Gransnet forums

News & politics

Corbyn and Momentum

(1001 Posts)
lemongrove Wed 21-Feb-18 22:33:26

Hopefully this will be about politics and news only ,with no personal remarks or attempts to stifle.

Jon Lansman is more dangerous than Corbyn, at least at the moment.

Grandad1943 Thu 01-Mar-18 21:32:59

If you wish to see how ideological thinking can seriously damage a country just look to the conservatives idol Maggie Thatcher. I believe almost all the most serious problems this country has now can be laid at her goverments door, such as the housing crisis, low wages, the gig economy, social mobility to name but a few.

The polices expanded by Jeremy Corbyn would look to redress many of the above problems that were caused by her government

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:59:25

ww feel free to say how marvellous you think Jeremy Corbyn is, and I will feel free to say what an absolute plonker he is.The thread is for all.?

durhamjen Thu 01-Mar-18 20:57:51

I get the impression that even Lansman will vote for her.

bmacca Thu 01-Mar-18 20:54:27

Some of the ridiculous reporting in the MSM is helping Momentum recruitment, whitewave, which is probably not what they intended! It's interesting that whilst Lansman is respected by many, he is not particularly well-liked. Most Labour people I've spoken to this week would support Jennie Murray for General Secretary.

GracesGranMK2 Thu 01-Mar-18 20:48:42

... but implementing policies simply for ideological reasons leads to all kinds of madness.

We know. We are in the middle (or hopefully towards the end) of that madness.

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:48:18

There isn’t much else to ask about nightowl except Corbyn. There’s nothing positive to argue about the Tory government or Brexit so this is all that is left and the same stuff gets regurgitated time and time again.

Key words are

Communism
Marxism
Student loans
Venezuela
Spy - oh no I forgot that was a lie
GFA/IRA - oh no I forgot again that was a lie as well

Anyway I’m sure you get the drift

GracesGranMK2 Thu 01-Mar-18 20:43:47

Thank bmacca. It helps me get a flavour of what Momentum are interested in.

nightowl Thu 01-Mar-18 20:42:09

Jeremy Corbyn said he would abolish tuition fees for students going forward. He said he would ‘look at’ ways of reducing or ameliorating student debt for existing students and graduates. Why is that so hard to understand? And since the Labour Party did not win the general election, I don’t see how he can be said to have lied or gone back on his word.

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:40:37

Momentum had over 700 new members last week so far this week 360 new members.

It is the same week after week

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:37:40

bmacca yes that is right. Momentum has been holding these meetings all over the country for weeks now and the outcome will mean that labour members will have real input to labour policy.

.democracy in action

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:35:46

Students really thought that if Corbyn got in then there would be no or little tuition fees.
So much was promised to them which would never have happened.
Gentler, kinder politics!!

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:35:02

Oh I’m glad I misunderstood I thought you’d lost it for a minute.

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:33:10

I did say ‘we are not that country’ WW but implementing policies simply for ideological reasons leads to all kinds of madness.

durhamjen Thu 01-Mar-18 20:31:31

I think wally was wrong and I was right.
The link I posted from was Jalima's which you obviously haven't read.

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:30:55

bmacca......don’t hold your breath on that one!

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:29:39

Oh lemon you aren’t seriously comparing the U.K. with Venezuela. Do you know anything at all about Venezuelan history - that is a ridiculous statement.

Jalima1108 Thu 01-Mar-18 20:29:23

So intelligent people current students and graduates alike are starting to realise that the free education utopia might be a little further from their grasp than they were led to believe in the run up to the 2017 general election. were in fact 'led up the garden path' by obfuscation and weasel words?

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:29:16

Hopefully students will realise it is all hot air.Politics eh?

durhamjen Thu 01-Mar-18 20:29:05

Those who will rejoice?
The homeless; students; those on zero hours contracts; those on minimum wage; those on hospital waiting lists; those EU citizens working here who do not know if they will be able to keep their jobs; CBI; EU; housebuilders; car companies.

Please feel free to add to the list.

bmacca Thu 01-Mar-18 20:28:32

GracesGran, the Momentum questions are rather too lengthy to reproduce here. They cover a wide range of issues from Disability representation, Charter of members' rights, Code of Ethics, CLP governance, Recruitment, and parliamentary selection. Although Lansman has previously talked about deselection, Momentum proposals are about a democratic selection process. I doubt that any sitting MP who has the support of their CLP, members & affiliates would have much to worry about if these proposals were to become Labour Party rules

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:27:58

Thank you Jalima I was going to look for that ( Labour and tuition fees)
I think you were wrong dj and Wally was right.

whitewave Thu 01-Mar-18 20:26:42

Anyone seen the Hercules a new war plane a gunship being used by America!! shock

Imagine the awful destruction it is quite dreadful

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:25:11

Are we onto CND now? ?

lemongrove Thu 01-Mar-18 20:24:10

On GN Grandad we have a policy of no really personal attacks on other posters,but politicians are fair game.
You will find just the same on any thread that enjoys Tory bashing.
Simply because you may enjoy the prospect of a Corbyn and McDonnell led government doesn’t mean that anyone else has to ( although, as you have seen on here, some do and some don’t.)
It certainly isn’t just Corbyn the man that I and others
object to, but what his far left policies would lead to.
McDonnell never likes to give figures, but has already said he would borrow massively.
If far left policies are implemented because of ideology, you have seen what this leads to in Venezuela.
We are not that country ( to start with) but many fear what harm could be done post Brexit to our economy with him at the helm.
Of course, if the electorate vote that way, then they do, but where you and others may rejoice, many do not!

durhamjen Thu 01-Mar-18 20:23:58

"So while the Labour Party haven’t made a u-turn on one of their key manifesto pledges, current students and graduates alike are starting to realise that the free education utopia might be a little further from their grasp than they were led to believe in the run up to the 2017 general election. But that doesn’t mean that they should turn away from Labour."

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion