Gransnet forums

Health

what would you program into the ideal robot nurses/doctors

(11 Posts)
NanaMaryNH Mon 25-May-26 14:04:10

Let's say you could have an open line to any doc or nurse in the world who could help you with any need you had. Who would they be? Eg, if you have melanoma, you'd want the best doc with the best treatment experience and outomes. Maybe not the new graduate doc next door? And they'd be kind and maybe even funny? And not judge your irrational fears, etc!!!! List as many people and qualities, your IDEALS, that you can't get it in one place here.

Elegran Mon 25-May-26 14:42:29

Your heading and post are about different things. Robot or real doctors and nurses?

If I was programming a robot, I would include a way for the patient to contact a real breathing, speaking, listening human being who would observe my expression and tone of voice as I described symptoms and asked my questions, someone who would make conclusions with that information as well as the bare facts. He or she would explain the diagnoses, treatment and prognosis in terms that I could take in and understand. Robot chats usually bring you round in a circle that starts back at the beginning again without properly answering you

I don't know enough about all the individual specialists who might be able to help with every ailment I might suffer from. I rely on my GP to refer me to whoever is most suitable for the problem of the day. Since I won't be travelling (expensively) round the globe for (expensive) treatment, that will be a relatively local consultant.

NanaMaryNH Mon 25-May-26 15:16:28

Thx for taking the time to reply. As a (retired) human being health professional, I appreciate your preference. But... AIs will be able to assess much of what you described and refer you to the best humans for you. And to be kind or even funny (your preferences). Eg, I live in America, so I just asked an AI to list the best surgeons for an issue and it checked my insurance (we don't have NHS) and listed the best "peer reviewed" surgeons, with their contact info. This feels like the most basic guidance, What else might someone want? Monioring my meds would be nice!

Grannynannywanny Mon 25-May-26 15:38:12

What else might someone want?

An orthopaedic waiting list that doesn’t involve a wait of a year for a total knee replacement classed as urgent would be beneficial. AI might well be able to suggest the best surgeons but that’s not much help with the current state of the NHS.

MissAdventure Mon 25-May-26 15:44:33

Compassion.
The abilty to take heed of what they're told., by the person who has taken the time to make an appointment.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 25-May-26 17:43:40

Accuracy

NanaMaryNH Mon 25-May-26 22:59:46

Thanks to all! ANyone else?

mae13 Tue 26-May-26 04:09:16

The 'Ideal' robot medic would have the words "how are WE today, then?" expunged from their memory bank.

Rather like the scene in '2001 A Space Odyssey' when Dave, the last surviving astronaut, starts to dismantle the memory of HAL the rogue computer.

Vintagewhine Tue 26-May-26 07:26:26

Are you working on AI?

fancyflowers Tue 26-May-26 08:27:51

A robot could only refer you to the most qualified doctor to deal with your problem.

Not that it would be much use as you probably couldn't get an appointment for six weeks.

Sallywally1 Wed 27-May-26 06:13:22

Compassion, empathy, patience, understanding, a sense of humour, the ability to go the extra mile, skilled in specialty. Am I being unreasonable?