Gransnet forums

News & politics

Has identity politics replaced that of social class?

(55 Posts)
thatbags Sat 02-May-15 19:57:08

James Bloodworth seems to think it has and he doesn't seem to keen on the idea.

durhamjen Sun 03-May-15 16:45:50

Because there's not much production anymore.

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 16:46:31

*FlicketyB" Russell Brand has, as promised, used the proceeds from his book "Revolution" to open a cafe - Trew Era Cafe - in Hoxton, a non-profit making business employing recovering addicts. Outside is a "Kindness Offensive" bus offering free toys under the "Random Acts of Kindness" scheme. I expect that will elicit a huge amount of hilarity from the "I Hate Russell Brand/All Socialists are Hypocrits" crew - and perhaps it is misguided and perhaps it won't work out - but at least he's having a go at doing things differently.

durhamjen Sun 03-May-15 16:50:17

As do many people in the spotlight, Eloethan. It's just they do not crow about it all the time.

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 16:55:17

What durhamjen? - are you saying Russell Brand is "crowing" about what he does? If so, how many people on Gransnet were aware the he had ploughed all his profits from his "Revolution" book into opening a cafe employing recovering addicts? Have I misunderstood you?

Ana Sun 03-May-15 16:59:52

He didn't exactly keep it quiet. The opening of the café was widely reported in the media at the time.

Ana Sun 03-May-15 17:01:03

Together with the fact that the profits from 'Revolution' had been used for the enterprise.

whitewave Sun 03-May-15 17:10:42

It doesn't really matter though whether he shouted it from the roof tops the point is he has an idea and energy (more than enough if everything is to be believed!) and they are out there in the social sphere with something like 10 million followers so not everyone thinks he is misguided.

Ana Sun 03-May-15 17:17:01

I agree, whitewave, there's no reason at all why he shouldn't publicise his efforts. He doesn't seem the type to hide his light under a bushel!

janeainsworth Sun 03-May-15 17:19:27

Well I didn't know about it, but it sounds amazing and well done him.
As for publicising it, that's justified because other people may follow his example - social reinforcement. And be more sympathetic to recovering addicts.
I've sometimes argued with MrA about sharing charity donations I make on Facebook. He doesn't like it because he thinks it's boasting about giving money away. My argument is that it raises awareness, particularly of smaller charities that people might not have heard of, and might then feel they would like to make a donation themselves.

janeainsworth Sun 03-May-15 17:23:57

jen I think 'production' now includes the financial and service industries - anything which brings money into the economy.
Perhaps that's why class divisions aware now so indistinct.
All those financial whizz kids working in the city, and anyone treating someone from overseas in a private hospital, would have to be regarded as working class.

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 17:31:11

Well, I'm a great supporter of Russell Brand - naive and simplistic he may be but I think his heart is in the right place. It was my husband who alerted me to the fact that, as promised, RB had - using the proceeds of his book - opened a cafe staffed by recovering addicts. I hadn't seen reports of it on TV or in the papers.

As a matter of interest, who on Gransnet had seen reports on TV/in the papers that Russell Brand had opened a cafe for recovering addicts?

Ana Sun 03-May-15 17:34:10

I did. And a quick google reveals that it was reported in most of the daily newspapers. It was probably on the BBC news as well.

thatbags Sun 03-May-15 18:15:15

Excellent post, flick, at 11:18. It explains, to me at any rate, what he's doing very well. Thank you.

Now I'll go back and read the posts that come after that.

durhamjen Sun 03-May-15 18:17:39

Sorry, Eloethan, I did not mean that. I meant that others do the same as him, and like him, do not crow about it.
I actually like Russell Brand for his political stand, particularly about housing and poverty. I saw it, but did not think of it as crowing. I obviously expressed myself badly.

whitewave Sun 03-May-15 18:37:23

I hadn't seen the reports of his cafe. But that isn't saying a lot smile

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 18:46:46

I read "The I" every day, but I had not seen reports about the opening of the cafe - I only found out through my husband going on Twitter.

How many other Gransnetters, apart from Ana, had seen the news that Russell Brand had opened a cafe, run by recovering addicts and paid for from the proceeds of his book "Revolution"?

Ana Sun 03-May-15 18:58:47

I'm not sure what you're trying to prove, Eloethan. The fact is that the opening of the café was reported widely. The Telegraph report even had a video of Brand at the opening, and the Guardian made a point of informing its readers that it had been funded from the profits of Revolution.

If no one else on GN knew about it they can't say it's because it wasn't publicised enough!

The i must be about the only newspaper that didn't cover the story.

durhamjen Sun 03-May-15 18:59:10

I saw it. It's on the New Era estate where he helped the residents in their fight to keep their houses and flats.
Haven't bought the book, though, although I have just started reading Caroline Lucas's book, Honourable Friends?

Brand is telling people to vote Green now.

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 19:03:50

Please Gransnetters - how many of you were aware that Russell Brand had used the proceeds of his book "Revolution" to finance a cafe, which provides training and employment for recovering addicts and provides reasonably priced drinks and snacks for the community?

janeainsworth Sun 03-May-15 19:11:30

I wasn't, as I've said.

petallus Sun 03-May-15 19:31:30

I wasn't aware.

I have a lot of respect for RB.

petallus Sun 03-May-15 19:32:19

Easy to be cynical and make snide comments. I think he is sincere.

Ana Sun 03-May-15 19:36:16

I can't see any 'snide comments' about RB on this thread, petallus.

Eloethan Sun 03-May-15 19:50:09

Ana - FlicketyB referred to Russell Brand as a "champagne socialist" - i.e. someone who is rich and lives the high life whilst professing to care about less well off people but who does nothing about it.

Ana Sun 03-May-15 20:28:41

Oh, I see - (although I did actually know what 'champagne socialist' means!)

For what it's worth I think what he's doing is admirable, but the idea that he's doing good by stealth is IMO untenable.