I think most people believe that there should be some sort of additional body to oversee and discuss proposed policies and legislative changes.
That does not mean that everyone supports a House of Lords based on the current system of patronage or what some may feel is an insidious form of corruption. And an additional body with 850+members - the second largest in the world after China - is, in my view, totally ridiculous. The fact that there is no compulsory retirement age or test of fitness for office, and that members can claim £350 a day for merely turning up seems quite crazy to me.
I am pleased the government has been defeated re the cut in working tax credits (with the assistance of several Conservative members). The Guardian on Saturday gave examples of several people who would be seriously affected by the proposed cuts in tax credit, including:
A 34 year old female teaching assistant with a 7 year old son who will be £1,399.40 worse off next year;
A 42 year old female residential child care officer with an 11 year old daughter who will be £1,715 worse off next year.
A 33 year old female community centre worker with 2 daughters who will be £2,454 worse off next year.
A 42 year old male local government worker with 3 children (one disabled) who will be £2,799.60 worse off next year (on a salary of £22,000)
How can anybody justify these huge cuts to people who are already earning quite low salaries and would they be accepting of such changes if their own children/grandchildren were going to be affected?