Loved the image cat-hurling. What's not to adore? 
But seriously!
USA full of people who are completely deluded that having guns in their house will help in the case of burglary, against all evidence to the contrary.
The only way a middle aged woman might fell a burglar with a baseball bat is if she managed to creep down the stairs without him noticing her and whack him from above - in which case MAW would be in big trouble.
3 examples from family members:
1. sister in law asleep in her mezzazine bedroom in Dublin micro flat. Someone broke into front door. She woke up and screamed down at him "What the F... are you doing in my house" he ran away with only one or two small items. (burglars are notoriously nervous)
2. MIL, quite fragile, woke to find young man trying to climb through her open bedroom window (the number of conversations i have had about the evils of open windows .... but she is firmly of the opinion that the house needs constant airing day and night) Again she shouted, he fell down (it was one of those small, at the top, windows that only agile skinny people could attempt). She then gets worried in case he is injured and struggles out on her walking frame to check!!!!! (he had run off) What IS she like?
3. another older relative who has a big 3 story house in london, woke to see reflection of man on stairs in her mirror. She kept extremely quiet. She was afraid her DH would wake up, tackle him and get hurt. Burglar took car and left. Nobody hurt. Good result I'd say.
The car is the single most valuable portable item and is commonly taken - some people recommend that you actually leave the car keys near the door so that burglars will find them and drive away, without causing any further problems.
I conclude that either yelling like a banshee or pretending to be asleep are the best strategies. And a phone near the bed.