Gransnet forums

News & politics

So much for controlling immigration!

(132 Posts)
notentirelyallhere Wed 11-Sept-19 17:56:58

Sorry, hot potato, can't resist posting nevertheless :

Record number of migrants cross Channel to UK in single day

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2019/sep/11/record-number-of-migrants-cross-channel-to-uk-in-single-day?

1000+ so far this year apparently.

growstuff Thu 12-Sept-19 13:12:34

I don't suppose the rise in numbers trying to reach the UK in unseaworthy boats has anything to do with the end of summer and the thought that the seas will be even more unhospitable in winter hmm

EllanVannin Thu 12-Sept-19 13:01:45

No arrangements/facilities were ever met when we agreed to take in refugees. No homes. No medical support. No checks for diseases,etc. Young men posing as teenagers and nobody noticing ( rolls eyes )

No organisation whatsoever that you just get to a stage where you couldn't care less what happens now. I've given up thinking that those involved with the settlement of these people hadn't got the sense they were born with. The problem lies with the powers that be who opened the door for them in the first place.

It ain't my problem ! As long as it doesn't interfere with my way of life, people can come and go as they like.

EllanVannin Thu 12-Sept-19 12:46:44

Fennel, borders will close after 31st of October. Why do you think that more are risking their lives ? Others always know these things before we do, but since it's already been said on the news, word has spread rapidly.

crystaltipps Thu 12-Sept-19 12:44:54

Which EU country did “that African woman” come from?

growstuff Thu 12-Sept-19 12:43:45

Leaving the EU will not affect people from non-EU countries arriving for NHS treatment, nor will affect the number of illegal immigrants from countries such as Albania.

In any case, the amount spent by NHS on people who aren't eligible is tiny as a percentage of the NHS budget. By definition, we don't know how many "illegal" immigrants are in the country, but again it's tiny compared with the number who are here legally.

I really don't understand the logic. It's on par with the dingbat on YouTube, who claimed on the day after Brexit that all Muslims would now be "sent home".

mcem Thu 12-Sept-19 12:36:48

The oft-repeated phrase "Not all leave voters are racists but all racists voted leave" is still proving true.

JenniferEccles Thu 12-Sept-19 12:35:34

Does anyone remember that case of some African woman who turned up here pregnant with quads. They were born here which cost the NHS many thousands. She has now gone back having not paid a penny and the authorities have no idea where she is.

I guess though we should be thankful she left or doubtless she would now be in a council house here claiming benefits.

WHY are we such a soft touch?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 12-Sept-19 12:31:40

EllanVannin, innanswer tomyour post "what other excuse did you have for voting, answers on a postage stamp"

Myself and others who voted leave actually done a lot of research on the EU "governing body" the vast amount of money wasted by moving parliaments frequently, expense accounts, gilt edged pensions, fraudulent claims etc.

The EU as it stands has got too big and is failing a lot of its member states. Greece, Italy, Spain even France and Germany are seeing a downturn.

Fennel Thu 12-Sept-19 12:31:16

"-before the border closes in this country !"
In practice, how do you think this can be done, EllanVanin?
We'll always be accessible via hundreds of miles of sea coast.
Not enough maritime patrols to police our island.

crystaltipps Thu 12-Sept-19 12:29:37

They don’t “all” want to come here. Plenty want to go elsewhere.

rebbonk Thu 12-Sept-19 12:27:01

Since when has France been an 'unsafe' country that people needed to flee from fearing for their lives?

These are no longer refugees.

JenniferEccles Thu 12-Sept-19 12:22:12

And then we have idiotic doctors who don’t agree with charging people from overseas for their treatment.

No wonder they all want to come here.

crystaltipps Thu 12-Sept-19 12:00:45

The U.K. has been a bit of a soft touch as we don’t have ID cards/ registration as they do in other European countries. Our governments have been too mean/ lax and couldn’t be ar*ed to implement the available controls . The people smuggling gangs should be sorted out via cooperation between EU countries, but again the U.K. can’t be ar*sed to do that. Leaving the EU won’t make the slightest change to that despite what the Farages of this world say.

Fiachna50 Thu 12-Sept-19 11:54:10

I think some people voted Leave not because they objected to people coming here, just that they wanted control over the numbers arriving here and to know who was arriving here. The bit I do not understand is why are people from say Vietnam and the Phillipines classed as asylum seekers? To my knowledge there is no war etc. What are they seeking asylum from? Perhaps this will start a meaningful discussion. Id like to add I did not mean to cause confusion with my post. I really wanted to say there is a big difference between refugees, asylum-seekers and economic migrants.

JenniferEccles Thu 12-Sept-19 11:33:39

The important point to remember here is that those migrants attempting to enter our country illegally by boat have already passed through several European countries.

This then makes a complete nonsense of their claims that they are asylum seekers. If that were the case they should have applied for asylum in the first safe country they reached, as the rules state, but as we all know, they want to live in the 'soft touch' UK.

I don't know how many times it needs to be said, but we are a tiny country and cannot continue to house hundreds of thousands of immigrants each year.

They will continue to flood in here though, as long as we conveniently provide a water taxi service.

EllanVannin Thu 12-Sept-19 10:55:26

Voting Brexit was tantamount to being racist ! What other reason did you have for voting ? Answers on a postage stamp !

EllanVannin Thu 12-Sept-19 10:53:54

No thanks to those who voted for Brexit, these refugees will risk their lives between now and October 31st----before the border closes in this country !!

MaizieD Thu 12-Sept-19 10:32:59

Do you think people were duped into believing that leaving the EU may stop immigrants, coming here?

I always had a suspicion that Brexit would mean that the French would be very 'relaxed' about preventing refugees crossing the channel to the UK... Why on earth should they continue to put themselves out for a country that has flounced from the EU?

Gonegirl Thu 12-Sept-19 10:32:16

I think the leavers voted that because they wanted fewer immigrants, and some would have had racist reasons
But some would have thought they were doing what was best for the economy. You can't call all leavers racist.

MaizieD Thu 12-Sept-19 10:29:25

The difference between economic migrants and refugees is another discussion altogether.

Absolutely right, Fiachna50, but it's one which needs to be had again (because we have had it on here in the past)

I'm sure that the OP had the best of intentions but muddying the waters by calling asylum seekers/refugees 'immigrants' was not helpful. We do control immigration from non-EU countries and we could have done far more to control 'immigration' via Freedom of Movement.

crystaltipps Thu 12-Sept-19 10:08:15

Let’s face it, Brexit was always about immigration not the economy. There’s plenty of evidence for that. As for having our fair share- Germany, France, Sweden have far more asylum seekers than the U.K.

Lessismore Thu 12-Sept-19 09:49:41

petra, the hilarity continues.

Would anybody care to comment on immigration and Brexit?

Does anybody feel there was some element of racism in some people wishing to leave the EU?

Do you think people were duped into believing that leaving the EU may stop immigrants, coming here?

GagaJo Wed 11-Sept-19 21:50:41

I am friends with a lovely asylum seeker family. Wonderful, kind, strong, intelligent mum, fantastic, hard-working, clever, quiet, beautiful 16 yr old. Very sweet 5 year old. Dad, a professional in their own country, unable to work until their case is resolved.

She was a teacher and he was a publisher. The 4 of them are living in a squalid, tiny, 2 bed flat. But are very happy to be here and be safe with their children.

I wish I could help them.

notentirelyallhere Wed 11-Sept-19 21:21:18

Sorry, didn't mean to be so fierce. Of course it's Brexit related. I saw a post the other day where someone quoted the irony of her elderly, anti-immigration, Leave - voting parents being looked after in their last days by foreign medical staff. Sad.

I think we're going to be worse off in so many ways. Not least as a result of the richness brought by other languages on our streets and the benefits of other culture's ways and food choices. It's made us so much more relaxed and less insular. I've also employed my share of Eastern European plumbers, builders and handymen , all of whom worked fantastically hard for good rates and who were a pleasure to have around.

petra Wed 11-Sept-19 21:04:19

but i'll bet you absolutely nobody will have the guts to say so
Well here goes, deep breath. This is a Brexit related thread
There, I did it.
Now I can't get Kirk Douglas out of my head.