Gransnet forums

News & politics

Charity tax avoidance

(26 Posts)
Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 05:53:37

Charities avoid paying tax as well as companies and corporations. Who, apart from me, isn't surprised? Who, apart from me, thinks tax laws needs to be changed so as to deter tax avoidance? Who thinks it's time corporation-creep-afflicted charities were brought to book the same way as the capitalist corporations they have copied? #justaskin

It's the rules that are at fault as much as the users of them.

baubles Thu 31-Jan-13 07:24:33

The people at the head of charities aren't necessarily more 'moral' than those at the head of any other big business and if the rules allow such tax avoidance, it will continue to happen.

The rules governing payment of tax have to change, so no, I'm not surprised.

janeainsworth Thu 31-Jan-13 09:02:03

Bags You can only see bits of the articles if you don't have a Timesonline subscription.
I've never heard of the Cup Trust, although it says it attracts more donations that the British heart Foundation and other leading charities.
Am I right in thinking this Trust is an organisation that pretends to be a charity, making meagre donations, so that wealthy investors can benefit form its charitable status?
Is there evidence that well-known charities abuse their charitable status?
After all there is a reason for charities enjoying their beneficial tax status - we wouldn't want to donate to a worthwhile cause in good faith, out of our taxed income, and then have the government take yet more tax out of, would we?

Just asking because I can't read the article.

Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 09:29:21

Here is some info about the Cup Trust. I hadn't heard of it before either.

Mey Thu 31-Jan-13 09:58:05

The reality of it all is, that lots of individuals and companies would avoid tax and try to find ways to avoid paying tax, they see it as a means to survival.

I dont think that charities should pay tax at all.

Mey Thu 31-Jan-13 10:01:37

liked your little diagram bags you are indeed a very hafficient person and a value to GN I know I spelt it wrong thats how I say it smile

Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 10:22:06

mey smile. I like the idea that I'm hafficient but it's not my diagram. Someone else deserves the credit. I just found it.

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 10:52:18

It would be disgraceful if the government took money from charities!!! Charities save them loads of money as it is. (think the St Mungo's thing for just one eg)

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 10:53:45

I wonder if Gransnet has indulged in tax avoidance by hooking up with Age Concern.

No! Of course not!

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 10:58:14

the cup trust Not the best of websites.

janeainsworth Thu 31-Jan-13 10:59:32

But the Cup Trust is clearly not a genuine charity is it?
And unless I am mistaken, it is the individual investor who is avoiding tax by getting the tax relief on their bogus 'donation.
Cup Trust is the facilitator, and make their money from the fee paid to them by the investor.
Is anyone suggesting that genuine charities like Age Concern wheel and deal in Gilts to enable their contributors to avoid tax?

Or have I completely misunderstood?

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 11:00:41

I can't do that diagram. I've got a cold. They do sound dodgy though. So is The Times for having a firewall. hmm

janeainsworth Thu 31-Jan-13 11:00:46

Didn't see your post about Gransnet being pally with Age Concern j07 before I posted

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 11:01:41

You can't tar all charities by that brush. Just do something about the Cup Trust. (which I'd never heard of before)

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 11:02:18

That's alright janeainsworth. Probably just as well if no one sees it. grin

Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 11:04:56

I belive Cup Trust has charitable status (i.e. is technically a charity) even if it isn't what most of us would regard as a proper charity. I expect there are more like it.
inagist.com/all/296762568792494080/

j07 Thu 31-Jan-13 11:06:28

Bloody Times should drop its firewall for a day. Might do a bit of good then. hmm

janeainsworth Thu 31-Jan-13 11:09:25

Yes j07.
They should perhaps report things accurately as well hmm

Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 11:11:48

Bloody Times should drop its paywall, full stop hmm

Bags Thu 31-Jan-13 11:12:50

Accurate reporting? Haha!

sorry

but...

Eloethan Fri 22-Feb-13 01:12:28

Apart from Oxfam, which I believe spends only about 10% of its income on administration (staff salaries, etc.), I have some concerns about charities. Am I right in thinking that many independent schools are classified as charities?

Many charities spend huge amounts on administrative costs. After seeing a documentary a couple of years ago concerning The London Marathon I decided I wouldn't continue sponsoring people for it.

Greatnan Fri 22-Feb-13 05:04:46

I am a retired tax inspector and perused the accounts of many well known charities. Suffice it so say, I don't contribute to any of them. I can't give any more details, as I am bound by the Official Secrets Act.

Eloethan Tue 26-Feb-13 15:25:28

Greatnan - What you say is worrying - and (not for the first time) seems to back up what my husband says. What a shame you can't say any more.

There seem to be thousands of charities and I don't suppose many of us know exactly how they operate and what happens to the money donated to them. Time for a bit more investigative journalism I think.

granjura Tue 26-Feb-13 17:28:31

I thought charities were exempt from tax? I certainly do believe that it is wrong for so called public schools where parents pay £10.000 + a term to be exempt.

Greatnan Tue 26-Feb-13 19:39:14

Public schools are supposed to contribute to the well being of the community at large! Most give a few bursaries or scholarships.