Gransnet forums

News & politics

UK-France summit.

(52 Posts)
Fennel Thu 18-Jan-18 18:17:08

A debate is starting on France24. The main issue seems to be UK's contribution to the Calais refugee problem

paddyann Thu 18-Jan-18 22:20:40

whats the choice ,pay France to deal with the problem or let all the folk at Calais flood across and build shelters and immigration centres here to deal with them...that'll really keep the Brexiteers happy......not! With the added chance of immigrants going walkabout when they arrive here .

Fennel Fri 19-Jan-18 12:18:08

Most of the programme was taken up by live recording of the speeches of the two leaders.
May's was obviously read from pages in front of her. Macron probably had notes, but rarely looked at them. So came across as more sincere and impressive.

Nonnie Fri 19-Jan-18 12:48:08

Easier for Macron to come across as confident, he has a big majority.

eazybee Fri 19-Jan-18 13:08:24

Of course he is sincere and impressive; he wants to continue France's record of doing as little as possible to help the refugee crisis.

lemongrove Fri 19-Jan-18 13:14:20

Am I right in thinking you live in France Fennel ?

Exactly eazybee wanting more money yet for evicting immigrants that France should be dealing with.
OK, these people don’t want to live in France, but they are there and it’s up to France to either offer them a home or send them back.We already do lots there to help.
The French authorities should never have allowed the tent encampments to get so huge.

paddyann Fri 19-Jan-18 14:20:32

or maybe "BRITISH" borders should be on british soil ....not up to France or anyone else to deal with people who want to come here .Isn't that what voters wanted ... a say on everything that affected them ?

Welshwife Fri 19-Jan-18 15:28:58

France does do a surprising amount for the refugees and asylum seekers. They have various camps and settlement areas in different parts of the country. Those who do not wish to settle in France simply migrate again to Calais and try their luck with the lorries.
Many of them actually want to go to Germany or Scandinavia - more than are trying to get to U.K. Those who have French as their main or secondary language do want to stay in France - which is many from African countries. Those who want to get to U.K. have English as a second language or relatives already living in U.K.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 15:33:19

It is utterly amazing.

Brexiters want to stop immigration and yet not prepared to take responsibility in policing our borders. Our customs staff are all on the French side, if I was Macron I would suggest that they all went back to their own country and dealt with the problem there.

The refugees didn’t fly into France but passed through other countries to arrive at Calais. It is solely France’s problem it s Europe’s. But we are busy leaving so must take sole responsibility, for those migrants aiming to get into the U.K.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 15:33:57

It isn’t solely

MaizieD Fri 19-Jan-18 15:38:14

OK, these people don’t want to live in France, but they are there and it’s up to France to either offer them a home or send them back.

Oh, for heaven's sake! If there weren't a dirty great expanse of water between us and France they would be here in the UK. That's where they want to be. Why on earth you think they should be solely France's responsibility is beyond me.

ninny Fri 19-Jan-18 15:43:05

Yes but there is a dirty great expanse of water and they are in France so the French should deal with them.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 15:47:47

No! ninny so let’s bring back the border to the U.K. as it should be and then see who should deal with them.

Fennel Fri 19-Jan-18 16:32:34

There have been many reports in our local papers (SW France) of individuals and councils in small towns and villages offering to give homes to these refugees.
They're taken there from Calais by bus, a few agree to accept the hospitality, but others want to go to the big cities. Or back to Calais for the UK.
I think it's partly due to the fact that they're more likely to speak english than french.
French people have tried, here, anyway.

MaizieD Fri 19-Jan-18 16:35:57

...they are in France so the French should deal with them.

Nothing to do with racism, of course...

MaizieD Fri 19-Jan-18 16:38:14

We just don't want these foreigners here, do we...

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 16:54:25

They are the cause of all our ills you should know that maize

ninny Sat 20-Jan-18 08:14:11

?

MaizieD Sat 20-Jan-18 08:19:09

The feeling is mutual, ninny.

suzied Sat 20-Jan-18 08:19:15

Maybe the French should just stick all the migrants on boats and send them of to England as thats where they want to be. Then we would have huge refugee camps in Dover. Is that what Brexiteers would want? Surely it’s in the interests of the U.K. to have secure borders in Calais and we should contribute to that.

MaizieD Sat 20-Jan-18 08:25:04

If I were French that's one way of dealing with the migrants that I might think would look pretty good, suzied....

Mamie Sat 20-Jan-18 09:00:58

I second what has been said about huge efforts to settle people throughout France. Have seen it locally and in all the papers.
I do think this business about the “border” in France is a red herring though. The UK “border” is only in France in Calais, Dunkirk and Paris and the French “border” is in the UK at Dover and London, but in fact what you are talking about are juxtaposed border controls which make it easier to drive straight off the other end.
In several other ports along the French coast, the French border control is in France and the UK border control in the UK.
You still can't travel without passport / ticket / visa (if needed) so I don't see how migrants could just be put on a boat. The ferry companies would pay huge fines if they had allowed anyone to travel illegally.
I sometimes think the newspapers give the impression of a Trump style wall in Calais.
The costs are actually about protecting the ferry port.

MaizieD Sat 20-Jan-18 11:04:25

I sometimes think the newspapers give the impression of a Trump style wall in Calais.

That's certainly the impression I have...

You still can't travel without passport / ticket / visa (if needed) so I don't see how migrants could just be put on a boat.

I was thinking more in terms of chartering a boat wink

But as this really isn't a serious idea the detail is kind of irrelevant...

felice Sat 20-Jan-18 15:03:36

we have similar problems here in Belguim with refugees etc wanting to get to the UK. They can register here but do not want to seeing the UK as the promised land.
I was rolling through the DM online this morning, I like to get the various views of the different papers.
There was a very small item pointing out that if the French tightened the controls there, they would try to cross from 'Brussels', need a lesson in Geography I think.
The main problem here is almost in the city centre, with a few hundred people camped out in a city park, and there was a major incident recently when shots were fired when lorries were attacked near the ports. There is a bit of bitterness towards the UK as we are seen as having to deal with their problem, after all that is where they want to go.
UK border controls are also on Belgian soil and I know people would like to see them moved to the UK.
Why does the UK not want to take responsibility for these people?

MaizieD Sat 20-Jan-18 15:07:29

Why does the UK not want to take responsibility for these people?

Perhaps ninny could answer that question for you. She is sure they're not our responsibility.

As a Brit living in the UK I am just as puzzled as you...