Gransnet forums

News & politics

POPPY POLICE

(48 Posts)
rosequartz Sun 08-Nov-15 15:12:35

My deleted post wasn't anything controversial!

I kept mislaying my poppy as did DH but we did make sure we wore them today. The BBC does go overboard in making everyone wear them, but at least if they pay £1 for each one it must raise a lot of money for the Poppy Appeal. If they do. If Sienna Miller had on a very expensive dress or had borrowed it from a designer then I can understand that she didn't want to make pinholes in it.

The slap bands, wrist bands etc etc have proved to be very popular with school children and raised a lot of extra money for the Appeal.

a slap band is a straight piece of - oh here you are grin:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slap_bracelet

rosequartz Sat 07-Nov-15 23:25:27

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Luckygirl Sat 07-Nov-15 23:10:54

What pray is a slap bang!?

Purpledaffodil Sat 07-Nov-15 21:32:36

DGS' school had poppies AND whole tray of poppy themed goodies, slap bangs, wristbands, poppy reflective dodahs etc etc. I bought him one of those slap band things, but had horrible day teaching in a class where at least half of the children had them. On one side they were printed as rulers to make them even harder to confiscate temporarily ( but I didsad) From a child's point of view they were much more appealing than an easily lost poppy.
I agree poppy fascism has been awful this year. However I have my sparkly British Legion poppy now which pins on securely[ smug emoticon]. Before I would lose several every year.

ninathenana Sat 07-Nov-15 20:23:15

The RBL chap I bought my enamel pin poppy from told me "the suggested" donation for each type. £2 for my pin badge. Which I was happy to give.

Luckygirl Sat 07-Nov-15 20:10:57

I will not be buying one, but will make a donation to a charity in memory of those who died.

NotTooOld Sat 07-Nov-15 17:52:09

Anniebach - entirely agree with you.

Anniebach Sat 07-Nov-15 16:55:16

There was even one on the BBC weather report , not the one worn by the chap, just a photograph stuck on the BBC weather line. It is now irritating me, they are cheapening the meaning of it , it means - I remember and not - look I am wearing a poppy

Indinana Sat 07-Nov-15 16:06:49

I have to agree, it is virtue signalling. Perhaps poppies should be graded according to how much you donate. Standard for £1, a double paper poppy for £3, a glittery one for £5, a fabric one for £10, and an enamel pin for £20. Then we could all really show off our support wink

TerriBull Sat 07-Nov-15 15:30:08

I agree NotTooOld, Sienna Miller got pilloried for not wearing one on Graham Norton last week, quite unfairly I thought. I read later that she had been unable to attach the one she had brought with her to her dress

I bought a poppy this morning and appear to have lost it already!

JamJar1 Sat 07-Nov-15 15:00:06

Oh dear this is the first year I can remember that I have not bought a poppy as just recently I've been more indoors than outdoors. My OH was going to buy one for me but I told him to just make a donation for me instead. Now getting around and about a little more so hope I don't get accosted by the Poppy Police. Yes, I think sadly for some it has become all about virtue signalling.

NotTooOld Sat 07-Nov-15 14:50:37

'virtue signalling' and 'poppy waving' - both of those phrases sum it up for me, this year at any rate. I haven't noticed it so much in previous years.

rosesarered Sat 07-Nov-15 13:51:49

Poppy waving?

Alea Sat 07-Nov-15 13:50:51

Another example of virtue signalling?

stillhere Sat 07-Nov-15 13:49:25

Because it is very obvious that the object of the exercise is to make others feel ashamed of their lack of outward support, when it is obvious that there is no lack of support judging by how much money is raised every year.

stillhere Sat 07-Nov-15 13:47:26

How timely - I was looking at Facebook posts where all seem to be exhorting us to display a photo of a poppy on our page. I went to a large meeting of a couple of hundred women two days ago, and only perhaps four were wearing a poppy. I thought - how refreshing, because I bet every single one of them owns at least one, maybe several, as do I. It made me realise how much pressure girls must come under to wear a hijab.

KatyK Sat 07-Nov-15 13:31:54

DH and I would love to wear our poppies but the ones we bought from a chap from the British Legion fell to pieces as we were pinning them on sad

Anniebach Sat 07-Nov-15 13:23:59

The poppy seems to have become a problem

NotTooOld Sat 07-Nov-15 13:22:37

roses - yes, I suppose I did mean in the media.

loopylou Sat 07-Nov-15 13:19:54

Hear, hear!
So far this year I've bought 4 traditional poppies and lost all of them. I've now got a knitted poppy that hopefully will survive smile

Next year I'm buying the brooch version( it would work out cheaper too!)

rosesarered Sat 07-Nov-15 13:18:34

I always buy a couple for us, from poppy sellers, but haven't actually worn them this year ( haven't been out much recently, ) and when we did ,forgot to pin on the poppies. Nobody has commented on our poppy-less state, or do you mean in the media, NotTooOld ?

ninathenana Sat 07-Nov-15 13:15:04

Well said.

NotTooOld Sat 07-Nov-15 13:14:03

Why are the poppy police picking on people this year for not wearing poppies/not wearing enough poppies/not wearing poppies early enough? IMHO the current bullying of non-poppy wearers is disrespectful to those who fought in wars for freedom and democracy. I have always bought a poppy but this year, in protest at the bullying, I have not. I will remember those who gave their lives in my own private way with a donation and a prayer for peace.