Gransnet forums

News & politics

Gransnet is right wing?

(159 Posts)
Nanadog Sat 10-Nov-12 23:39:03

Just come back from the local curry house where my DD, DiL and myself have our monthly girls night out. argument discussion arose about Mumsnet and Gransnet. Both DD and DiL declared thry would have nothing to go with Mumsnet as too right wing and (from a position of ignorance/assumption) castigated me for advocating GN declaring it to be right wing too.
Not so! Said I, in defence mode and thinking of greatnan, bags, myself and others we're definitely to the left of centre.
Was I right?

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 18:44:10

Sadist!

Mamie Sun 11-Nov-12 18:52:07

Just like to point out that they have been Departments and not Ministries for a very long time. Wouldn't like anyone to think we were a bunch of out of touch old dears.
Clearly, after a lifetime working in education, I know far too much to be Secretary of State.... hmm

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 19:09:52

Well I still work for the ministry of justice. Which ironically seems to be the only people allowed to practice age discrimination.

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 20:31:17

Good point Mamie and besides it sounds too 'old boy' ...there isn't a feminine of 'ministry' is there, any more than there is a feminine of 'pope' but I digress. Department is too French methinks.
I'm clean out of inspiration.

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 20:54:44

The chamber of the red/green/purple/ orange/etc wax!
It means as much as the titles of any admin org does!

london Sun 11-Nov-12 21:19:40

i all so worked 4 education smile school meals 30 years but sorry im lost of with politics and this thread xx

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 21:43:48

Don't worry London. It's gone mad! As some of our threads tend to.
It annoys those who want to be TERRIBLY SERIOUS!
But those of us with zany or surrealistic senses of humour can't resist.

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 21:44:35

grin

jeni Sun 11-Nov-12 21:50:45

Night all moon

Ana Sun 11-Nov-12 21:55:51

Night jeni moon

london Sun 11-Nov-12 22:02:30

night all from me to x

Nanadog Sun 11-Nov-12 22:55:53

Night all moon

Joan Mon 12-Nov-12 05:49:13

I was brought up in a politically opinionated family; any opinion about anything was OK as long as you could justify it through logic. Most of us were left-wing; at the age of around 12, I decided to be a conservative just to oppose my parents, but could not find any justification. I ended up further left than them in some ways. One brother was a bit to the Right, but came back to the Left after Thatcher.

I believe that thinking people often belong to the left of centre, because it is more logical imho! At our age, most of us will have learned that extreme politics in any direction are pointless - they just cause misery. I have Tory friends, and enjoy a bit of political banter with them.

When still in England and living in Ossett with my husband, we had some older family friends who were conservatives, and old Dennis used to take us for a drink at the local conservative club, which was a few doors down from our house. He would openly say "I've brought my socialist mates in for a drink", and we'd get drinks bought from all quarters!

When working in polling booths at elections, party workers from all of the political spectrum get on well, share sandwiches and a few laughs. The only exception was in the late 1990s when we had a far-right racist party called 'Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party'. They talked politics (a no-no among booth workers) and got nasty with other party members. In the end they got the cold shoulder from everyone.

Political banter - bring it on - it's fun!!

POGS Sun 25-Nov-12 23:38:41

Personally I tend to lean to the right of politics, as I am sure some GN's may have noticed. grin

However, I hope I am mature enough to leave the politics of bias where it belongs, out of my mind. If an idea is wrong then I would say so, likewise if I feel something is a good valid point I would say so, irrespective of whichever party has said it. That point does not however come over very well when you are answering a thread in favour of one party but if people waited they may see you commented favourably against that party on a different subject later on. I know I have jumped too quickly in the past to 'sound off' so I fully appreciate that is easier said than done. It only comes if GN's don't judge too quickly what they make of fellow GN's.

I do really hate the politics of spin and hypocrisy, sadly that applies to all parties and the majority of their die hard supporters.

I dislike it though when someone makes a snide, obvious politically biased retort to a perfectly reasonable comment made by someone of a different political view. This childish behaviour only stops a thread from progressing with intelligent debate or, as in some cases, does make the poster feel they are intruding in a sort of a one party forum.

Why does it have to be so clear cut which party you support. Isn't there a serious point of watching, listening and making a judgement call as to who you support at that time?. I like to think I am not particularly 'shackled' to a party and would vote for them even if I thought they were bad for the country or my town .

The ideal party for me would be a bit of a 'mix and match'. That will never happen so I appreciate the naivity of that comment, just wishful thinking on my part.

The word 'lurkers' is often used on threads and I believe a lot of GN's choose to keep to the old saying, 'Never talk about politics or religion'. That doesn't mean they are not interested in either subject, they probably can't be bothered to argue their case nor find it a worthwhile pursuit disagreeing with those who are not interested in listening to another point of view. No more no less than that.

absentgrana Mon 26-Nov-12 08:28:00

I understand that current membership of Gransnet is now about 15,000 – double what it was when last mentioned a year or so ago. It stands to reason, given that this is not specifically a political site, that members' views will cover a wide range, including no interest at all in politics. In addition, there are plenty of people who post on forums and threads that are unlikely to touch on political matters, such as knitting, weekly weigh in and the one about physical exercise, and don't post on other threads. It always surprises me when I have been kidding myself that I am familiar with the names of most regular posters and I stray into a forum that I don't often access – loads of completely unfamiliar names busily posting away on – yes – a regular basis. In other words, I think it would be idiotic to suggest that Gransnet is right wing, left wing or bat wing.

Nanadog Mon 26-Nov-12 12:34:49

Yes, but absent isn't (aren't?) most of those JO under some of her reincarnations? confused

JessM Mon 26-Nov-12 12:53:14

What, talking to herself about knitting? Surely not! grin (no offence meant!)

absentgrana Mon 26-Nov-12 12:56:43

Nanadog grin

JessM I think she quite often holds conversations with herself – but perhaps not about knitting.

glitabo Mon 26-Nov-12 13:53:16

I consider myself to be a socialist but I find no affinity with the labour party.
I would definitely join the GN party. I would like to work in the department for -the vulnerable citizens the underdog.
I also think there should be a continuity division which is non party political to include, health, education and justice.

Greatnan Mon 26-Nov-12 13:53:21

I am very clear which party I would support - none of them! I am totally disillusioned and whilst I feel sorry for those MPs who genuinely want to serve their fellow men I am beginning to believe that most of them are in it to feather their nests and make sure they get cushy jobs when they retire.

Joan Wed 05-Dec-12 07:36:02

I'm inclined to agree, Greatnan.

I'm dyed-in-the-wool socialist, but find both the UK Labour Party and the Australian one are letting the true believers down.

lionlilac Wed 05-Dec-12 19:57:45

Really miss Old Labour. Loved Michael Foot.

vampirequeen Thu 06-Dec-12 05:06:49

We need to change the way candidates are elected. We shouldn't let them go from university to Westminster researcher to candidate. We need MPs who have lived in the real world for a period of time.

Greatnan Thu 06-Dec-12 07:13:01

I agree, VQ, but it sometimes seems that the Westminster environment corrupts even the most down-to-earth arrivals - like John Prescott.

vampirequeen Thu 06-Dec-12 08:12:12

Omg don't get me started on the class traitor lol.