What about a "Benefits, Legal & Money" Topic?

Hi GNHQ. Has enough time passed for you to assess this? Perhaps you could let us know the outcome.

(Reported by me in hope we get a reply.)

I forgot to add, that yes, I think it is a good idea to have a benefits heading.
I favour a dedicated section, though clearly added on to the Legal and Money section would be better than nothing.

Could GNHQ think that by putting this thread on 'chat', it is likely to be read (and replied to) by far more Gransnetters than one on 'site stuff', so giving them a more accurate idea of how much support there is for the suggestion? Just a thought.

Bump.

Yoo-hoo, GNHQ. Any progress?

(As an aside, I just saw 'Gransnet' on the MN Talk list. So that's what we are - an obscure little section of MN.)

I wish they would just get on with it.

I'm commenting on here with the vain hope that it might rise to the top again as I still think it would be a good idea. Having just read PippaZ latest post which I feel is somewhat disenchanted with GN (rightly so) I think perhaps we should make a more concerted effort to get some one at HQ to listen and respond.

Maybe it's part of the GN tradition of keeping us occupied while nothing actually happens.

Yes once again a great idea.

Fingers crossed PippaZ

I've put a post on the original thread Grannynannywanny, asking what the problem is - I can understand why there is an issue that needs us to put a thread first in one place and then another.

I have reported that post so maybe (or not) they will tell us why this is such a challenge for them.

I hope when GNHQ are considering this request they take into account that there were 4 pages of posts unanimously in favour in response to Pippa’s original post.

Yes. I think benefits would be better on its own

I have been out today celebrating my birthday this weekend and was really suprised to see GNHQ had asked for another thread.

I'm sure we have all heard that one of the most unclaimed benefits is Pension Credit but many people will need to find out about them, not necessarily for themselves but for older and younger family members. I started to find out about them for my mother and, to be honest, there should be a degree course in finding your way round and understanding them.

I am trying to understand why GNHQ wanted this on Chat, as well as on Site Stuff. I can only think that they want to be sure this subject will not offend anyone. I can't believe it will. I know just how helpful our community can be. I also know that the helpful threads have often helped me - even though I have actually posted on them.

Elegran's OP sums it up well. If you think that at some time some small piece of information or support could help one or many of out fellow GNetters, please post and let GN know.

Yes, definitely a separate thread. Otherwise, information will get missed in the melée of other topics amongst the posts.

Yes, I think it’s a great idea, as previously discussed.

Yes please, for all the reasons already stated in the 4 pages which were in response to Pippa’s original post.

As Fanny says, yes, yes & yes. Seems like we are knocking on the door but nobody's in!

Yes, yes, yes ?

Yes good idea

I support the idea of somewhere to ask for, and give, advice about benefits.

'Benefits' as a separate topic would be best but if it has to be added onto 'Legal and Money' rather than stay without then okay.

There are already a lot of posts supporting this on the thread in 'Site Stuff', which is where GNHQ requested it be put to start with.
I hope they will not ignore that thread in favour of this one, which they have now asked for.

I don't know either why they wantd someone to start a new thread about it under the "Chat" topic, but now that there is one, they can hardly ignore what they themselves requested.

I think it highly likely that they don't have anyone inhouse who can do a change to the coding of the site. They probably have to outsource the work to a specialist organisation at vast expense. Sites are so complex now. Gone are the days when an amateur could run one up in an evening.

Better to have a separate Benefits header .

The Legal and Money section is a rag bag of topics on all manner of things. A look back through the recents: wills, inheritance, wages, buying and renting property, VAT and excise duty on EU purchases, TV licencing, Premium Bonds, car financing.

PippaZ’s idea of a separate section dedicated to Benefits is a much better idea imo. I have already posted at length on Pippa’s thread about this and really cannot understand why GN are resisting. It really is a minor adjustment that a competent programmer could deal with in not much time at all. I suspect they just don’t have anyone there who can actual do this small thing - just like all the other minor changes we have been asking for for a very long time. I just wish they would be upfront about what is going on.

I thi k it's a brilliant ide.

Yes please.
For all the reasons already explained in the original thread
Mon 20-Sep-21 21:42:53, Site Stuff
?

www.gransnet.com/forums/site_stuff/1301165-Would-it-be-an-idea-to-have-a-Benefits-Forum-on-the-list?msgid=28941606