Boaty McBoatface is named...

Not democratic. 4th place "won".
Imagine if that happened elsewhere.

A good result, very fitting for Sir David and we do get a sub though should that be subby mcsubface?

Yes lovely man, he would have been my second choice. But not terribly democratic.

Yes, a good compromise, though a large part of me would have paid good money to hear the Queen say - 'I name this ship BoatyMcBoatface.'

An appropriate tribute and yes, good that the sub will be "boaty*

I agree it is a more fitting name, but pleased that the submarine will carry the Boaty name.

Agree! They've gone with a good name in my opinion. Shame the public will never be trusted to suggest important names again.

The right choice of name I think but it will always be aka Boaty McBoatface