Gransnet forums

News & politics

If there was another EU referendum...

(1001 Posts)
Pollaidh Tue 03-Jul-18 18:13:46

Would those who voted Leave still do so? And why? I am genuinely trying to look outside my Remain bubble, but the logic of Leave still continues to elude me. I am asking Gransnet because apparently older people were most likely to vote to Leave.

nigglynellie Mon 06-Aug-18 12:41:40

If a referendum is likely to give a result that a government can't possibly agree with and will override, then why in gods name have it in the first place?! An exercise to prove?????? A chance to???? waste money, cause discord, family rifts, look totally dishonest to the point that no one will ever believe one word any politician ever promises ever again? An overridden referendum would be a completely pointless, expensive decisive exercise. Why on earth ask an opinion of others, when you've already reached it and intend to act upon it regardless?!!

lemongrove Mon 06-Aug-18 12:09:32

If that’s what you think too Varian better get your bunker well stocked now.
Some of us think that’s arrant nonsense.

varian Mon 06-Aug-18 11:58:23

The utter nonsense of a leaver accusing remainers of promoting anarchy reminded me of an article by Iain Macwhirter in The Herald last year entitled :"Why Tory Brexit spells Anarchy for the UK" in which he concluded_

"This unilateralist project is of course complete madness – a romantic, neo-imperialist fantasy. The infantile delusion of reactionaries who can't come to terms with the real world of rules-based international relations. But the clock is ticking, and who's to say they won't achieve their Johnny Rotten goal of anarchy in the UK."

www.heraldscotland.com/opinion/15597163.Why_Tory_Brexit_spells_Anarchy_for_the_UK/

Almost a year on this danger is even more real. When vehicles are stuck in a twenty-mile traffic jam, medicines become unobtainable, supermarket shelves and food banks start to empty, flights are grounded, our security compromised and yet the rabid right wing tabloids still foment unrest by blaming everything on immigrants, "enemies of the people" and the EU, then it is likely that civil unrest could soon develop into anarchy. Who on earth would ever have voted for that?

MamaCaz Mon 06-Aug-18 11:36:51

Well spotted, MaizieD!

MaizieD Mon 06-Aug-18 11:33:17

Good heavens, wondering what among the hogwash is worthy of any response at all but this one wins Gnet today:

Much better than the short vituperative posts, sometimes as many as ten in a row to clog up the thread, from people who were possibly recalled to Moscow,

Moscow is supporting Leave, not Remain.

Bridgeit Mon 06-Aug-18 10:11:46

As , has been said many times before by ,The ridiculousness of holding such a momentous referendum with so few Facts available was irresponsible beyond belief.
Some of you are absolutely certain you know how great everything will be, nothing to worry about at all, we will all prosper,whilst standing on the deck of a ship called Rule Britannia waving a uanion Jack .Others take a more pragmatic view realising that the long reaching tentacles of the EU,(good & bad) will take many years to untangle & straighten out. Then & only then can we begin to Mould our country which is good for The Many, Not the Few !! To believe otherwise is pointless, what frightens me the most is the absolutely blinkered certainty on both sides that they are right,but there is no right or wrong . Either way this country will survive and adapt, but we need to remember it was an emotive vote ,that is why there will always be discontent, because there is no Promised Land.

varian Mon 06-Aug-18 10:07:12

I recommend going on the Mumsnet Brexit threads to see an overwhelming amount of serious comments about the state our country has been brought to.

SingingBabooshkaBadly Mon 06-Aug-18 08:04:26 posted-

"Surely May needs to find the guts to stand up and say ‘This isn’t working. This is not what people voted for. They didn't Vote to destroy our economy. They didn’t vote to destroy the NHS. They didn’t vote to increase hardship on the most vulnerable in society and to reduce the living standard for all but the very wealthiest. They voted because they were promised life would be better out of the EU than in. This cannot be achieved. It impossible to deliver what people believed they were voting for and Brexit will deliver the exact opposite of what was promised. Brexit will be an act of National suicide and we therefore will not be delivering it."

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/eu_referendum_2016_/3324439-Westminstenders-In-the-Brexit-Lane?pg=13

No MP, no government, no PM should ever willfully permit our country to drift into such a dangerous situation. It is their patriotic duty to prevent such irrevocable harm and if parliament cannot be trusted to protect our future then it is essential that when the terms are known, the people are allowed to vote on whether to accept them or whether to withdraw Article 50 and Remain in the EU.

As David Davis said "a democracy is not a democracy if it cannot change its mind"

bee63 Mon 06-Aug-18 08:39:50

If we didn't have 'risk-takers' we would not have entrepreneurs, emigrants - and no-one would have ever discovered the New World!! Or ever stood on the Moon

^ this.

Allygran1 I am really enjoying your posts and learning a lot for them. I’m also not sure why some people are complaining about your long c&p posts. Have you been on the mumsnet Brexit board? Remainers do nothing but post very long ( mostly c&p’d stuff ) all the time.

eazybee Mon 06-Aug-18 08:38:18

I enjoy reading the long posts, when they are factual and informative, not personal or aggressive.
Much better than the short vituperative posts, sometimes as many as ten in a row to clog up the thread, from people who were possibly recalled to Moscow, although I think have spotted at least one posting under a new name.

petra Mon 06-Aug-18 08:37:16

If anyone is still pondering as to how good/bad things are I would suggest visiting the Gov.UK website.
Heading.
" More good news for British businesses as export growth continues"

lemongrove Mon 06-Aug-18 08:24:27

Some of us enjoy reading....and don’t find anything too ‘hard’ to read.Ally posts interesting and informative comments/articles and always quotes her sources in a true academic way ( unlike some.)

crystaltipps Mon 06-Aug-18 08:19:41

Yes I do read a lot thank you, but just dip in and out of GN for the odd 10 minutes here and there so no time to read huge posts which are usually cut n paste from Wikipedia or repetitive rants and could be easily cut down to a short paragraph. I do object to being labelled inaccurately. But that seems to be certain posters’ MO. I doubt if even those posters who agree with the long winded posts read every one either.

lemongrove Mon 06-Aug-18 08:09:03

Allygran there are some who won’t read posts simply because they don’t agree and some who claim they are too long to read ( what, one page from a book?) In fact I wonder if they read much at all.
Of course wealthy people with vested interests in the EU are doing all they can to overturn the referendum results, they won’t succeed though.

crystaltipps Mon 06-Aug-18 06:49:30

Get your facts right- your definition of anarchist is inappropriate as a label to fling at anyone who doesn’t agree with you. It suggests a specific political persuasion that wishes there to be no centralised (or any) government or laws. Not just those who point out the incompetence of the present government which we are fully entitled to do. I would like there to be a more effective government who work for the interests of the whole country not just the extremists in the Tory party. Sorry I haven’t read your long posts as life is too short.

Allygran1 Mon 06-Aug-18 01:49:39

Maisie what would be the point of a private answer to a public question. I am sure crystaltipps will respond eventually now she/he has seen your reply.

Allygran1 Mon 06-Aug-18 01:43:04

No no no MaizieD.

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 21:39:50
"^If we didn't have 'risk-takers' we would not have entrepreneurs, emigrants - and no-one would have ever discovered the New World!! Or ever stood on the Moon^"

You responded to that post with:

Those were risks which were taken by individuals or a collection of like minded individuals and, IMO, has absolutely no comparison with voting Leave. Real risk takers, had they found life in the EU so utterly intolerable, would have packed up and gone to a country which had nothing to do with the EU^^Not selfishly involved other 'non risk takers' in their decision.

Now let us examine what you are saying here. In this Sovereign Nation a vote was held, two votes in fact under UK Law and UK Democratic majority voting system. The majority of people voted in both elections to leave the EU. Now your argument is:

Real risk takers, had they found life in the EU so utterly intolerable, would have packed up and gone to a country which had nothing to do with the EU^^Not selfishly involved other 'non risk takers' in their decision.

You miss the point the majority vote in two elections was to leave. Call those voters "risk takers" or Leave voters or both, the point is that we the UK, the British people, under our laws, democratic majority voting system accept, accept the majority vote. We all leave! If you as an individual then feel so strongly about that majority vote, it is you as you describe the remain voter "a non risk taker" who should, as you put it: "^packed up^" surely, and go to a country which had nothing to do with the UK.

You seem to have lost the sense of where you live, your sense of accepting the majority vote. That is how this Country makes it's decisions, within the Law. How you can tell those people who voted to leave the EU in two majority vote election's that they should have "^packed up and gone to a country which had nothing to do with the EU^" is mind boggling.

I hate to say this but it needs saying, that it is about time that those who are still using the name of the Remain voter in an attempt to overthrow this Government, this Country's Democratic majority voting system, and attempting to de-stablize our Parliamentary system, through organised activist, on-line propaganda and infiltration of opinion sites, subversive activities such as Fake News, misinformation, scaremongering and generally attempting to do this Country down, are not the ordinary remain voters, in fact they are being infiltrated by far left organisations to de-stabilize our basic values, our democracy, our laws. They will fail.

Even using the name Remainers by these groups has to a large extent been dropped for fear that there will be some retaliation from the genuine remain voter. These groups are self styling now as Pro Europe, and even Peoples Vote. That tells me that they are now trying to appear to represent all the People, well they do not represent me, they don't even represent my neighbours who voted remain, nor I suspect do they represent the majority of remain voters in the Towns and Cities of the Great Britain.

Some wealthy and powerful people who do not want us to leave the EU are putting so much money into trying to over throw democracy in this Country that one would think that even an activist would ask WHY? Why are they spending so much money? What is in it for them? We never hear why they want to stay in the EU only why we should not leave, and that is generally confined to how many lorries will be stacking up at Dover, will it mean I need a visa to go and see my family in France, Germany, Switzerland? Will my grandchildren be able to come to see me in the UK without a visa? Oh! I will have to show my passport on the boat, plane and train. Show your passport!, HEAVENS TO MURGATROYD! If people need visa's get visa's! If the lorries are stacked at Dover, well you tell me when they are not. As for the 'risk taker" and the 'non risk taker' labels, all I can say is that we are all in it together, like it or not Maizie. There may be hiccups along the way, but whatever Brexit brings, it won't bring down our Banking system the stress test of last week showed we can cope with dropping house prices, higher interest rates etc and the Banks can deal with the worst of scenarios. We have full employment almost, we have more positive business attitudes to a free world wide market, and to be frank I hope we go for the WTO option. But because believe in the Executive power of the Government when I vote, I will accept the deal that our negotiator do. That is how our democracy works Maizie.

The UK Government if any one wants to see just how organised they are and how ready they are only need to go on the Department for Exiting the EU website and it's all there. Go to the House of Commons Library site and see the white papers for every major department including Agriculture and Fisheries, and for our Green people you will see just how much of our farming industry will be 'going pesticide free, and ridding ourselves of neonicotinoid pesticides that kill our pollinator populations including Bees. It is down to that sort of detail. Not just organised ready. Maisie READ the hundreds of documents that our negotiating teams have already agreed, 80% according to Bernier. Sorry to shout but I am so cross at Maizies remark that we leavers should go to another Country outside the EU!! We are in a Country that is outside the EU, the United Kingdom of Great Britain as of March 2019.

Maizie I find your thinking at odd's with mine there is nothing new in that,but your post about leave voters going to another Country outside the EU is a peculiarity too far. I just can't see how you don't get the fact that we voted twice, we are a majority democratic voting system and we all accept the majority vote. We all Leave the EU. I am staggered by your comments about leavers going to another Country.

MaizieD Mon 06-Aug-18 01:20:38

P.S. If you want a private answer from someone I suggest that you DM them. Otherwise anyone is free to comment on you posts.

MaizieD Mon 06-Aug-18 01:19:16

Jeerz, Ally. what on earth have you been reading?

Do tell me more about this misinformation, fake news and scaremongering. The most scared person I know of is a committed Leaver who has been campaigning for Leave since we joined the EEC.

And do tell me what laws these wicked conspirators are ignoring and overturning.

I've already explained to you how democracy works, have another look and tell me how it is being subverted.

I do hope you didn't contribute to lawbreaker Darren Grimes' crowdfunding appeal.

Allygran1 Mon 06-Aug-18 00:09:46

MD the pro Europe groups and others including the wealthy and ex Politician's funding activities, such as infiltration of sites like this one, not this one of course! Plus propaganda of misinformation, fake news, scaremongering, in fact they are using every means possible to be able to ignore and overturn our current laws and rules of democratic majority to stay in the EU's pocket, including attempts to bring down a legally elected Government. Is this not rejecting laws and rules? Is that not anarchical? .

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 23:15:30
Sorry, the 'fact' being that anarchists reject laws and rules.
chrystaltipps you said that without you key board tapping!

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 23:15:30

Sorry, the 'fact' being that anarchists reject laws and rules.

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 23:14:28

Anarchist, I believe the label was, Ally

Have you found any of those laws we're breaking yet?

Allygran1 Sun 05-Aug-18 22:43:43

crystaltipps Sun 05-Aug-18 16:19:27
If you are going to sling mud and pin labels on people it helps to get your facts right.

Which facts are these crystaltipps?

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 21:46:34

People voted Leave for all sorts of reasons, some of which I almost understand. But to preen themselves about being "risk takers' is one of the most idioticly selfish I've encountered.

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 21:42:59

While they say soothingly "It's fine, the wall will get out of the way. It'll give in at the last moment"

MaizieD Sun 05-Aug-18 21:39:50

"If we didn't have 'risk-takers' we would not have entrepreneurs, emigrants - and no-one would have ever discovered the New World!! Or ever stood on the Moon"

Those were risks which were taken by individuals or a collection of like minded individuals and, IMO, has absolutely no comparison with voting Leave. Real risk takers, had they found life in the EU so utterly intolerable, would have packed up and gone to a country which had nothing to do with the EU. Not selfishly involved other 'non risk takers' in their decision.

My Remain vote had nothing to do with risk aversion. But I, and no doubt many others, feel as though I have been forced into a car with a manic driver and am powerless to do anything as we drive straight towards a brick wall at 90mph.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion