Gransnet forums

News & politics

Jimmy Savile

(765 Posts)
merlotgran Mon 01-Oct-12 15:15:59

Do you believe the allegations that he groomed underage girls for sex and if so, do you hold accountable those in the media/BBC et al who heard rumours, had suspicions, saw evidence etc., but said nothing (probably to protect their careers)?

Personally, I always thought he was weird - even going back as far as schooldays when he was an up and coming DJ. I wouldn't have been at all surprised if all this had come out years ago and maybe it should.

Jendurham Wed 14-Nov-12 14:40:12

I am reading Alfie Boe's autobiography which was published before all this came to light.
In one chapter he writes of the naming ceremony of the Queen Victoria in Southampton dock. He and his wife were staying overnight on the boat and met Jimmy Savile sitting in an armchair on his own.
Savile said to Alfie's wife, "You're a pretty girl, aren't you. Come and sit on my knee," right in front of Alfie Boe.
He wrote it was cool to meet him, but weird when he started flirting with his wife. The next morning at breakfast Savile just scowled at them when Alfie said it was nice to meet him.
I wonder what Alfie Boe thinks now. It made me squirm to read it.

annodomini Wed 14-Nov-12 15:11:17

I wondered when the rumours about Cyril Smith would surface. There have been murmurings for many years. But who knows...

JessM Wed 14-Nov-12 15:25:17

Sigmund Freud chose not to believe his patients when they told him of sexual abuse. He constructed a complicated theory about childhood sexuality so that he could assert that it was all in the fevered imaginations of girls with an "oedipus complex". He influenced psychiatry immensely. sad

whenim64 Wed 14-Nov-12 15:35:39

The Cyril Smith murmurings were rife in Rochdale. Police did question him, but no action was taken againsst him. He admitted smacking boys on the bare bottoms when he had a hostel, claiming it was to make them get in the bath. I can't think of a single circumstance in which that would be necessary, and if boys only needed motivating to get in the bath themselves, why would he even need to be present when they were undressing?

annodomini Wed 14-Nov-12 16:10:46

There were some people for whom Cyril could do no wrong - I was not one of them. Some of his opinions were far from liberal (with or without a capital letter).

Elegran Thu 15-Nov-12 14:31:41

Oh good grief. Dave Lee Travis has been arrested next.

Anne58 Thu 15-Nov-12 15:16:39

Apparently is is not in connection with the Jimmy Savile enquiry.

Ana Thu 15-Nov-12 15:20:26

Not directly connected with JS but he is being investigated as one of several others named.

Elegran Thu 15-Nov-12 15:25:35

The DT headline said "as part of the J S sex probe" but in the actual article it said that paedophilia was not involved - he is accused of putting a hand up a 17 yr olds skirt in the 70s or 80s and something similar with another young woman. He says he is "genuinely surprised that allegations of this nature have been made" and he "totally refutes any impropriety"

Ella46 Thu 15-Nov-12 15:26:37

Seems to me that the police are just going for the easy targets!
I just hope they are working on the paedophiles too.

Anne58 Thu 15-Nov-12 15:30:51

Good grief, if I brought charges against every chap that put his hand up my skirt during the 70's & 80's...........

jO5 Thu 15-Nov-12 15:33:55

tell us more phoenix. smile

Anne58 Thu 15-Nov-12 15:35:33

Neither the time nor the place, methinks j05

jO5 Thu 15-Nov-12 16:05:06

Whoops! Have I done it again?! hmm

I'm really sick of all this murky stuff now. My head is going under a virtual duvet till it all goes away.

I know victims need closure, but they can do it without me reading about it.

numberplease Thu 15-Nov-12 17:32:21

Anno, I`m afraid that years ago I was one of those for whom Cyril Smith could do no wrong. I have very fond memories of him coming to our school Christmas carol service every year in Rochdale Town Hall, and seeing the 2 reserved chairs in the front row. I never heard any rumours about him until fairly recently, and was so disappointed and upset by them, never would have thought in a million years that such a thing could happen.

jeni Thu 15-Nov-12 18:31:06

We had a local GP and a solicitor who were always doing it! Both dead.

bookdreamer Thu 15-Nov-12 18:35:37

phoenix I agree. We just used to tell them to get lost.

mollie65 Fri 16-Nov-12 08:38:19

bookdreamer have to agree - groping and the like were not unheard of in the 60s and 70s in most work places - assume DJs were a little over ego-ed and thought they were God's gift to women. doubt that any woman has not been 'molested' in this way and I have to say it does not traumatise you for life. Children and hospital patients are an entirely different case and the perpetrators deserve to have the book thrown at them.
it all seems to much akin to a witch hunt

Nanadog Fri 16-Nov-12 09:15:27

Exactly Phoenix and * bookdreamer*

Nanadog Fri 16-Nov-12 09:17:08

Actually it was the (mid - late) 60s for me, but my skirts were so short anyway......

nanaej Fri 16-Nov-12 09:29:49

I think that it is so difficult to extract the real harm that youngsters suffered as a result of paedophile activity and the sexual fumblings of over ego-ed celebs and the 'groupies' who were flattered and keen to get involved.

I agree that some girls, with hindsight may regret what happened, but different to those youngsters who were not looking for anything sexual at all.

Greatnan Fri 16-Nov-12 09:30:27

I was always able to tell men to 'p*iss off', even when I was only a teenager, but I know some women who are put under pressure by their boss and one friend lost a good job because she wouldn't agree to the advances of her line manager. He gave her a very poor assessment which was totally undeserved, but she felt too demoralised to fight it.

Mishap Fri 16-Nov-12 11:56:02

Yes greatnan - a lot of that goes on. I was talking the other day to someone who worked in the BBC (as a freelance) and she found herself locked in the photocopier room with a randy manager. She's a big girl and she sorted him out - but....she is a freelance and it would be very simple for him to use someone else next time and freeze her out of lots of future work.

Riverwalk Fri 16-Nov-12 13:03:52

Ella46 I agree that the police seem to be going for the easier targets.

Boorish, ill-mannered creeps groping girls lower down the pecking-order at work, and celebrities taking advantage of teenagers is one thing - as gross as that is, is far removed from sadistic housemasters, priests, fathers, step-fathers who are systematically sexually abusing young children over many years.

FlicketyB Fri 16-Nov-12 16:09:01

The problem is it is very difficult to assess how some one will be affected by an event. A few years ago I was juror in a trial of historic 'sex abuse'. the girl was only 8 when it happened and it involved one brief non-penetrative grope and briefly showing pornographic magazines to this girl, plus another girl reported exposure and again being briefly shown pornographic magazines. There was no suggestion that anything more had happened or been repeated and it was clear the police had trawled very extensively for further victims and found none.

It was obvious from the evidence that the child in the first instance, now a young woman of about 30, had been deeply traumatised by the event and as jurors talking outside the jury room we concluded that the case had possibly arisen because the girl had sought counselling and Counsellors are obliged to report sex abuse to the police.. Yet having had similar brief and not repeated experiences as a child, I was unaffected by them and my daughter, who was similar in age to the girl was unable to understand why someone should have been so traumatised by what she considered was a relatively minor event. But the fact was that one child was severely traumatised by what might only temporarily puzzle or distress another child.