Gransnet forums

News & politics

Our country post Brexit

(1001 Posts)
whitewave Tue 01-Aug-17 07:49:36

I thought I would start this thread to enable those who are enthusiastic Brexiters, to educate us Europhiles and show that our worries are silly and uniformed.

We hear so little from you, except to criticise our worries.

We have so many threads about the negative effects why not have one which shows the positive effects that leaving the EU will come about?

Tegan2 Tue 05-Sept-17 17:20:45

It has just been pointed out to me that this great repeal bill is frighteningly similar to the German Enabling Act of 1933; does anyone know anything about that?

Welshwife Tue 05-Sept-17 16:32:36

Today's article by Polly Toynbee

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/sep/05/brexit-bill-government-negotiations-labour?CMP=share_btn_link

whitewave Tue 05-Sept-17 15:21:37

Faisal Islam on sky also indicated that

EEA the likely outcome shock so status quo but with no influence/control. I expect leavers will be satisfied with thatconfused

whitewave Tue 05-Sept-17 15:18:17

Information with regard to the negotiations is being published by Europe, and can be found on the web site.

The British government is as usual trying to manage information/expectations and keeping negotiations secret. They have clearly not heard of the term democratic process.

whitewave Tue 05-Sept-17 15:08:05

According to Faisal Islam of sky, Europe has been told to listen for an announcement by Maybot on something like 21 September.

Perhaps it's the big crash out/cliff edge.

Ought to start stockpiling tinned food as there will most certainly be a shortage if this is the case as no border controls have been prepared.

Tegan2 Tue 05-Sept-17 09:11:46

And these are ministers controlled [to a certain extent] by the DUP sad.

GracesGranMK2 Tue 05-Sept-17 09:09:50

"EU repeal bill is a power-grab by ministers"

An interesting article in the Times, sub-headed "Brexit voters will feel betrayed as they realise that ‘take back control’ really means even less democracy than before"

You may have to sign in (but not pay) to read the whole article.

yggdrasil Tue 05-Sept-17 08:04:42

The British nation doesn't even take into account the views of people from other parts of Britain.

TriciaF Mon 04-Sept-17 16:05:02

Margaret good point - I agree.
I'm not sure if I agree with Brexit or not, but I do think the British nation as a whole tends to be insular and doesn't take into account the varying views of other nations.

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 15:30:37

politicalscrapbook.net/2017/09/families-expecting-third-child-will-be-2500-a-year-worse-off-due-to-tory-welfare-cuts/

Good comments on here re Kate and Will's third child. Hope we don't have to subsidise him or her. Government policy.

whitewave Mon 04-Sept-17 15:21:58

Soubry's spinal transplant has not taken sad

She has no intention of voting against the bill.

Party before country

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 15:08:01

twitter.com/VoteLeaveWatch

This is quite a good site, as well, on a you haven't done what you said you would do basis to the Brexiteers.

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 15:03:53

twitter.com/Open_Britain

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 15:00:32

I also think that EU laws are a good thing.
Not quite sure what will happen when our toys are imported from everywhere over the world without EC regulations.
The stuff about trading standards is really quite demeaning to Europe, which includes the UK. Childish. I am surprised that Mark Littlewood and Janet whatever her name is want to be associated with it.

MargaretX Mon 04-Sept-17 14:59:46

If there is one thing I know about living next door to Switzerland it is that they are an exceptionally organised nation and that money and yet more money and paying your debts is uppermost in their minds and that they are a succesful nation, bang full of sovereignty no matter what they are doing. It is ridiculous to compare the easy going, partially poorly educated population of the the UK, with the Swiss.

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 14:53:52

Say well done from me to your S.O., Tegan.

A couple of things about that video. I think it really is a bit much to go back to the second world war.
However, more importantly, the EU did not destroy our fishing, as it says.
www.opendemocracy.net/can-europe-make-it/griffin-carpenter/brexit-so-long-and-thanks-for-all-fish

www.opendemocracy.net/can-europe-make-it/griffin-carpenter/eu-common-fisheries-policy-has-helped-not-harmed-uk-fisheries-0

Tegan2 Mon 04-Sept-17 14:35:29

The S.O. has just contacted me to tell me that he has just had a phone call from The Telegraph, which he used to buy mainly for the sport section. They asked why he had stopped his subscription and he told them it was due to their stance on Europe something that he believed was bad for the country and would take us back 50 years. They then said they would drop the monthly charge to £5, to which he replied 'you haven't been listening to me, have you'. They then offered him more things to tempt him back, to which he replied that even if it was free he wouldn't read it. He had already written to them to explain why he no longer wished to read their biased newspaper. Good for him; he won't come protesting with me but he does his bit!

Tegan2 Mon 04-Sept-17 14:29:57

I have said that I'm putting off watching it because I know I'm going to be upset by the content. And the person who sent it to me is someone whose opinions on many things I find quite worrying [immigration for example]. Also, I'm assuming that there will be people in it [eg Gisela Stuart] who have since said it was a mistake to have a referendum and have left the mess to everyone else to sort out. I shall watch it in snatches and am looking forward to it in the way that I look forward to trips to the dentist. But shall be honest about it if I do find things I agree with [which I'm sure durhamjen would have done]. It may, however, take me some time as I'm going away soon and will not have full internet access.

MaizieD Mon 04-Sept-17 14:07:22

So, you are right Petra and Remainers will not watch it!

One Remainer, lemongrove. I speak only for myself; no-one else.

MaizieD Mon 04-Sept-17 14:05:06

I read some of the comments. as recommended by Petra. I only hope, for the sake of people who do watch it, that the film itself is rather more measured and intelligent...

Did any 'Leavers' read the twitter thread I posted?

durhamjen Mon 04-Sept-17 13:57:05

I've watched it before. Didn't say anything about it because I don't agree with it.
Like Maizie says, it's an hour out of your life you won't get back again.

whitewave Mon 04-Sept-17 13:47:16

Oh don't make those sort of assumptions lemon - I fully intend to watch it as soon as I have the time.

I will be interested in the leavers comments about it though, as this thread was set up just for that.

lemongrove Mon 04-Sept-17 13:30:47

At least Tegan2 is prepared to watch it though, showing broad mindedness.

lemongrove Mon 04-Sept-17 13:30:00

So, you are right Petra and Remainers will not watch it!?

MaizieD Mon 04-Sept-17 13:23:16

When you've seen it, Tegan, would you be able to tell us its salient points?

I have to confess that I don't want to watch it and the facts that it's an hour out of my life and that the first lot of comments I read said nothing more than the usual abuse of Remainers that I can see every day on twitter or in comments on articles. Plus some hysterical stuff about German plans for world domination and lots of approving comments from US Trump supporters... These put me right off...

Tegan said:

[the bit I've seen so far just seems to think that we should become more like Switzerland]

You might find this twitter thread interesting:

Starts with this tweet (about the Swiss 'deal'):

Nearly all the same priviliges/obligations? De facto membership? Dont know where to start w/this one but ok I will

twitter.com/AllieRenison/status/904323922035867648

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion