Gransnet forums

News & politics

New .years .Honours

(141 Posts)
Anniebach Fri 29-Dec-17 22:50:30

Darcy Bussell. A Dame

Ringo Star. Sir

Barry Gibb. Sir

Nick Clegg. Lord

WilmaKnickersfit Sat 30-Dec-17 23:15:45

nannysue the knighthood was for services to music and charity. Ringo Starr does a lot of work for charity. If you Google him you will see all the causes he supports. He also started a charitable foundation in 2001 with his wife Barbara Bach called the Lotus Foundation and you can read about the causes it supports here

Lotus Foundation

paddyann Sat 30-Dec-17 22:27:07

and thats her choice Annie but its still flawed and corrupt...many "honours" are bought and paid for others got by the back door by toadying to politicians or politicians toadying to get something in return...not MY idea of honourable at all.But whatever you're comfortable with.Like the monarchy its out of date .It only serves to confirm a "class " divide.The I have a title so I'm better than you...like the two Ronnie sketch

nannysue1 Sat 30-Dec-17 21:38:42

What has Ringo Starr done that deserves a knighthood? He was lucky enough to get to play drums with the Beatles and did some voiceover work on the back of that for Thomas the Tank Engine. This completely devalues the honour of a knighthood.

CardiffJaguar Sat 30-Dec-17 21:36:13

The system has been degraded over many years. If it was scrapped now that would mean all those who really do deserve an honour would miss out and that could be particularly sensitive for them looking at all those idiots who have had an honour they do not really deserve. Not an easy problem to resolve.

Anniebach Sat 30-Dec-17 19:51:17

So PaddyAnn, you think the people around the country who have been awarded an honour are either in cahoots with a corrupt system or are proud of something they should be ashamed of because they didn't earn their honour it was a fiddle ?

A member of my extended family, age 101, is pleased to accept hers, she places it second only to being made an honourary Bard , and she is no fool

maddyone Sat 30-Dec-17 19:27:40

Paddyann Totally agree with you, a flawed and corrupt system. It should be done away with.

paddyann Sat 30-Dec-17 19:08:44

only if you believe in the system Annie..a very flawed system at best and corrupt at its worst

Anniebach Sat 30-Dec-17 18:54:04

Sorry I cannot agree W11girl, an honour now to people who work in their community means as much as your friend's meant to her

W11girl Sat 30-Dec-17 18:47:19

My friend was awarded an MBE in 1971 when such things mattered. She received it for her hard work in the local community. These days these things are handed out like sweets and mean little or nothing to the wider population.

WilmaKnickersfit Sat 30-Dec-17 18:40:47

Wikipedia has details of people who refused and why in lots of cases. It is more up to date than the one jen kindly posted. smile

List of people who turned down British honours

Don't know why, but I am surprised Bernice Eccleston refused.

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 18:13:15

Jane, it was said that Roald Dahl did just that, but died before he received the knighthood.

paddyann Sat 30-Dec-17 18:10:48

there is NO British Empire however much the some like to believe there still is...so WHY give out empire medals..its clearly ridiculous .We have enough stupidity over class systems without these stupid honours making some think they are superior beings...I remember a story about a famous actor whose friend called him by his first name ...he refused to answer until his friend ...of many years ...amended the request and called him Sir D....I'd have said bye bye to him and NOT added Sir to that either .

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 17:55:32

Some turn down anything to do with empire but accept a CH later on because they think it's not the same as an empire medal.

Jane10 Sat 30-Dec-17 17:39:46

Interesting list of refusers dj. I see that some refused then the ante was upped and they were offered higher honours and still refused. I wonder if some people refuse eg an OBE and hope to get a knighthood next time round?

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:50:24

www.theguardian.com/public-leaders-network/2017/dec/29/local-government-fire-police-2018-new-year-honours-list

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:39:13

Jon Snow turned one down, then investigated the system.

Having been offered an OBE in 2000, and turned it down at the very least because I was a working journalist, I was motivated to find out more about how the whole thing worked.

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:35:05

It's an outbreak of moaning to beat all others, though, Jalima.
Mention of the honours system does not bring everybody together; some like it, some don't.

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:32:35

This is why Benjamin Zephaniah turned his down.

OBE, me? Up yours, I thought...I get angry when I hear that word “empire”; it reminds me of slavery, it reminds of thousands of years of brutality, it reminds me of how my foremothers were raped and my forefathers brutalised.

Jalima1108 Sat 30-Dec-17 16:29:42

Nooo djen, grumppa mentioned bringing the nation together not tearing it apart!

The weather usually does the trick

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:29:01

I think L S Lowry refused the most over his lifetime.

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:27:53

docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AonYZs4MzlZbdG9mbm5mZGVqVXBmbDRYNkprczM1QUE

A list of refusers for you, Newquay.
There are others.

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 16:23:17

Isn't that brexit, grumppa. That'll go on for ever.

Jalima1108 Sat 30-Dec-17 16:22:59

Yes, it is heartening to know that most honours go to those who are relatively unknown, except perhaps in their local communities.

Perhaps we needed something to bring us all together, grumppa!

Newquay Sat 30-Dec-17 16:19:17

Wonder how a list of refuseniks could be published? Anyone know?

Anniebach Sat 30-Dec-17 16:18:58

Thank you Jalima, so 70% of the honours go to those unknown to us, for me if a pop star gets one and a few politicians then fine, I am happy for the 70%