Gransnet forums

News & politics

Consensus and detente on racism

(86 Posts)
thatbags Tue 15-Nov-16 22:16:00

I've just bumped into via Twitter and read this really good, thought-provoking essay about the current state of racism in the US. It's by David Marcus.

His argument is that America had a detente, an agreement, about racism—a set of rules that people understood and agreed with on the whole—but that the presidential election has marked the end of the detente and we have lost something as a result. He concludes that we should:

"listen to each other without immediate judgment and with trust in people’s good faith. That trust will not always be rewarded, but without it a détente can never be.
If a generation of Americans who lived through the racism, riots, anguish, and terror of the civil rights movement were able to trust each other’s decency and create cultural codes and norms to punish abject racism, we should be able to do it, too. But the truly scary thing is that, at this moment, it doesn’t appear we want to".

nigglynellie Fri 18-Nov-16 19:23:09

When I was very small and travelling with my mother on the top of a bus in Oxford, there was sitting further up the bus a young black man. I asked my mother why he was black, and she replied that he came from a very hot country and that his skin was black to protect him from the sun which was much hotter in his country than here. The young man turned, smiled and thanked her. I've never forgotten this incident, and have sometimes wondered what happened to him. I voted for brexit, but please don't label me a racist.

Ana Fri 18-Nov-16 18:53:00

But how did you know he said he didn't like the little boy because he was black?

He might have meant the boy looked unfriendly or surly. Did you just assume it was because of his colour?

Aslemma Fri 18-Nov-16 18:46:23

I think young children can be racist without being taught, but they can be taught to think differently. When he was about 3 one of my sons saw a little black boy playing in a front garden and said "I don't like that little boy". Rather than reacting in horror I simply said "Why not?" to which he replied "He doesn't look nice." I replied that he was just a little boy like him but his mummy and daddy came from a very hot country and they look like that. My son accepted that explanation and grew up to have friends of various ethnicities.

petra Thu 17-Nov-16 17:10:52

The French prime minister has warned France and Germany that they have to listen to their people Re immigration and terrorism. He warned that if they don't " the eu is in danger of falling apart"

TriciaF Thu 17-Nov-16 14:15:02

Thanks, Eloethan - that's a useful distinction, that helps to sort out my own confused views.
And goodness me, there's some heavy information on here, my poor old brain is struggling to take it all in.

whitewave Thu 17-Nov-16 11:50:14

Read binkos link, gives a good explanation for why people act in a certain way.

Marmark1 Thu 17-Nov-16 11:18:54

Lilyflower 10 44,so well put.Nothing else needs to be said on the subject really,
The arrogance of some people here makes my blood boil,
The majority of people have spoken via their vote.

Blinko Thu 17-Nov-16 09:07:12

Cheers, ww it stuck a chord with me too.

whitewave Thu 17-Nov-16 07:33:04

blinko I didn't have time to read that article yesterday.

Absolutely excellent and fits well with how I understand what is happening.

Thank you for posting it. I shall re-read it as it will take a couple of reads to assimilate

Eloethan Thu 17-Nov-16 00:02:36

TriciaF I tend to agree with the definition of racism as being "prejudice plus power".

I'm of the view that most people have fairly irrational dislikes/prejudices about all sorts of things - e.g. tattoos, accents, mode of dress, etc., and we can't legislate for people's thoughts and feelings.

I am a white, British born, person and I have never felt that somebody dislikes or distrusts me because of my colour. Even if I had had such an experience, although it would be hurtful to me, it would be highly unlikely to materially affect my life. For instance, it would be unlikely to influence whether or not my job application or my request to view a particular rental home would be considered.

I think the story would be different if I were a non-white person living in a country predominantly occupied and administered by white people. Some of those people are prejudiced against me and have a stereotypical view of my character, intellect and general abilities. By the law of averages, some of these people yield a degree of power - eg responsibility for recruitment of employees or admissions of students. Their views about people like me are - consciously or sub-consciously - likely to influence how they view my application/request. It is at this point - where prejudice combines with power to affect my life chances - that I think the word "racism" means more than the fairly commonplace petty prejudices that many people have.

Anya Wed 16-Nov-16 22:40:54

Petra I can't reminder which bits of your post I didn't understand as it was so long ago, but I suspect it was all of it. If part of a post makes sense I can usually figure out what the rest means...It's a skill I learned from having so many people with varying degrees of dementia in my life smile

Anya Wed 16-Nov-16 22:38:28

A pure bred mongrel here..

rosesarered Wed 16-Nov-16 21:47:20

Italian,Irish and Yorkshire here! grin

Anniebach Wed 16-Nov-16 21:34:05

Whitewave, Cornish , Welsh and Breton ,

Washerwoman Wed 16-Nov-16 19:55:30

Also Lillyflower just read back over today's whole thread and your post at 10.44 was very succinctly put and spot on.Thank you too.

Washerwoman Wed 16-Nov-16 19:47:58

Thank you Blinko for that link.Very thought provoking.
As was Jason Cowley 's contribution to What makes us Human on Radio 2 at lunchtime.Discussing with Paddy Considine the seismic shifts both here and in America this year.

whitewave Wed 16-Nov-16 19:02:51

Oh! I'm a Cornish Celt I believe members of the Brittany tribe.

Anniebach Wed 16-Nov-16 18:57:19

You are not superior to me whitewave , which branch of we Celts do you relate to?

Blinko Wed 16-Nov-16 18:46:53

This came up on another thread. Sociological aspects of changes in Western society leading to Trump and also Brexit. The article talks about the dangers of labelling those who voted for either as racist pure and simple. The argument is more complex.

www.the-american-interest.com/2016/07/10/when-and-why-nationalism-beats-globalism/

It's a good ten minute read but worth the effort, imo

whitewave Wed 16-Nov-16 18:14:24

Yes we know bags

thatbags Wed 16-Nov-16 18:12:41

The Out of Africa thing has been known for a long time.

Ana Wed 16-Nov-16 17:29:11

I have no idea! I have never traced my family tree and one of my grandmothers was French, married to a Scotsman. I expect I'm just a mongrel, like most others.

whitewave Wed 16-Nov-16 17:23:03

grin are you an Anglo Saxon then ana?

Ana Wed 16-Nov-16 17:21:20

Who are you calling an Anglo-Saxon? hmm
This could get nasty...wink

whitewave Wed 16-Nov-16 17:18:08

Well I definitely was here first as I am a Celt and here before any of you Anglo saxons so I feel superior to all of you lot.