Gransnet forums

News & politics

Corbyns Torque

(1001 Posts)
Primrose65 Tue 09-Jan-18 12:00:05

A continuation of Momentum and Intertia

www.gransnet.com/forums/news_and_politics/1243288-Corbyns-Inertia

humptydumpty Tue 30-Jan-18 16:16:14

Annie certainly not suggesting TB government was as bad as Maggie, but would still have preferred it to be further left. It would be good if that was a precursor to a more left-leaning LP government IMO

jura2 Tue 30-Jan-18 16:09:53

This really annoyed me today:

'Labour MPs should oppose any Brexit deal that Theresa May puts to parliament this year in order to help trigger a general election and cause her downfall, Len McCluskey, the Unite general secretary, has said.'

Labour should oppose Brexit because it is bad for the UK, and bad for the majority of their members...

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 16:04:20

I don't think the Gordon Brown government (the last labour government) were the same as the Tories AB. I am sorry he did not have the personality we seem to demand these days.

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 15:57:14

humpydumpty, you think the last labour government was the same as the Thatcher years?

Surely not better to have a centre left labour government who gains votes from the tories and the .libs than a far left party who gives votes to the tories and the .Libs ?

If you think the last labour government was the same as the tories best you look up what the country gained under that government and compare it with the Thatcher government

Aspirations are good but power is needed to turn them into reality

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 15:36:27

So you would swap your 'wilderness' for something you don't believe in Annie as long as they won? That surely has to be the worst sort of politics?

I have to agree humpty. Blair appealed to many a conservative - conservative in all but name - and at least didn't have to fight with the minority on the far right who are controlling the current government.

humptydumpty Tue 30-Jan-18 15:28:46

The thing is, was the centre left LP that different from the Conservatives? surely it's more important to have a party representing a desire for social justice than a middle-of-the-road let's-not-rock-the-boat party..

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 15:16:10

And you nightowl have no evidence that the far left can win the next election . All I have done is state facts, the far left gave us the wilderness years, the centre left gave us three elections . perhaps the far left will gain votes in middle England , that is for the future

nightowl Tue 30-Jan-18 14:19:41

The electorate rejected New Labour in 2010 Annie. You have no evidence whatsoever that your version of the LP would win an election now.

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 14:08:11

Primrose ?

Primrose65 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:41:41

I hope it's an open court Annie and someone has the good sense to stream the video.

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:39:59

Ilovecheese, you prefer the wilderness years to a three election win?

Why do you think that is the argument? Oh, of course, it's because you don't believe in putting a view of politics forward only attacking one man. On your basis Annie, if Corbyn were to win three elections you would then start supporting him. At least some people are unhappy because they don't agree with the current LP political position - I think we can all understand that but I cannot understand your vilification campaign of one man as being anything to do with what your politics might be.

Ilovecheese Tue 30-Jan-18 13:33:14

Maybe Haringey could build some more council houses now instead of this PFI nonsense that ends up costing the taxpayer more money.

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 13:28:47

Ilovecheese, you prefer the wilderness years to a three election win?

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 13:27:16

Primrose, I didn't know that about Lansman and Galloway, never thought I would agree with Lansman ? Corbyn as witness ? Hope there is a glass door available, if asked a question he can squeal, run, hide . Who will he support, his very close Comrade or his boss !

Primrose65 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:19:56

Rehouse them where GG?

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:13:46

I hope the people who were going to be rehoused in better accommodation appreciate they are living in dreadful conditions now for the benefit of Lansman.

! Unbelievable. It is the councils job to rehouse them. Nothing but nothing should have stopped them doing that. Talk about using those who have suffered from this dreadful event for political purposes. I am quite disgusted by this comment.

Ilovecheese Tue 30-Jan-18 13:10:40

But like GracesGranMK2 says, it was also a difficult decision for those of us who didn't like the way that the party changed under New Labour. Our views should not be dismissed as "Corbynistas" or similar taunts.
There is not one right way here, just different opinions.

Primrose65 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:09:16

The leader of Haringey has quit. It's a shame, she was eloquent, measured and was focused on solving problems.

"Political issues are rarely binary, solutions are not simply good or bad. Political leadership is about setting a vision and working to deliver on it using whatever tools are available."

I hope the people who were going to be rehoused in better accommodation appreciate they are living in dreadful conditions now for the benefit of Lansman. People who think Momentum and Corbyn will benefit the poor or the working class are totally deluded.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/claire-kober-quits-labour-left-jeremy-corbyn-victory-haringey-council-leader-latest-a8185101.html

Primrose65 Tue 30-Jan-18 13:02:40

Jon Lansman has said there is no place for George Galloway in the LP. Perhaps there will be a bun fight over that too!

And there is! George Galloway has instructed solicitors to sue Lansman for defamation and is going to use Corbyn as a witness. I'm sure Corbyn will condemn and support all sides but I'm stocking up on popcorn! grin grin grin

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 12:48:31

The far left drove the party into the wilderness years, the Blair government won three elections

Anniebach Tue 30-Jan-18 12:46:14

It is very difficult Primrose , one which many long standing members are facing, I am torn between the fact there are still good labour MP's who care for the party and those who want to kill the party and form a communist party.

Primrose65 Tue 30-Jan-18 12:36:49

It will be interesting gillybob. I have my suspicions that the great one is not really JC at all.

gillybob Tue 30-Jan-18 12:21:04

I’m attending a meeting in a few weeks time. It has been called by the LP in our town who are very split. Our MP is very pro-Corbyn and the traditionalists ( of which I was once one) are very worried about Momentum who seem to be casting off anyone who disagrees with the great one. Should be interesting .

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 12:19:11

It's such a shame that you've been put in a position where you feel the need to decide.

I imagine you feel equal sympathy for those who had the party changed from under them by Annie and the Blairites too Primrose. Or is what's sauce for the goose something we should cry about when it affects the gander?

GracesGranMK2 Tue 30-Jan-18 12:15:50

Greater and different experience humpty. We have had leaders who needed matchsticks to add up in the past.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion