Gransnet forums

Health

root canal, extraction or implant

(33 Posts)
Apple3pie Fri 03-Apr-26 13:05:18

I've had many root canals. Some painful, some not at all. Most of them worked, except one tooth that I had three root canals on plus one operation, and it still kept getting infected. I would try the root canal first. Even the painful ones were just moments during the procedure, and probably not worse than the pain you are experiencing now.

sodapop Fri 03-Apr-26 12:45:14

I've had successful root canal treatment as well, not painful at all . Just takes a long time as Shelflife said. Extraction will be cheaper and if it's at the back no implant needed.

NotSpaghetti Fri 03-Apr-26 12:40:48

I wouldn't want a gap really as it impacts your bite and can cause other issues.

LadyGracie Fri 03-Apr-26 12:35:41

I’ve had 3 root canals and all have been successful and definitely not as bad as I feared. I would go for the root canal rather than extraction.

Shelflife Fri 03-Apr-26 10:08:12

Difficult decision ! Don't think I would go down the implant route. I have had root canal work done twice, on each occasion I went for the appointment in fear and trembling - my feelings were unfounded . It was no worse than an ordinary filling , just took much longer! Both have been successful. However you may opt for an extraction-that will be much cheaper !!
Good luck .

NanKate Fri 03-Apr-26 10:06:48

I agree with Primrose.

I decided on a tooth extraction recently, lower back tooth. I am coping well without it and it was much cheaper.

The one thing I am really pleased I started 14 years ago was teeth whitening.

Primrose53 Fri 03-Apr-26 09:56:34

In my experience root canal treatment is often unsuccessful and you end up having an extraction anyway.
Personally, I would just have the back molar removed.
Good luck - toothache is awful.

truman Fri 03-Apr-26 09:52:28

One of my back molars either needs a root canal, extraction or implant. I dont think I have ever had a root canal but I do have two implants. I am on penicillin at the moment as its a bit painful. If I choose the root canal do they always work. I need for this to last years, like the implants. I have a very small mouth and I cannot open my jaw fully as I have TMJ (problem with jaw muscle) the dentist is not sure she can put an implant in that position. I really dont want it removed as I only have one other molar at the bottom on that side. I am undecided as to what to do. Has anyone else had to make this choice.