Gransnet forums

House and home

Would you enclose this?

(56 Posts)
Flaxseed Sun 03-Jul-22 19:57:03

*Photo taken from Pinterest so as not to ‘out’ myself*

So, finally after a stressful sale of my house last year, temporary stay with DP whilst he sells his, we have exchanged contracts on our first house together.
We move the end of the month which cannot come soon enough!
We will have a wood burner very similar to the one in the photo. Floor to ceiling (one storey property)
We have toyed with the idea of enclosing it with a brick surround to create a fireplace with shelving either side but what do you think?
I am constantly looking at ideas for leaving as it is, and enclosing it and am so indecisive!
DP is easy, but is leaning more towards enclosing it.
What would you do?

OpenUniversity2017 Tue 05-Jul-22 13:09:35

Would I enclose it ?
No.

Elegran Tue 05-Jul-22 13:07:03

If you do enclose it, you need to be very careful with safety issues. Monica's woodburner which heats the bricks enclosing it so that enough heat goes out to heat a four-bedroom house shows just how hot the surroundings get.

We knew someone who had, not a woodburning stove, but a big open fireplace with a centuries-old wooden beam as a mantlepiece, in a very old house - It was beautiful, and they used it a lot. One night they went to bed leaving the fire very low and, they thought, safe. One of them was up during the night and when passing the fireplace in a darkened room, realised that the mantlepiece beam was glowing red. It turned out to be almost hollow from the back and would have eventually burned through and collapsed. It could have been a tragedy.

Happysexagenarian Tue 05-Jul-22 13:06:49

Leave it open. The exposed flue will generate extra heat in the room. Floating shelves at staggered heights on either side could look quite nice while keeping a spacious feel.

Good luck with your move.

Madashell Tue 05-Jul-22 13:02:48

Leave it as is, go to Ikea for some “Billies”, in summer surround the burner with house plants.

I miss my log burner…

Dianehillbilly1957 Tue 05-Jul-22 12:49:17

Definitely keep exposed, wood burners are designed to give you as much heat as possible, enclosing them limits this a fair bit. With the cost of heating now days you need everything you can get! Also try using an Ecofan, they sit on top at the back of the stove and fan the heat out, also great way to see if you're needing more wood as the fan slows as it cools...

Theoddbird Tue 05-Jul-22 12:31:19

I have a wood burner. A lot of heat comes from the flue. By enclosing it you would lose that precious heat.

aggie Tue 05-Jul-22 11:53:49

I had one in the last house with brick round it , the room was good size but the brick looked heavy , the one we have now has never been lit , but I use fairy lights in and on it at Christmas

M0nica Tue 05-Jul-22 11:37:17

We live in an old house and our woodburner is in set in a huge brick chimney, including bread oven . Three or feet thick in places and heavily bricked through both floors.

We use it in winter during cold spells. Far from the chimney insulating us from the heat, the solid mass of bricks absorbs the heat and the chimney heats up like a great storage radiator and the heat from it, heats not only the living room, but the karge hallway and the two bedrooms above.

A couple of years ago, we had problems with the gas supply to our end of the village and for two weeks in Novemeber had no central heating. This one, not large, stove, effectively heated a large 4 bedroomed house

Flaxseed Mon 04-Jul-22 20:43:49

Thanks for all your comments.
I think I have been swayed to keep it exposed. Especially if there are building regs to create a fireplace/surround!

We do intend having cupboards/shelves either side.

I doubt we would actually use it much as that won’t be the only form of heating in that room.

I will be back with other questions to all you knowledgeable lot, so watch this space!

Mapleleaf Mon 04-Jul-22 08:03:19

I think it would be better to leave it open. As others have said, it will allow more heat to remain in the room, and you could look for complementary free standing shelving/cupboards to sit either side, allowing for airflow and the heat from the chimney, of course - nothing placed to close to it, as it will get very hot.

Grammaretto Mon 04-Jul-22 08:02:57

I'm assured a wood burner is carbon neutral Esspee. I have a woodland nearby so no need to transport fuel either.

Grammaretto Mon 04-Jul-22 07:56:43

I would leave it at least for the time being. You will get used to it too and be grateful for the extra heat when winter comes. You can always change the colour of your walls to make it less stark. If yours is similar to the Pinterest one.

H1954 Mon 04-Jul-22 07:40:57

I would leave the chimney exposed. As already stated, it would radiate the hear from the fire. I would consider book cases, or even positioning other furniture in the spaces each side of the wood burner. Definitely wouldn't enclose the chimney.

Joseanne Mon 04-Jul-22 07:30:19

StarDreamer

Joseanne wrote ^... and will hang a large picture above the wood burner."

Will the rising heat damage the picture?

We've never actually lit the wood burner! It came with the house. The room is south facing, mild coastal region, and we aren't ones for liking too much heat! Purely aesthetic!

StarDreamer Mon 04-Jul-22 00:57:23

Joseanne wrote ^... and will hang a large picture above the wood burner."

Will the rising heat damage the picture?

NotSpaghetti Mon 04-Jul-22 00:20:56

J52 - and some stoves are more efficient.

Leave it as it is I think.

J52 Sun 03-Jul-22 21:33:57

Esspee

Wood burning at home emits more particle pollution than traffic. The days of wood burning stoves is coming to an end so no point in altering the room by building it in would be my recommendation.

Not quite true. It depends on the fuel used. Multi fuel stoves that burn seasoned wood and specially adapted carbon products do not pollute the atmosphere more that diesel or petrol.
With gas and electric prices on the rise keep your solid fuel stove, just burn the right fuel.

Stephanie48 Sun 03-Jul-22 21:29:42

I would leave it as it is. You could put light coloured bookcases each side to frame it, and for storage.

Grannybags Sun 03-Jul-22 21:24:17

I think it would look nicer left as it is

Esspee Sun 03-Jul-22 21:23:10

Sorry, are not is. Should have proof read my comment.

Esspee Sun 03-Jul-22 21:21:39

Wood burning at home emits more particle pollution than traffic. The days of wood burning stoves is coming to an end so no point in altering the room by building it in would be my recommendation.

VioletSky Sun 03-Jul-22 21:20:45

Small room, as photo large room, fireplace and storage for me

J52 Sun 03-Jul-22 21:17:44

I’d leave it, for all the reasons already mentioned. If you enclose the chimney you’ll have to comply with building regulations.

Joseanne Sun 03-Jul-22 20:42:30

We have a white one which is enclosed to make a fireplace. We have just had the wall painted in a sapphire blue and will hang a large picture above the wood burner. The walls either side are pebble coloured as a contrast and have shelves.
If you leave it open it might look more rustic. It depends what style you want.I

MrsKen33 Sun 03-Jul-22 20:19:10

Our also is free standing. It heats the room much better. Love it. All we need in the winter