Gransnet forums

Health

Any advice on Magnesium supplements.

(17 Posts)
annsixty Thu 15-Feb-24 15:08:16

A friend called on me today , she had been to see her GP after having a scan done for painful legs, particularly at night.
She is a bit of a health worrier and was concerned when told the scan showed nothing wrong.
Her GP suggested a Magnesium supplement but when we consulted Dr Google it would seem there are several types of this.
Has anyone any suggestions as to which type to take?

Callistemon21 Thu 15-Feb-24 15:43:30

I take the Vitabiotics ones, they do help to alleviate cramps.

Nannylovesshopping Thu 15-Feb-24 15:46:02

I take boots own brand magnesium for leg cramps at night, they are utterly brilliant, and painful leg cramps are a thing of the past!

annsixty Thu 15-Feb-24 15:52:39

Thank you both .
I did recommend Vitabiotics to her as that is my go to brand for Vit C and Iron.
However my query was really about the citric or glycinate.
There are others Ithink.

boheminan Thu 15-Feb-24 16:37:20

I bought Boots own brand because like Nannylovesshopping, I get leg cramp at night. However, two months into taking them and I'm still getting the cramp, so am not convinced they work - for me.

Chestnut Thu 15-Feb-24 16:46:52

I buy all my supplements from Healthspan because they really are the best. I suggest you compare the ingredients of each brand for yourself.

Magnesium 375mg from Healthspan

Chestnut Thu 15-Feb-24 17:05:03

boheminan

I bought Boots own brand because like Nannylovesshopping, I get leg cramp at night. However, two months into taking them and I'm still getting the cramp, so am not convinced they work - for me.

Just looking up the magnesium from Healthspan which I just posted about, and it says this:
We would recommend this product to be taken for a minimum of 6 to 8 weeks, however maximum benefits may not be obtained until at least 3 to 4 months of continuous usage.
So keep going and good luck.......... 🙏

Chestnut Thu 15-Feb-24 17:06:45

And as I said, compare the ingredients of the Boots pills you're using with the Healthspan ingredients.

boheminan Thu 15-Feb-24 17:11:05

Thanks Chestnut I'll do a compare of brands and ingredients

Skye17 Thu 15-Feb-24 17:15:19

I find two of these magnesium bisglycinate capsules at night help me sleep. They should help with painful legs too.

www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/B0BY5GFG77?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_image&tag=gransnetforum-21

Bobblesack Thu 15-Feb-24 17:29:24

I take lots of magnesium to help my Vit D deficiency, and I do find that it helps with restless legs too. My tip would be to avoid Magnesium Oxide as it can cause bad diarrhoea, but Magnesium Citrate is much gentler on the stomach and works well.

karmalady Thu 15-Feb-24 17:36:44

Epsom salts in a bath. Mag sulphate. The skin will absorb what it needs

Jaxjacky Thu 15-Feb-24 18:24:26

MrJ swears by a Magnesium spray for cramp, instant relief.

V3ra Thu 15-Feb-24 18:59:16

I buy all my supplements from Healthspan because they really are the best. I suggest you compare the ingredients of each brand for yourself.

Same here. There are lots of informative articles on their website as well.
For anything I take regularly I have it on a subscription which gives a price discount.
I can manage the details of this, eg how frequently I want it delivered and if I want to change a delivery date or cancel it, through my account online.

SORES Thu 15-Feb-24 19:13:09

our knowledgeable local healthshop recommended the NaturesPlus Magnesium capsules, they do an orange powder too, mix with water as a drink, speeds absorption, take daily, it needs to kick in properly, expensive, but beats howling with pain and cramps in the middle of the night

1summer Thu 15-Feb-24 22:46:32

I also like Healthspan supplements but I have Epsom salt baths which eases leg pain and helps reduce swelling in my feet and ankles.

SORES Fri 16-Feb-24 07:50:29

Sorry OP, missed out the crucial bit, they are Citrate, and Vegan