Gransnet forums

News & politics

The National Anthem

(161 Posts)
Anniebach Wed 16-Sept-15 09:40:00

Eloethan, so funny,

Eloethan Wed 16-Sept-15 09:36:03

My husband pointed out these tweets to me this morning:

"Sing you traitor. How is this man even an MP, let alone the leader of the opposition?"

I liked the riposte:

"Because singing is not a requirement to become an MP. You're thinking of the X Factor."

merlotgran Wed 16-Sept-15 09:28:40

I'm not a Jeremy Corbyn fan but I think he did the right thing. He's made no secret of the fact that he's not a monarchist so to sing it would have been hypocritical.

Anniebach Wed 16-Sept-15 08:54:22

This is a country where the Anthem use to be played in cinemas but finally stopped because of the rush of the public to get out before the first note sounded.

The press are condemning Corbyn for insulting the queen , the same press who when Diana died behaved like a pack of baying hounds after blood - the queens blood, one newspaper accused her husband and son of murder

It's an awful Anthem , praising a head of state not a country

The man behaved with respect for the occasion

tanith Wed 16-Sept-15 08:36:29

I think it's a big fuss about nothing. The media is just looking for things to pick at about Corbyn. He was perfectly respectful , can you be rude by NOT doing something?

whenim64 Wed 16-Sept-15 08:33:18

I feel the same - I don't see what the problem is. He treats others with respect so why criticise this?

Luckygirl Wed 16-Sept-15 08:08:58

I have no problem at all with that. He was respectfully quiet and no hypocritical.

I do the same when I play at church services - remain respectfully quiet during prayers. No-one has a problem with that and I do not have a problem with Corbyn's behaviour.

The National Anthem is a total pain - it would be lovely to have something new instead of this imperialist crap.

Anya Wed 16-Sept-15 07:49:17

I have no trouble with him standing quietly but not singing the national anthem.

cornergran Wed 16-Sept-15 07:40:21

If you take on a very public and challenging role this will happen. I wonder though at what point the responsibility of a role supersedes personal belief. Lots of levels here.

wondergran Wed 16-Sept-15 05:21:54

I think the media nowadays pick up on every single little thing which, quite often, borders on the ridiculous. I presume Mr Corbyn is anti monachary, which he is totally entitled to be and could not force himself to sing the national anthem. He attended the ceremony, was dressed suitably and showed the correct level of respect that this occasion warranted which is all that matters.

Eloethan Wed 16-Sept-15 00:32:51

It seems to me that if we call ourselves a democracy then anybody should be perfectly at liberty not to have to sing the national anthem. It is, in my opinion, a horrible dirge of a song anyway with ridiculous words that concentrate wholly on the monarch rather than on the country and its people.

There has been almost universal condemnation of Jeremy Corbyn for not singing words with which he does not agree. No doubt, if he had sung the national anthem there would have been a lot of sneering remarks about him being a hypocrite. Some people snigger at other countries for treating their leaders as if they were divine beings and yet it seems to me that many people in this country have a similarly strange attitude towards the monarch who is, after all, just another human being.