Gransnet forums

News & politics

Gransnet is right wing?

(159 Posts)
Nanadog Sat 10-Nov-12 23:39:03

Just come back from the local curry house where my DD, DiL and myself have our monthly girls night out. argument discussion arose about Mumsnet and Gransnet. Both DD and DiL declared thry would have nothing to go with Mumsnet as too right wing and (from a position of ignorance/assumption) castigated me for advocating GN declaring it to be right wing too.
Not so! Said I, in defence mode and thinking of greatnan, bags, myself and others we're definitely to the left of centre.
Was I right?

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 14:44:41

Health and or social security for me. Who for education foreign affairs etc (or are we going to be 'splendid isolationists" in which case no need for foreign affairs)
Do we have ministry of peace instead of so called defence?

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 14:45:26

jendurham Minister for Health?

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 14:47:01

Sorry jeni posts crossed. Will you accept Social Services?
Any takers for Minister of Peace? JO5!

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 14:47:42

Meant Social Security..

MiceElf Sun 11-Nov-12 15:02:20

I rather fancy being the minister for culture.

Jendurham Sun 11-Nov-12 15:04:38

What's wrong with the National Health Action party?
Run by doctors for all of us to get the NHS back again. Some people see it as a single issue party. However, the Tories in my view made a mistake by telling us all that GPs were capable of running huge budgets.
Many of them have more experience than Osborne had when he was made chancellor. He probably never even had any experience of accounting apart from signing his dad's wallpaper business accounts.
Headteachers also run huge budgets, so they could join forces to run the country.
Do any of you agree with Michael Gove's "back to when we were at school" ideas?

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 15:05:56

Ok that's miceElf sorted grin

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 15:38:15

Nanadog. I'd ADORE social security. Even I couldn't make a bigger mess of it than it is already!
Do you know they are changing the descriptors for ESA AGAIN! That's the third change since it started. Since that dratted ATOS can't apply the current one correctly heaven knows what they'll do with new ones. The appeal service will then have to juggle 4different systems. My poor old brain can't cope. I think I will retire!

Granny23 Sun 11-Nov-12 15:45:34

I have voted in every election since I was 21 and have always voted SNP. I joined the party in 1973 - since then it has moved steadily leftwards until it has nearly caught up with me!

The Westminster system is devised in such a way that new or minority parties have little or no influence (no big backers, denied PPBs or a place on debates or Question Time, seldom called at PMQs, ridiculed when they speak, etc.) and that will continue until there is proper proportional representation. PR is not in the best interests of the big two who would rather take their chances in the 'winner takes all' system. They are not too worried about an independent or small party candidate at an election because they would rather lose 1 vote or seat to the 'others' than to the opposition, which = 2 votes/seats lost in terms of overall majority.

The alternative is to join an existing party and work from within by creating an inhouse pressure group.

Good luck to the new (virtual) party - I would suggest SENORITY as the name grin

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 15:46:35

I don't think I'm left-wing enough for this party! wink

Greatnan Sun 11-Nov-12 16:30:30

Come on, Ana, you could have an input into our constitution! I propose Bags as Minister for Science and Technology, and Soop as Minister for Peace.

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 16:56:41

I like that Seniority
jeni sorted
ana how about heading up the new Ministry of Common Sense
greatnan proposals accepted subject to their agreement.

We need some more volunteers and more Ministries.

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 17:12:01

Ana minister for women's affairs

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 17:14:17

Women's affairs? What are you implying, jeni? grin

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 17:18:23

Not that you'd had affairs. But that you seem well balanced and sensible .

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 17:21:06

Thank you....I think!

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 17:25:09

smile

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 17:31:48

Ministry of Wonder and Awe.
Ministry of Food, Drink, Fishing and Partying.
Ministry of Men
Ministry of Woodlands and Ash Trees
Ministry of Celts
Ministry of Disarmament

Any volunteers?

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 17:33:31

Like the list!

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 17:34:12

Oh! Don't forget ministry of magic.

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 17:34:13

Well, if we'd known those options were available....! grin

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 17:44:45

Ministry of Magic is a must

Still time to bagsy a position. ana

Ministry of Much Ado About Nothing

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 18:22:59

Oh and the famous 'Ministry of silly walks' mr 15/12month DGD is already qualified for that post!

Mishap Sun 11-Nov-12 18:37:07

Right-wing? - not the forum that's for sure!

annodomini Sun 11-Nov-12 18:41:53

Can I be chief whip? I think it would suit my temperament. grin