Gransnet forums

News & politics

Women Bishops - synod rejects again

(114 Posts)
JessM Tue 20-Nov-12 18:50:50

Disgraceful rejection of women bishops. If we have to have bishops in the House of Lords at least let some of them be women!

JessM Wed 21-Nov-12 06:57:58

I guess the dinosaur brigade have been politicking away, getting themselves seats on synod, while the sane majority have not.
Twenty years of ordaining women priests and the sky does not appear to have fallen - but none of them can become bishops. I remember Anne Widdecome (sp?) (who on earth is that woman!!!) being interviewed and saying she was going to leave the Anglican church over it.
I reckon amend the religious category exemption from the sex discrimination act and let em sue! But can you imagine the ruffled feathers that would cause in other forms of religions (nearly all of them sexist to the core) so no government would do that.

Joan Wed 21-Nov-12 06:37:08

Oh dear - what utter dinosaurs! When I first read about the lost vote, i assumed it was blokes voting against it, men who imagined their balls would drop off if women got the power they deserve. But women!! They are the uncle, I mean auntie Toms of the gender battle. Whimps!

Mamie Wed 21-Nov-12 06:12:24

At least we all get a chance to practise spelling disestablishmentarianism... smile

Bags Wed 21-Nov-12 06:03:30

Comment in the Guardian reckons the CofE has just committed suicide. What a bunch of prejudiced nitwits it is, that synod thing. Pompous twits.

JessM Wed 21-Nov-12 05:29:27

So this is what it takes to break the self-imposed ban on naughty words in GN! grin

Nanadog Tue 20-Nov-12 23:46:24

Time I went to sleep !!! Night all moon

Anne58 Tue 20-Nov-12 23:44:55

Spouse accent, love it! [grin}

Ana Tue 20-Nov-12 23:42:52

A spouse accent! grin That's a new one....

Nanadog Tue 20-Nov-12 23:35:54

WIRDS = WORDS ...said with a spouse accent ( only I'm not..a Mickey Mouser that is)

Nanadog Tue 20-Nov-12 23:34:18

anno of course, that makes sense.
phoenix I have over the course of the last three months since I joined GN appreciated your posts and your way with wirds. Never more though that just now.

I'm off to sleep with a smile inside. grin moon

Anne58 Tue 20-Nov-12 23:26:41

Thank you Nanadog luckily I didn't see the stupid cow who has probably set progress back by decades lady mentioned, but I stand by my stand (!) on this, why should the damn church be exempt from laws just because it's always been that way!

DOUBLE SHIT BUGGER ARSEHOLE ETC, PLUS OTHER WORDS

annodomini Tue 20-Nov-12 23:23:02

grin nanad, radio 4 on in bathroom while performing morning ablutions.

Nanadog Tue 20-Nov-12 23:17:45

You have a TV in the shower anno?

Joking aside I too wanted to throttle her. It wasn't just her inane remarks but the smug and beatific expression on her face that made me angry

Love your SBABWP phoenix grin

isthisallthereis Tue 20-Nov-12 23:14:14

This disgraceful result will do the C of E a lot of harm, making it look ridiculous and totally out of touch. I am very embarrassed, very angry and very shocked. I seriously thought it would go through this time. Do we really have another 10 years or more of this nonsense to go through? There are so many much more pressing and serious things to debate. There should be no question about women bishops. We need them. As with women priests, they will be entirely a good thing.

merlotgran Tue 20-Nov-12 23:01:32

phoenix. grin You could get excommunificated for that.

Anne58 Tue 20-Nov-12 22:55:25

wisewoman that has made me very, very angry I'm not a violent person, but that comment up there ^ makes me want to get hold of that woman, give her a damn good shaking, tie her to a chair and make her watch videos that show exactly how there are households that are NOT run by men, "Oh goodness me, are there really some women who can function without a man?* [fit of the vapours emoticon]

And maybe also draw the daft cows attention that women do now actually have the vote and the intelligence to use it!

Oh, and of course, male priests are ALL pillars of the community, whose word is law.

I'm about to indulge in a really good swear, please look away now if you don't want to see the result:

Shit bugger arsehole bugger wank poo.

So there.

annodomini Tue 20-Nov-12 22:46:08

wisewoman, I nearly drowned in the shower when I heard her saying that! shock

Grandola Tue 20-Nov-12 22:38:17

I feel so sad about this decision. [Sad] But I'm also confused.confused How can just a few people overturn a decision that was agreed by the clergy themselves? It's totally bonkers! How demoralising for the women who are clearly capable of taking on such roles - how belittling and how discriminatory. God must be shedding tears over the sorry mess.

wisewoman Tue 20-Nov-12 22:09:48

I heard a woman lay member of the synod interviewed on BBC and she said these words "Male priests should be ultimate authority in the church as fathers are the ultimate authority in the home." I swear she said this in 2012 on the BBC. I was speechless.

Ana Tue 20-Nov-12 22:04:31

I think that's a very good point, petallus.

merlotgran Tue 20-Nov-12 22:01:17

OK, petallus, who have you got in mind. The priest from The Thorn Birds or Ballykissangel?

JessM Tue 20-Nov-12 21:34:35

pretty resounding unanimous horror then?

Anne58 Tue 20-Nov-12 20:49:32

I think that women priests are far less likely to find themselves arrested, as certain others of the cloth have been very recently!

I wish someone could explain why the church is allowed to actively discriminate, where other organisations could be prosecuted.

Even some job advertisements have to show a sort of disclaimer, for example one I saw recently for a supermarket check out job stated that they had been allowed dispensation with regard to age discrimination laws, as because alcohol was sold, all till operatives had to be over 18.

petallus Tue 20-Nov-12 20:40:41

I suspect that for some women, male priests are romantic authority figures. Different dynamic if the priest is a woman.

Granny23 Tue 20-Nov-12 20:36:48

Women - know your place!

UN- BE- LIEVE- ABLE angry