasoning behind it

geekesse Fri 11-Sept-20 17:36:09

JenniferEccles, I certainly have not “simply just buried [my] head in the sand”.

I have considered very carefully the possible consequences of my decision, and chosen to remain untested. I have a higher than normal risk of bowel cancer, and it is likely to kill me sooner or later whether I know about it or not, and whether I have treatment or not. I choose to reject the option of early diagnosis. My body, my choice.