Gransnet forums

News & politics

Cliff Edge anyone?

(1001 Posts)
whitewave Fri 30-Jun-17 07:31:33

This term gets bandied about in relation to Brexit without any of the consequences attached to it.

I have just done some research/ reading and thought it was time we all had the opportunity to discuss what exactly a "cliff edge Brexit" means and whether it can be taken seriously as a "no deal is better than a bad deal" deal.

So talks have failed and our government decides to go it alone.

It is day one of Britains great adventure

We have no trade deals with the EU or the rest of the world.
The economy goes into recession
We now have in front of us several years of negotiating trade deals both with our potentially biggest customer -Europe and the rest of the World.
Countries like Argentina and others that bear a grudge will block any dealings with the WTO.
Getting exports to Europe will become an absolute nightmare, as even if we have successfully arranged our borders for a post Brexit scenario, Europe has only just begun to get their border controls in place for the flow of goods to and from the UK.
The SE becomes a huge lorry park as good stand waiting to be processed. There is a potential for shortages to occur- particularly in relation to food, as there is only one port in Europe that is set up to deal with this commodity, and that is not yet functioning.
Issues like "country of origin" causes complete chaos for business and everything becomes a bureaucratic nightmare.
Flights are delayed/cancelled until the UK can do its own deals with regard to flight rights.
And of course as we have read only recently, nuclear material will dry up, threatening cancer and other treatment.

References are available on request????

Tegan2 Mon 03-Jul-17 17:33:04

Isn't it patriotic to be concerned that we may be/become a laughing stock? There have been articles posted on here that already say that we are a laughing stock and I find it really upsetting that people are looking at us in bemusement.

Ana Mon 03-Jul-17 17:25:32

ofgs you know exactly which one - why bring it up if it doesn't concern you?

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 17:22:52

Which post are you talking about then ?

Ana Mon 03-Jul-17 17:20:41

I was talking about remainers generally, especially on GN. The 'laughing stock' complaint has been raised many times for different reasons.

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 17:19:59

I can't see anywhere in the Lord West post that says patriotism is frowned on. Not sure where you got that?

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 17:18:34

ana is Lord West a remainer?

Ana Mon 03-Jul-17 17:17:03

Remainers do seem to be overly concerned that the UK will 'become a laughing stock'. It seems really important to some of them, yet patriotism is frowned upon...

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 17:06:58

Lord West says that the UK will become the laughing stock as there are insufficient Royal Naval boats to police the UK fishing waters.

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 11:49:55

This is fun.

Someone suggested that we play Brexit Bingo.

So we put down all the facts given out by the remainers and cross them off one by one as they come true.

have your cake and eat it

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 11:40:07

Financial Times front page article writes about the City having given up on the government making any sense over Brexit, and negotiating its own deal leaving the government outside of the negotiations.

This government now clearly has severe legitimacy problems.

James2451 Mon 03-Jul-17 10:41:05

There are many excellent and wise comments on these pages, but unfortunately the media and the majority of members of the Commons are failing to listen to public opinion or simply adopting the Nelson touch. The Gov at present seems to be in a trance and is simply ignore the reality of a UK being led down the wrong path.

Can I suggest you write to your MP's are request them to click on to the gransnet.com and learn more about our concerns for the future of the UK outside the eu etc?

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 09:35:14

Re Gove tweet about fisheries.

Barnier replied

" Gove is spouting bollocks in 140 characters"

A lot will agree with that sentiment. Including the fishermen

durhamjen Mon 03-Jul-17 08:55:24

More nurses are now leaving the profession than starting.
More nurses going back to the EU than arriving.
In two years we will be back to where we started anyway, Welshwife.

Welshwife Mon 03-Jul-17 08:39:25

It is getting confusing with all these changes.

EUCitizens who have worked in UK for many years - 20/30 are now getting jittery about their UK pensions and worried about still being paid. Many are Health workers so will I imagine still pay tax at source on their payments. All such a mess.

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 07:54:50

The next thing the Brexiters will have to move on is in relation to British on the continent.

What May plans to do is unfair. She should "be planning to move foreward, not about unravelling earlier commitments"

We wait for the due announcement

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 07:47:59

Whitehall is planning to remain in the customs union.

I started this thread on 30/6 today is the 3/7 and in that time the government has begun to move rapidly towards reality.

whitewave Mon 03-Jul-17 07:40:43

So plan B now on the table.

Wonder how long that will last?

So now pursuing an EEA or Canadian.

Oh well all you Brexiters soon be back to where we started. I hope all this grief was worth it

durhamjen Sun 02-Jul-17 20:51:35

Just have to eat it all ourselves - except for my family as we are all vegetarian or vegan.

I have often wondered at the reliance on exports and imports, with similar goods adding to the miles from country to country.

whitewave Sun 02-Jul-17 20:41:21

Just reading and I can personally verify this fact, although I had forgotten it. The vast majority of our fish is sold to Europe through the single market.

So presumably roughly 20% tariff will have to added if no single market is negotiated. I would imagine Irish fishermen and others will gain a lot from that.

durhamjen Sun 02-Jul-17 20:02:30

I think they spent most of that year hoping that the job would be taken away from them!
It certainly worked for May, to show the Brexiteers up.
Showed her up as well fortunately, for the schemer that she is.
However, like you say, a wasted year.

Why can't they get together and have cross-party talks. The Brexiteers don't have any experience of such negotiations, and the EU are becoming fed up of their antics.

whitewave Sun 02-Jul-17 19:37:44

How long has it taken to knock this reality into their thick heads?

A whole wasted year.

Idiots!

durhamjen Sun 02-Jul-17 18:59:21

Customs union is still possible.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/02/british-officials-drop-cake-and-eat-it-approach-to-brexit-negotiations

whitewave Sun 02-Jul-17 18:37:31

Usual good article by William Keegan

"The farce that is Brexit has now become open warfare between Brexiters, whilst the rest of the world- with the possible exception of Putin and Trump- look on in sympathetic wonderment................................( May decision to sack Hammond ).
Hammond's sin was to let (May) know that the warnings of our Brussels-based ambassador Rogers, whom May has sacked, were prescient; that making the country poorer was neither good politics nor good economics; and that (Brussels) was not going to let us have our cake and eat it."

Keegan then goes on to point out the new buzzword "transition" as it is patently obvious that nothing can be completed in two years.

The debate now is how to handle the transition and how long this transition is likely to be.

Remainers obviously hope it will take several hundred years, and meanwhile we will remain inside the customs union and Margaret Thatchers greatest achievement - the single market.

"Lord Adonis pointed out in the Lords debate on the QS last week, more than 60% of our trade is with the EI or with other countries with which we enjoy free or preferential access as members of the customs union and single market.

Leave? What folly",
"Why is all this nonsense happening? Largely because of the anti- Europeanise that (Hesletine) described as a cancer gnawing at the heart of the Conservative Party.

durhamjen Sun 02-Jul-17 17:23:39

I suppose at least Branson is on the right side, even helping to fund Gina Miller, Tegan.
It would still be better if he came back and paid his taxes properly.

durhamjen Sun 02-Jul-17 17:15:08

www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/02/mays-brexit-plan-will-hit-rights-of-britons-abroad-campaigners-tell-eu

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion