Gransnet forums

Legal, pensions and money

'Proper' brands v Supermarket versions

(190 Posts)
PinkCosmos Mon 17-Oct-22 11:29:12

I suppose this relates to the previous post in this specific forum about supermarket prices going up. Sorry if this topic has been mentioned before.

Has anyone tried supermarket own brands (of anything) rather than 'proper' brands.

I have always used Fairy washing up liquid but the big bottle has just gone up to £3 ! I thought I should give the Asda own brand a try. It was a slightly smaller bottle but it was £1.

The Asda own brand is absolutely fine. I don't like the smell as much but it cleans just as effectively as the Fairy one.

This is something I would never do in the past as the own brands seemed to be a bit substandard years ago. For example, I would never use Aldi own brand washing powder.

I wondered if anyone else has experience of some good swaps

Riverwalk Tue 18-Oct-22 10:45:42

The cheaper brands of paracetamol can be harder to swallow - the tablets are chalky and catch at the back of the throat. I find the caplets (not capsules) are smoother and the shape makes them easier to swallow.

MissAdventure Tue 18-Oct-22 10:46:56

Unless they turn sideways on the way down. swallowing a log in

MissAdventure Tue 18-Oct-22 10:50:45

I haven't complained to Asda about online shop items, Riverwalk.

I shall have to give it a try, and see if they are as accommodating as Ocado.

I depends how my eyes are, and how greedy I'm feeling whether I do an online shop.

I am due to do one, I'm sure, and a kindly gransnetter gave me a kindle thing, so it is bigger and altogether better for online stuff. smile

Riverwalk Tue 18-Oct-22 11:03:59

MissAdventure

Unless they turn sideways on the way down. --swallowing a log in--

Like my horse pills cod liver oil capsules - they are huge and always turn sideways!

MissAdventure Tue 18-Oct-22 11:07:00

grin
I take zapain, and they are like trying to swallow a small sofa.

Riverwalk Tue 18-Oct-22 11:10:14

grin

Rosie51 Tue 18-Oct-22 11:17:45

I saw a short video, wish I could remember where, on swallowing tablets. The guy demonstrated that normally when we take tablets we toss our heads backwards to swallow. He said by tipping our heads forward to swallow the opening is bigger and the airway is closed and that would help with those choking episodes when it "goes down the wrong way" My blood pressure pills are tiny so I never have trouble with them, but will try it next time I'm swallowing a large round or preferably "log shaped" cure. smile

NotSpaghetti Tue 18-Oct-22 11:20:06

MissAdventure I hadn't really noticed that to be honest as I have only a known allergy to penicillin. I've googled excipients to see what they say and it looks like a minefield!
I'm not at all experienced in this area but I am an avid packet-reader and googler of any meds I'm taking. I know I'm OK with the wood-pulp cellulose that my paracetamols use for bulking for example but if anyone is interested here's a fascinating (and digestible) paper:

www.nps.org.au/australian-prescriber/articles/pharmaceutical-excipients-where-do-we-begin

NotSpaghetti Tue 18-Oct-22 11:21:47

MissAdventure

Unless they turn sideways on the way down. --swallowing a log in--

grin

Kate1949 Tue 18-Oct-22 11:27:02

Looking around here I realise that practically everything is own brand, with the exception of coffee and dairy free spread and one or two other things. Aldi washing powder is great.

SueDonim Tue 18-Oct-22 11:45:58

They say the proof of the pudding is in the eating - I’m not so sure about that! I realised this morning that I am currently eating branded Weetabix for breakfast. I would not have noticed that it was the genuine article without this thread to prompt me to look. I think I got it cheap in B&M but it’s no better or worse than any other make.

A tip for tablet-taking - take a good swallow of water immediately before the tablet, then quickly pop it in and wash down with more water. The initial gulp kind of primes your swallow reflex. It’s also a good way to help children get tablets down.

Gwenisgreat1 Wed 19-Oct-22 11:27:02

I use Aldi dish washer tablets instead of finish

JdotJ Wed 19-Oct-22 12:02:02

Asda baked beans are exactly the same as Branston baked beans. Yummy

pandapatch Wed 19-Oct-22 12:07:31

Zoejory

Marks and Spencer's Baked Beans are cheaper than Heinz and they are just divine.

I much prefer them to any other brand

Idunnsapple Wed 19-Oct-22 12:21:59

Waitrose Essentials pasta is very good. I do buy Italian brands, like Barilla, De Cecco etc when on offer, but more often Waitrose dried pasta. My son loves their fusilli.

Co-Op Earl Grey is the best of supermarket Earl Greys.

Witzend Wed 19-Oct-22 12:22:53

Asda’s Extra-Special 3 fruit marmalade is our favourite now.

annab275 Wed 19-Oct-22 12:27:29

Surely big brands are those that pay for advertising. I am not going to buy something just because someone on the TV gets paid to say it’s the best. With the way prices are going I am sticking to the basics and cooking from scratch

sandelf Wed 19-Oct-22 12:29:20

For 'good stuff' JS Taste the Difference - Tuna, tea bags etc. Often do buy JS basic (tinned spuds), Napolina tinned toms better than JS. Bought a JS version of Jif the other day as couldn't find Bar Keepers Friend - awful, scratches surfaces and doesn't remove stains! - Then found BKF in Savers for amazing price.

grandtanteJE65 Wed 19-Oct-22 12:32:47

I find it depends on which shop's own brands we are talking about, and which products.

I imagine the same applies in all countries, so it doesn't matter that I don't live in the UK.

Due to allergies, I only use one brand of washing powder and body shampoo, and don't experiment with others. I have, though, managed to find a "own brand" shampoo I can use.

Foodstuffs are usually substantially cheaper if you buy the supermarket's own brand, and but for a very few products the difference in taste or in quality is so little that it hasn't prevented us buying whatever it was again.

Theoddbird Wed 19-Oct-22 12:42:29

I always buy supermarket own brands. Many are made in same factories as the more expensive ones and often the same. One that really surprised me was Aldi Alcafe gold instant coffee. It is as good as the more expensive brands and half the price. I find most own brands as good as the expensive ones. I buy Tesco and Sainsbury's own brands. Have done for years. My favourite pizza is an Aldi one as are their red onion vegan sausages.

nanna8 Wed 19-Oct-22 12:43:06

Aldi chocolate is far better than Cadburys. Similar to Lindt, possibly made by them?

missdeke Wed 19-Oct-22 12:47:45

I find a lot of own brands are just as good/better than brands. The only thing I cannot find a decent substitute for is Kelloggs corn flakes. Mind you I no longer buy them as finding small size packs in the supermarkets is impossible.

The same goes for shampoos and conditioners etc, everything is family sized and when you live alone with very little storage space it makes evething more inconvenient.

Missiseff Wed 19-Oct-22 12:56:35

Why would you not buy Aldi washing powder? I use their liquid and it's brilliant

Milliedog Wed 19-Oct-22 13:03:47

Love this thread..

Diggingdoris Wed 19-Oct-22 13:06:35

My aunt went round a leading cereal factory and commented on the different supermarket boxes being filled as well as the main brand.
A few years back I know, but it stands to reason that I doubt each supermarket has its own cereal factory!