Gransnet forums

News & politics

school children in nappies

(43 Posts)
ninathenana Thu 01-May-14 23:02:04

This was a main stream school. I am fully aware that some special needs children are still in nappies in late childhood and some for life.

As I said I'm not going to argue the rights and wrongs of children starting school in nappies. I just can't see how this sits with the 'no touch policy'
The article states 'head teachers are legally obliged to accept children whether toilet trained or not'

durhamjen Thu 01-May-14 22:48:00

My grandson goes with me to pick up his sister from primary school. He hugs teachers, male and female, and they hug him. Children with ASD do not behave appropriately for each situation, so it's impossible to stop him.

Nelliemoser Thu 01-May-14 22:39:53

Holding the baby out over a pot was that was Truby King style child rearing.

It's the mum that is trained there not the child.

Flowerofthewest Thu 01-May-14 22:02:55

My DS insists that she 'trained' all of her children to use the potty from a few weeks old. Absolute nonsense but you try telling her. She swears she never had a dirty nappy in all three of her children. Poor little souls hanging over a pot at 8 weeks old.

We were told to give 'appropriate ' hugs to children if they needed comforting. Side by side with an arm around the shoulder. The problem is that with a lot of children with LD they plonk themselves on your lap and hug you for all they are worth and very rewarding it is too. I always returned the hugs from children or adults with LD whom I worked with. They have often experienced enough rejection without me adding to it.

Purpledaffodil Thu 01-May-14 21:32:53

Penstemmon I do agree re the spontaneous hug. As a retired teacher, I often get such hugs when I go into my old school. Because I am female and a grandmother, I have no problem in returning the hugs, but I know it is not the same for male teachers. A dear friend was even advised to look at the ceiling when he was supervising Year 3 boys getting changed for swimming. Some schools even operate a 'no touch' policy for all which must be so hard when a child is upset or hurt. What a strange society we are becoming!

Purpledaffodil Thu 01-May-14 21:23:12

The current view is that there is a hormone which kicks in and stops children needing nappies at night. This was total news to me, but others might have an opinion? It also seems that the age for potty training gets later with each generation. My MIL assured me that my husband was potty trained by a year and that she used to put him back to front on the loo, so that he could hold onto the pipe and not fall down through the seat. Hmmmm? In the eighties the thinking was that they had to be two to have control. Now three seems to be the accepted age in my daughter's circle.
I agree with previous posters about the relative comfort of modern disposables re soggy terry towelling. Also our toddlers had huge padded rear ends, not the natty streamlined ones they get with modern nappies. Aesthetics alone made us want to get them into pantsgrin

rosesarered Thu 01-May-14 20:59:25

My DGS who has autism was in nappies until the age of 7. He started out at a primary school where they were prepared to change him, and since then has attended special needs schools where they are very used to this. Although not in nappies now, he needs an adult with him sometimes when he has to go to the loo.
Children [who don't have autism or any disabilities at all] now start primary school at 4 years old which is very young, and they are expected to take themselves to the loo and of course not be in nappies.That extra year from being 4 to being five can make all the difference in lots of ways, and I wish they had not changed it , 5 years old is time enough to start school.

Penstemmon Thu 01-May-14 20:46:39

We have had this discussion before. The number of children starting in school nurseries (3+) and direct into Reception classes still in nappies has increased. This is due to an increase in the number of children with SEND attending mainstream school and also because some parents are leaving it later to toilet train, (I do think the ease of disposables has contributed to this !) I was in a hurry to get rid of the nappy bucket with its stew of Terry nappies and napisan!

It is difficult for schools to get it right. Only today I was at the school where I am a governor. There a young lad comes into run a sports activity. He is popular with the children and one little girl (6/7 yrs) spontaneously ran up to him and gave him a welcome hug. He had to put his hands in the air so as not to be seen to be being 'inappropriate' I find this very sad. However there are parents who would be paranoid enough to bring a complaint if he had simply and briefly returned the hug equally spontaneously.
What would be your response?

Aka Thu 01-May-14 20:03:01

NP Ana I just recognised the policy as one which is fairly standard in Special Schools I used to work with.

Ana Thu 01-May-14 19:58:29

Sorry, Aka - I just googled and thought it looked appropriate for the thread, but I was wrong.

The school my DGDs attend has a policy of not accepting children still in nappies. I don't know how strictly they enforce this, or what arrangements are made for disabled children. If a child has an toilet-related accident a parent is phoned to come and either change them or take them home.

merlotgran Thu 01-May-14 19:51:50

DS used to crawl out of his nappy like a snail shedding its shell. grin

Aka Thu 01-May-14 19:50:24

I think this is a Special Needs Academy for 5-11 year olds.

Grannyknot Thu 01-May-14 19:09:45

Unless a child has special needs, surely they should not be using nappies at 5 to 6 years of age shock

We are friendly with a couple whose 5 year old is still in nappies and I have wondered whether the modern, comfortable 'stay dry' nappies haven't contributed to this state of affairs. There is no trigger of discomfort due to a wet nappy, and therefore no impetus for change. Just a thought! Especially as I remember my 2 sometimes pulling at their sodden towelling nappies clearly having noticed that they are uncomfortable.

Flowerofthewest Thu 01-May-14 18:51:59

I also was going to suggest that children with disabilities, physical or learning, may need to be changed. I know that schools for children with these problems have nappy changing and even bathing facilities. The are necessary and are there for the benefit of all. May it is because many children with disabilities do attend mainstream now.

Ana Thu 01-May-14 18:08:08

I'm confused now! Nina did the article give any information about the school the teacher was talking about...?

Nelliemoser Thu 01-May-14 18:01:10

I would have thought all schools should now be equipped with full facilities for disabled pupils or trying to get them.
Schools are taking more children with physical disabilities, (they always used to be shunted off to "special schools" for the physically disabled); There are likely to be more children needing the facilities to deal with such issues.

This is not just an issue about parents who have not bothered to get the children potty trained.

There will always be kids that have the odd accident, but this does not does not excuse the parents who have never put in the effort to get their children toilet trained in the first place.

Ana Thu 01-May-14 16:57:56

Here's one school's policy - I must admit I was surprised!

www.woolgrove.herts.sch.uk/information/policies/changingnappies.pdf

ninathenana Thu 01-May-14 16:47:16

I'm not starting a thread trying to apportion blame.
I'm wondering when it became permissible for teachers to be this intimate with 5-6 yr olds. I have just read an article about a teacher who returned to school for a new term, to discover she now had a new annex specifically for nappy changing shock
When DS was in reception class he fell in the playground and badly grazed his knee. Because he was wearing long trousers the first aider called me in to school because she was not permitted to pull his trousers down to access the wound. I did wonder at the time why she hadn't sent him to the loo to change into his gym shorts confused