Gransnet forums

News & politics

Jeremy Corbyn Elected

(539 Posts)
rosequartz Sun 20-Sept-15 20:42:59

As jinglbellsfrocks had the last word in the last thread about Jermy Corbyn, I am starting a new one.

Do you think that the election of Jeremy Corbyn has scuppered Labour's chances of winning the next election or has it revitalised the party?

rosequartz Sun 27-Sept-15 19:17:57

Yes, but many people still wouldn't get it grin

Ana Sun 27-Sept-15 19:14:16

Anya, we need an 'irony' emoticon! grin

rosequartz Sun 27-Sept-15 19:13:05

Business not important, either, Anniebach
I didn't say it wasn't, djen
Just not a 'top job' apparently.

Anyway, I thought 'business' was a dirty word with some on the extreme left
You know, dreadful capitalism and all that confused

Anniebach Sun 27-Sept-15 19:12:17

Corbyn is Anya, you are posting on a thread titled - Corbyn elected

rosequartz Sun 27-Sept-15 19:10:08

Roseq, how important do you think health and education are?

Very important indeed, but apparently, in political circles, not the 'top jobs'

Not my definition:
n the UK, tradition holds that the top three Ministers after the Prime Minister are the Chancellor, Foreign Secretary and Home Secretary. In that order these 4 positions are referred to as the Great Offices of State, the most prestigious positions in government

Anya Sun 27-Sept-15 19:04:37

Just watching the news.

Remind me, who is the leader of the Labour Party - Jeremy Corbyn or Len McClusky? confused

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 16:28:32

I am not getting into anything either.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 16:26:55

I have not been talking about Jesus Christ at all.

durhamjen Sun 27-Sept-15 16:10:41

Corbyn has never said he wants to take Britain out of Europe.

All I said was that JC was the first true socialist, and it was Ab and me that you asked.

If you think that Jesus Christ was wrong being a true socialist, then I doubt your religious fervour.

Who said that they think the John behaviour was wrong?
Can't see that anywhere.

durhamjen Sun 27-Sept-15 16:05:58

www.cityam.com/225203/thomas-piketty-and-joseph-stiglitz-signed-labours-economic-advisory-panel-john-mcdonnell

This is excellent news.

Who are you talking to, soon, in your last comment?

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 15:35:04

Good. You at least think he can do some wrong[Jeremy Corbyn]. It would actually be nice if you said so once in a while.
Gracesgran and whitewave manage to do that.
{I am not going to go into specifics in case you might want to turn it into one of those games].
And you think that the John behaviour was wrong. Good again.
A more balanced view of what you think would actually make your views appear not so rigid I think.

MargaretX Sun 27-Sept-15 15:34:26

I watched him with Andrew Marr this morning. He did very well and didn't let Andrew Marr push him into a corner. Its hard for me not to like him-he reminds me of my brother who died 12 years ago, who was a staunch socialist and must have been about the same age as Corbyn is now.

I was also a socialist when young and I suppose I still am but I hope he doesn't take Britain out of Europe, and out of NATO as I am not so sure he knows what we would have instead

durhamjen Sun 27-Sept-15 15:29:04

JC was the first true socialist, over two thousand years ago.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 15:00:59

JC that is.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 15:00:14

Cant be bothered to answer that Ab.

dj, at no point did he say that his behaviour was wrong as far as I can remember.
Do you think it was?

Can I ask both of you while you are here.

Do you think he can do no wrong? Because that is how it comes across to me

Anniebach Sun 27-Sept-15 14:16:45

soon, do you never think talk instead of killing is worth trying?

durhamjen Sun 27-Sept-15 14:02:43

What was wrong with what he said about John McDonnell?

durhamjen Sun 27-Sept-15 14:01:31

I thought it was an excellent interview. He answered the questions very thoroughly and carefully. He did not obfuscate, like many politicians try to do.
Many new Labour supporters are not young. Many of them are Gransnetters or their children. I think my two sons and their partners are quite mature enough to know what they want, and are Labour supporters.

I agree with him about having a party which is inclusive, and does not walk by on the other side.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 13:51:32

I got lost about the Syria stuff. I dont know enough. I think they are going to say more tomorrow.
Glad he said he was not in support of Putin.

Nato have had a long term agenda of pushing eastwards? That is what he said. Again, I dont know enough.

Didnt like what he said about John McDonald. Seemed in some way to support him. Didnt come down hard on him at all. More concerned about his sentence!
Which is weird thinking about it, as he goes for peace.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 13:41:25

He seems to be staying out of Queen issues now!

He does answer questions straight on the whole.

soontobe Sun 27-Sept-15 13:35:48

I havent watched the whole of the interview . I intend to at some point, word for word!

I did notice at some point about something or other, that he wants to bring people around to his point of view.
He didnt say others points of view!

Welcomed what he said about business having lawyers and accountants to move money about to avoid taxes.

Didnt agree with him still thinking it was ok to bring IRA into Houses of Parliament when he did.

So so glad he doesnt want to talk to IS at this stage.

Gracesgran Sun 27-Sept-15 13:18:38

He even tried to answer the unanswerable in the best way he could f77ms. It is really silly to ask him the outcome of discussions before they take place; it just makes the journalists look rather old-fashioned and out of step.

I wonder what those who would be prepared to pay up to have their say in the Conservative Party would say they want if given the chance?

f77ms Sun 27-Sept-15 13:01:32

You have hit the nail on the head there saying we are too selfish to be socialist !!

f77ms Sun 27-Sept-15 12:59:38

I ,for one, am delighted about Corbyn being elected . He is a principled , honest politician the likes of which we have not seen for a long time . He actually answers questions which are put to him with no spin which is so refreshing.

The right wing media have tried their best to discredit him but most people I speak to are seeing through it lately.

What he seems to stand for is a fairer society , how can that be wrong or misinformed ? smile

Anniebach Sun 27-Sept-15 12:41:49

The young conservatives have no problem with Cameron