Gransnet forums

News & politics

The one indisputable FACT in this referendum debate

(338 Posts)
Anya Tue 14-Jun-16 11:18:34

Like many of us, I prefer to deal in facts, not surmise, assumptions, or what might be, or might not happen. The truth is that neither side have a clear idea of what leaving or remaining in the EU might entail, except for one clear fact.

This is, that if we remain, we will continue to have no control over numbers of immigrants from the EU, entering the country.

We all agree that immigration is a Good Thing, but uncontrollable immigration is another issue completely.

Ana Wed 15-Jun-16 17:53:56

So just for purely selfish reasons, then?

Tegan Wed 15-Jun-16 17:50:02

'WW how can anyone NOT vote Brexit! there will be rather a lot of us voting that way come next week.'
well, roses...as I've mentioned before, those of us whose children have been advised by their employers that a 'Leave' vote could result in them no longer being in employment will vote to stay in.

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:49:19

I certainly agree with your last sentence GJ I don't think anyone expects not to be challenged.The manner of challenging though, is another matter.

granjura Wed 15-Jun-16 17:43:59

roses- I kept very much away- as I did expect it too. As Tegan says so well though, whose twaddle depends very much on your own perceptions.

No-one can expect to post here on such important issues and expect not to be challenged on so-called 'facts' or opinions.

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:40:00

In fact, it may be the only thing we can all agree on.

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:39:38

I think we may all say that Tegan

Tegan Wed 15-Jun-16 17:36:45

One persons pompous twaddle is another persons informed information. Depends who you are and how you read it, I guess. I've learned quite a lot about politics on gransnet but, boy oh boy have I learned a lot more about human nature sad.

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:33:07

Well, Granjura perhaps Anya didn't expect a load of pompous twaddle ( but I did) and it always happens on these threads.
One week to go thank God.

obieone Wed 15-Jun-16 17:32:58

I find I am having to question a lot of stuff now.

varian Wed 15-Jun-16 17:31:32

Too many people talk in slogans which were coined by politicians or journalists to act as a useful smokescreen.

The ridiculous slogan "project fear" was coined two years ago by supporters of the Scottish separatists who wanted to break up the UK. Warnings about the likely affect of the fall in the price of oil were dismissed as scaremongering - and yet they have been totally vindicated. The Scottish economy would be in a dire state were it not still part of the UK and given Barnet subsidies beyond the wildest dreams of people in the rest of the country.

We are seeing the same nonsensical sloganising used again. The Leave campaign use these meaningless slogans and dismiss the warnings without any thought for the consequences. Don't be fooled. Weigh up the evidence and heed the warnings before it is too late.

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:31:27

Yes Anya another thread bites the dust indeed.

obieone Wed 15-Jun-16 17:31:05

The date of the article I can find is 6 June. Is that the one you mean?

rosesarered Wed 15-Jun-16 17:30:40

WW how can anyone NOT vote Brexit! there will be rather a lot of us voting that way come next week.

granjura Wed 15-Jun-16 17:27:52

Fact- large drop against the Swiss franc too in last couple of days.

Anya - another one bites the dust! What on earth did you expect, really- by starting yet another one???

whitewave Wed 15-Jun-16 17:24:43

Watching the Commons debate. How can anyone vote Brexit????

whitewave Wed 15-Jun-16 17:22:46

Call a spade a spade jing?????????

whitewave Wed 15-Jun-16 17:21:11

BBC news

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 15-Jun-16 17:21:05

God! There's some stuck up so and so's on Gransnet. hmm

obieone Wed 15-Jun-16 17:20:36

What is your source please whitewave

obieone Wed 15-Jun-16 17:19:27

Even the poor, especially the poor, very much need a healthy economy. They rely on the government very much so. Much more than others in the economy.

varian Wed 15-Jun-16 17:19:26

The value of the pound has a huge effect on the prosperity of this country. The only way we can prevent it from falling further is to vote REMAIN.

whitewave Wed 15-Jun-16 17:19:05

All currencies the dollar in particular

whitewave Wed 15-Jun-16 17:18:02

Of course the wealthy will be speculating like mad on sterling and making a killing. Sod the poor they are deserving it.

JessM Wed 15-Jun-16 17:17:15

My motto on GN is that someone tries to derail a thread by sniping then ignore them and move on.
Lots of conversations over the last couple of days.
The woman who said the EU was against her Christian principles confused
The woman who works in a hospital who said EU staff upset at the hostility of the campaign and planning to go home if there is a Leave vote.
The union rep who said that so many people seem focussed only on immigration to the exclusion of other issues.
I'm organising an event to publicise my concerns about women's rights in work, which are likely to be compromised if we leave.
Patel is already on record as saying she'd like to cut the burdensome red tape of employment rights and "help businesses create jobs".
The equation here is that you give your workers less holiday, pay temps and part-timers less, cut maternity leave entitlement and ditch the working time directive so that people can be pressured to work very long hours without entitlement to breaks etc. All of these would of course reduce staff costs and increase profit.
Of course many employers would continue to treat their staff fairly. But some would not. Would their profit be re-invested to create more exploitative jobs? Possibly. Or it might be just taken as increased profit and invested in holiday homes and yachts in sunny climes.
If there is a Leave vote and the likes of Johnson/Gove/Patel end up running the country they will not have to call a general election for 4 more years and could - no the WOULD - do incalculable damage to working rights in this country.

obieone Wed 15-Jun-16 17:16:52

Against which currency whitewave?
Only the Euro. Or others?