Gransnet forums

News & politics

Body in hotel water tank

(45 Posts)
Bags Sun 10-Mar-13 08:01:53

Haven't this couple already received 'compensation' in the form of immediate financial help from third parties? Why are there negotiations with Thos Cook for compensation? It's not the travel agency's fault there was a body in the hotel water tank. Maybe Cooks are expecting compensation from the hotel.

Weird.

If someone helped me out in a situation ike this, so that I could finish my holiday in comfort (especially more comfort), I think I'd feel sufficiently compensated already.

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:36:53

Well, jane, necessity being the mother of invention, I live in hope that we will find a solution to such problems where there is a high risk of infection such as during and after childbirth and other times when there are deep internal wounds, or even easily infected external ones.

Maggots.

Alcohol.

Something we haven't discovered yet.

Meanwhile, I still think we are getting over worried about little every day things that rarely cause any problems.

annodomini Mon 11-Mar-13 10:38:19

A friend's son contracted necrotising fasciitis when he sustained an open wound while water skiing in fresh water in Cheshire. Only quick thinking by an A&E medic who recognised it, saved his leg and possibly his life.

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:40:17

Ski-ing in open water.... so there were boats on it (pollution), and there will have been things living in it and dying in it and rotting in it.

Not a mountain stream, then.

I am not advocating drinking water out of lakes that people use for leisure activities.

Good grief. Some perspective, please!

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:41:23

Not straight out of, at any rate. Might be OK boiled.

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:41:37

wink

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:42:43

Or passed through the right kind of water filter. I'm not talking about those lime removing ones that southerners use (I did too in Oxon).

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 10:47:23

But I give up. I'm going to bring some wood in. I will take precautions so as not to get cuts on my hands or splinters. Gloves it's called. But even if I do sustain such an injury, the risk of anything nasty that my immune system can't cope with will be small. Trying to avoid every risk to perfect health is silly and obsessive as well as impossible.

JessM Mon 11-Mar-13 18:59:05

You are right about the tap water bags it is not sterile and it is fine for most purposes inc washing grazes. people boil it for baby's bottles but the chances of them catching anything from tap water in this country are minimal.

No reason to think we have immunity to either cryptosporidium or giardia unless we have had an infection maybe?

www.wales.nhs.uk/sitesplus/888/page/44044 - watery diarrhoea for a month? - no thanks
www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Giardiasis/Pages/Symptoms.aspx - two years of diarrhoea???? no thanks again. These are not trivial diseases.

janeainsworth Mon 11-Mar-13 19:42:12

And Bags you could pay a heavy price for playing the bagpipes apparently wink
www.thescottishsun.co.uk/scotsol/homepage/news/4835558/OAP-John-Shone-catches-bug-from-bagpipes.html

Bags Mon 11-Mar-13 19:48:37

Blimey, jane, whatever next?!

Galen Mon 11-Mar-13 20:30:26

I think it's because they put honey into them?

Tegan Mon 11-Mar-13 20:34:53

Of course, if my manuka is substandard I can't even depend on the placebo effect sad.

Greatnan Mon 11-Mar-13 22:17:26

I refuse to panic about bacteria/germs - I have survived for 72 years and even when travelling in Third World Countries have never had more than one short bout of a stomach upset in Egypt. My mother had a relaxed attitude towards hygiene, and I believe I have developed a robust immune system. I would far rather risk the water in the high mountains where I live than risk getting dehydrated again, which happened once when I got lost in the forest, without water, and had to walk in very hot weather for about six hours. My bp dropped to about 65/50.
I do carry water purification tablets, but I have never used them in the Alps. ]
I wouldn't drink water from a standing lake or pool, especially one used by boats.
The children who are 'detolloed' to the nth degree are the ones most likely to succumb to illness.

Galen Mon 11-Mar-13 23:08:47

Ditto! I've never bothered with bottled water either! When I was in Venice at about 18/12 old I was given watered wine as the water wasn't safe! I've continued with that but without the watergrin

Nelliemoser Mon 11-Mar-13 23:10:55

Bags many years ago I was very sick after drinking from a stream high up in in Glencoe. But I have no real evidence the incidents were related.

Our bodies are generally well able to resist loads of potentially infectious agents. cuts grazes etc etc.

Yet again I will say. "Blame the advertisers for this obsession with germs" Don't constantly use bacteriacidal sprays on work surfaces. Good hot soapy water does fine.

Greatnan Tue 12-Mar-13 02:14:08

And you don't need special cream for your underarm skin, or douches for your 'intimate areas'. Manufacturers are adept at creating a demand where none exists.

absent Tue 12-Mar-13 06:49:45

Greatnan Like the makers of Listerine – originally a disinfectant for floors and other hard surfaces – inventing a condition called halitosis (not that people didn't sometimes have smelly breath).

JessM Tue 12-Mar-13 07:16:16

Or, my pet hate, antibacterial wipes. angry
It is easy for us though to feel confident in our immune systems. They are magnificent. A miracle of evolution on a par with the brain.
But our generation has been the most disease free in history. Go back to your grandmothers' times and there was no child vaccination, high rates of TB and no antibiotics - infections of all kinds were very common. Their wonderful immune systems did not always prevail. Microbes evolve more quickly than ours.
There is also the point that our immune systems do age. This is why pneumonia becomes common in the long lived. Keep carrying those water purification tablets greatnan.
Our chief medical officer was talking about the threat of antibiotic resistance - people in 200 years may also see us as the most infection free generation in history.

janeainsworth Tue 12-Mar-13 07:58:57

Absent don't get me started on Listerine.
However, halitosis is not an invented symptom - it is real and shouldn't be ignored, the commonest cause being moderate to advanced periodontal (gum)disease which if left untreated will lead to loss of teeth.