Gransnet forums

News & politics

North Korea and US

(171 Posts)
Luckygirl Wed 09-Aug-17 09:33:16

Two raving nutters locking horns - heaven help us all.

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:27:12

Not if it is contained it isn't. That is the lesson some don't understand

petra Fri 11-Aug-17 11:27:31

Give up, * roses* in the nicest possible grin
Your arguing with people who obviously have never read any books written by people who have escaped NK.
And, believe that Kim Jung Un isn't a threat to world peace.

counterpoint Fri 11-Aug-17 11:28:29

Of course NK is not a threat. Why all the posturing? Because that is how you ensure that other people know not to attack you. In what circumstances would it make sense for NK to use its nuclear missiles? None. Yes, they've got them - in their position, I'd want to have them too.

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:29:15

The USA used to understand it, China certainly does as does Russia and the EU. South Korea is crying out for it as is Japan.

Sabre rattling is the complete opposite tonwhat is needed.

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:32:07

Whatever we all think of Trump as POTUS, we also know that NK has been a real worry for decades, and now they have achieved nuclear status, who knows what could happen.
SK must be especially worried.
Sanity will prevail ( hopefully) by both leaders, but 'containing' Kim Jong and cohorts will prove impossible I should think, from now on.

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:32:22

petra I was not arguing about NK and the suffering that it's people are enduring. I am arguing about how to contain NK so that the row does not suffer the result of two silly egos.
If you think that sabre rattling us the way to go then good luck with that.

The rest of the world do not agree thank goodness except perhaps people with big egos like Trump who can't see any further than the end of his penis.

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:33:49

Petra grin....I know!

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:35:29

Can the big ego that is Kim Jong Un see further than the end of his penis ww ?

counterpoint Fri 11-Aug-17 11:36:46

SK should be most worried about action by Trump that precipitates a response from NK, which could be disastrous for both. There is no evidence for NK being a threat. Consider how many countries have been invaded by the USA? And how many countries have been invaded by North Korea?

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:36:47

If you want a discussion about NK politics then go ahead. I think you will understand very quickly that we can easily distinguish between NK as a existential threat to the row and the way they conduct their internal social policy and economy.

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:37:50

rose I doubt that he can see it. Of course, what made you think that I thought otherwise?

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:41:24

The US has to come out with a statement in regards to the threats issued by NK......a difficult balance.
If it is placatory then the US is perceived as weak ( all around the world) if it is equally strongly worded it could be regarded as immflamatory, but many countries, especially in the Far East respect that.

whitewave Fri 11-Aug-17 11:43:08

Blimey rose I am at the banging head against a brick wall stage. I give up.

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:44:29

Hopefully, at this time anyway, a 'show of words' will be enough to satisfy honour on all sides.

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:47:34

Perhaps that applies to us as well ww grin

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 11:48:48

Looking at things differently is alright you know, we can all have another perspective on a problem.

counterpoint Fri 11-Aug-17 11:52:50

It's all this worrying about being perceived as weak that drags people into unnecessary wars. Why worry about it? It is perfectly adequate to say (as is obvious) that the USA is armed to the teeth and attacking it would be unwise. And it is pretty obvious that everybody already knows that. No need for Trump's posturing, nor for sailing nuclear capable warships up and down the Korean peninsular. Isn't that at least as aggressive as anything NK is doing?

Babette Fri 11-Aug-17 12:07:34

The Child POTUS needs deflection from his Russia investigations. Mueller is making progress. The house of Monnafort has been raided. Money laundering.
I have been in the US..at better times. Now the US thanks to this charlatan is a kleptocracy and even more worrying a "family business" run by a Mafia family.
It is extremely worrying, even more though as our PM is his "best friend". I cn only hope that this nightmare ends sooner than later for All our sakes.

keffie Fri 11-Aug-17 12:08:42

And they said that the Bushes were war mongerers! Mind you Trump not just a war mongerer! He is nuts with it

durhamjen Fri 11-Aug-17 12:10:03

Counterpoint, roses has never been and would never be in thatposition. That's why she can't envisage it, and has no sympathy for those who are.

Babette Fri 11-Aug-17 12:11:25

Rosarered....words have consensuses.

durhamjen Fri 11-Aug-17 12:13:25

Sorry, moved on a bit since then.

Why does the UK want nuclear missiles? Same reason NK wants them.
Both silly in my opinion.

rosesarered Fri 11-Aug-17 12:16:11

Keep your uninformed suppositions to yourself perhaps durham
Words are all part of the bluff and double bluff that goes on between countries and governments babette

nigglynellie Fri 11-Aug-17 12:27:40

At least the Americans have the chance to change their leader! pity the poor unfortunate citizens of NK who are stuck with this regime probably for donkeys years. Of course they all cheer and shout, and laugh hysterically, clap their hands till they fall off, prostrate themselves at every opportunity ; if they didn't they'd be dead along with their relations or at the very least in a labour camp for years on end! not sure that that any of that is very likely to happen to anyone in this country under the present government! As you said roses, people in the safety of the west haven't a clue what a true dictatorship is like and we can all consider ourselves extremely fortunate that we don't. A country that treat its own citizens in the way NK does, is capable of anything and we should be very vigilant.

durhamjen Fri 11-Aug-17 12:34:04

www.theguardian.com/world/2017/aug/11/north-korea-us-south-korea-huge-military-exercise

Hope nothing goes wrong here.