Gransnet forums

News & politics

Democracy strengthened

(130 Posts)
whitewave Thu 01-Oct-15 08:04:30

I have just been listening to some people on radio 4 talking about JC. At the start of the interview, the usual question about immigration was asked "do you think there are too many" "is JC wrong saying they should be welcomed" and "are they taking your jobs"

I was fully prepared for each of the 6 interviewees to affirm all the questions, but was delighted at all their replies. They were working class living in East London experiencing a relatively hard life - mum's with tiny children on the 13th floor of a high rise, dad having to travel -he is unemployed- to Leeds for an interview for a job. What happens if he gets it they are unclear. Other folk interviewed were similar.
What is absolutely clear is the support that they are giving to JC and his new form of democracy. They talked about how at last there is someone with whom they can identify, and understands their life and struggle.
They talked of at last after 18 years there being a real opposition to the Tories.
As for the immigrants not one was against them.

LullyDully Wed 04-Nov-15 03:12:03

Perhaps we would then move the ship building back to Portsmouth!!!!!!

durhamjen Tue 03-Nov-15 23:55:32

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/nov/03/snp-and-labour-msps-unite-to-vote-against-trident-renewal

So if Scotland says no to Trident, do we have to move the submarines to England? This is going to be an interesting battle of wills.

rosesarered Sun 04-Oct-15 16:59:10

it would feel like a war [ which it is] women and children always have it the hardest in any war.The reason things have dragged on for so long is there are not just two opposing sides but many factions. The West have now had this problem taken out of their hands by a fait accompli from Russia.

whitewave Sun 04-Oct-15 16:55:09

It must feel like the third world war in Syria. Imagine being a Mum with a family!

rosesarered Sun 04-Oct-15 16:53:34

there will be a bit of posturing and attitude from various countries, but in the end, they will have to work together to rid Syria of IS and the rebels , or at least some of them[ there seem to be about 5 groups with differing agendas.]

rosesarered Sun 04-Oct-15 16:51:25

no, forget about third world war, it won't happen.Not from this anyway.

durhamjen Sun 04-Oct-15 15:23:30

Third world war. My granddaughter was right!

Greyduster Sun 04-Oct-15 14:04:09

I think we need to worry, guys! My neighbour across the road has uncovered his tank (yes, you heard me correctly) and is POLISHING IT!!!! He must know something we don't! To be fair, it is quite a small tank, but even so.....smile

rosesarered Fri 02-Oct-15 20:23:18

Very true nigglienelly. Russia will now dig itself in, and the US will have to fall into line with them or leave.Both IS and all the opposition groups will be destroyed.Assad will be at the helm again.The only good thing will be that IS will be finished ( in Syria). especially as Iran is joining in with Russia.Perhaps there could never have been another outcome.

nigglynellie Fri 02-Oct-15 17:00:40

Imo, at the end of the day it'll be the Russians who will call the tune in Syria! They are the only ones who can do what they like with impunity, and will!!! The West always tinkers round the edges of any problem, whereas Russia will go for the jugular, they aren't answerable to anyone, so can ride roughshod over anyone else, and will!! Putin has an agenda here and sees an opportunity. While the West dithers and wrings it's hands, Putin marches in, reinstates Assad, and hey presto, Russia has a foothold in the Middle East! Assad stays put, propped up by Putin, who we are all afraid of if we're honest! With nothing to show for all this horror except a waste of innocent lives, smashed infrastructure, and a people still living under a vicious regime, with absolutely no hope of ever changing anything. What a mess and what a waste!!! Maybe, just maybe, we can in the future keep away from these countries, because if ever there was a case of the road to hell being paved with good intentions this for sure is it!

Nelliemoser Fri 02-Oct-15 13:01:37

Well we've got into bed with other tyrants before now to try to save a war situation.
nigglynellie at Fri 02-Oct-15 12:03:1* has made a very valid point about the whole situation.

I would suggest trying to get some sort of peace might be where to start but with all the issues and waring factions involved. It is not going to be easy.

nigglynellie Fri 02-Oct-15 12:03:18

If Putin wants Assad to stay in power, and we know he does, then it stands to reason that he will attack anyone whom he perceives to be preventing this. We can certainly work together to eliminate IS, but then what? After that the two powers will.then be on different sides with totally different agendas. All the West could do is 'back off' or risk all out conflict with Russia! a truly terrifying scenario. All the suffering endured by the Syrian people will have been in vain as they'll be effectively back to square one. Russia's agenda is of course a mediterranean port, and no doubt airbase facilities. What to do? I really don't know!

durhamjen Fri 02-Oct-15 10:48:37

It seems to me like the only one in Syria who wants the bombing to continue is Assad, as he wins either way. He is not bothered which side gets bombed as long as he stays in power. His troops have killed more civilians than any other group.
When you look at the countries involved this is World War 3.

whitewave Fri 02-Oct-15 10:46:16

Trouble is the USA will be aware of this, and undoubtedly tryits damdest to prevent this. Happy days!

Anya Fri 02-Oct-15 10:31:43

Meant to type groups.

I'm quite happy for Russia (or anybody) to wipe Daesh off the face of the earth, but if only it was that simple. Putin of course is looking for another base on the Mediterranean, one with enough strategic importance, and Syria fulfills that need.

whitewave Fri 02-Oct-15 10:09:27

anya on radio 4 this morning. US backed groups not troops, but presumably as they are fighting it amounts to the same thing?
Everyone is interfering, USA, France, us, Saudi Arabia, Emirates , Iran and on and on it goes.
Started off with a protest against the brutal regime, and Hilary Clinton that it was the end of Assad, blimey, bit optimistic.

Anya Fri 02-Oct-15 10:03:07

What's this about USA-backed troups in Syria? That's been kept very quiet.

Here's me thinking the only 'interference' in this civil war was strategic air strikes on Daesh targets on Syria's borders.

Anniebach Fri 02-Oct-15 09:54:08

Saudia Arabia is just the bestest friend to this country , they buy our arms, they shower the windsors with priceless jewels, our PM rushes to pay respects to their deceased king whilst criticising others countries in the Middle East for their brutal beheadings, stoning, public whippings , all of which goes on in Saudia Arabia. And our future king who refused to attend a state banquet for a Chinese delegation because of their actions in Tibet paid a royal visit to pay his respects to the deceased king and who has never refused diamonds ,emeralds, rubies etc given to his family

The flags flying at half mast over Whitehall was a disgrace

whitewave Fri 02-Oct-15 09:38:39

Letter in Guardian this morning " if in the event that we used the bomb, its deterrent effect would have failed"

whitewave Fri 02-Oct-15 09:37:14

Oh good! Russia bombing USA backed groups now.

whitewave Fri 02-Oct-15 07:22:30

I think really that the information is out there, but never brought to general view, as it doesn't suit a political or business standpoint.

Gracesgran Fri 02-Oct-15 05:56:59

It's not just that it is support for Corbyn Jen but it is support for the discussion. I hadn't realised just how much some discussions and views have been shut out over recent years.

durhamjen Fri 02-Oct-15 00:55:01

From the grass roots of Labour.

durhamjen Fri 02-Oct-15 00:52:16

labourlist.org/2015/10/corbyn-was-right-to-highlight-the-uks-corrupt-dealings-with-saudi-arabia/

More support for Corbyn.

durhamjen Thu 01-Oct-15 23:19:40

On Question Time they still think it's a button.