Gransnet forums

News & politics

White Poppy

(261 Posts)
FarNorth Wed 16-Sept-15 10:11:12

Here is an extract from an article on reasons for wearing a white poppy :

"Many of us instead wear a white poppy, the symbol of peace. We do so not because we feel the suffering of those who died or were bereaved any less, everyone agrees that we should commemorate the sacrifice.

But we fear that in remembering the First World War, too many people in government and the military are using the compassion that people feel to justify present and future wars."

stopwar.org.uk/news/why-i-will-wear-a-white-poppy-to-honour-the-dead-on-remembrance-day

Ana Sun 04-Oct-15 16:27:22

And choosing a red poppy does not signify that the wearer does not want peace.

nigglynellie Sun 04-Oct-15 16:14:52

Sorry, I'll, and yes we all want peace that's for sure, wanting Is the easy bit, it's securing it, that's the stumbling block!!!

nigglynellie Sun 04-Oct-15 16:05:12

Ill stick to my red one, it says much more to me than white,but each to their own.

thatbags Sun 04-Oct-15 16:02:01

I expect we'd all rather have peace.

durhamjen Sun 04-Oct-15 15:33:02

That's okay, you do not have to.
I'd rather have peace, but never mind.

nigglynellie Sun 04-Oct-15 15:31:34

No thank you.

durhamjen Sun 04-Oct-15 15:04:19

stopwar.org.uk/resources/white-poppy-2

A direct link to ordering your white poppies if you want to.

hicaz46 Wed 23-Sept-15 21:35:44

I'm with farnorth - says it all

rosequartz Tue 22-Sept-15 17:47:35

self-respecting spin doctor (and I have been one)
I'm intrigued grumppa
I wanna know more!! grin

Gracesgran Tue 22-Sept-15 14:52:07

Sorry, missed your stars Grumppa

Gracesgran Tue 22-Sept-15 14:51:34

Grumppa I wonder what this new style of apology is called. Soon seems to have studied under the same school as the recent rather sleazy Barrister in using the word sorry to apologise on my behalf rather than her own for the way "that that meant that to you".

Eloethan Tue 22-Sept-15 13:03:12

Anniebach's right. Whatever the truth, this story reflects badly on both of them.

rosequartz Tue 22-Sept-15 12:59:10

white ones weren't around in the immediate post-war period

I presume you mean poppies, friends123
However:
www.ppu.org.uk/learn/early/poppy3_early_years.html

White lies certainly were, I am sure DM used to tell me them hmm

friends123 Tue 22-Sept-15 12:48:31

I think it's a generational matter- white ones weren't around in the immediate post-war period.

Anniebach Tue 22-Sept-15 09:36:51

Ashcroft or Cameron lied , as for other allegations ! Bacon does seem to be a favourite with politicians

Anniebach Tue 22-Sept-15 09:31:05

grumppa, there are not shades of truth, there is truth, lies and white lies?

durhamjen Mon 21-Sept-15 23:43:25

So where do you put Cameron saying that he knew about Ashcroft's Non-dom status for only a month before the election, and Ashcroft saying he knew about it the year before?

grumppa Mon 21-Sept-15 23:38:51

I believe that eventually lies are always found out, Anniebach. It would certainly be stupid of any self-respecting spin doctor (and I have been one) to assume otherwise.

I am no longer sure what accusation is being made and discussed (hence my generalisation), but I am not convinced that being a little bit pregnant is a useful analogy, any more than the mother's excuse in Captain Marryat's Mr. Midshipman Easy that her illegitimate baby was a very little one. There may be shades of truth in some circumstances, but there are also absolute truths and downright lies.

Anniebach Mon 21-Sept-15 22:49:40

Lies are not always found out grumppa .

As for the accusation made and being discussed, if something is - not so near the truth , where is it? the same as being or not being a little bit pregnant ?

grumppa Mon 21-Sept-15 22:22:13

If spin means anything it means trying to put the most favourable interpretation on a person, object or action, typically on behalf on a client. What it should never mean is telling a downright lie, since lies are always found out.

An example: an estate agent abuses a client's trust by stealing from an apartment he is supposed to be selling to fund a drug habit. The owner of the estate agency is asked "Don't you have proper vetting procedures for your employees?" The spin doctor advises him to say "All the procedures in the world can't prevent this sort of isolated incident."

The statement is self-evidently true, but evades the question whether any procedures were in place at all, and gives the journalist a usable quote.

Slightly grubby, but not downright dishonest; that's life. To expect more from politics is like spitting in the wind.

Eloethan Mon 21-Sept-15 21:08:12

soontobe What did you mean to imply?

durhamjen Mon 21-Sept-15 21:01:20

Are you spinning, soon? You definitely seem to be in a spin about Corbyn. I'd just give up if I were you.

Anniebach Mon 21-Sept-15 20:55:59

?

soontobe Mon 21-Sept-15 20:54:12

I dont see "not so near the truth" as meaning lying. But if you take it like that, then I am sorry that that meant that to you, as I did not mean to imply that you were lying.

soontobe Mon 21-Sept-15 20:52:04

He doesnt do spin yet. I suspect he will. We shall see however. Lovely if he doesnt.