Gransnet forums

News & politics

should Corbyn and Watson both resign - or just lose the election?

(65 Posts)
jura2 Wed 30-Oct-19 11:52:57

discuss - I am pretty sure Corbyn cannot win this election.

Grany Wed 30-Oct-19 15:42:37

Agree with what you said trisher

trisher Wed 30-Oct-19 15:39:33

So let's ditch the old established bloke in favour of what? A younger more professional politician? I think a lot of people have had enough of them. Look at the track record on every main political party. Labour had Tony Blair, the Tories had Cameron and the Lib Dems Clegg. They've all moved on to pastures new with more money, leaving a mess behind them. Corbyn isn't doing it as a stepping stone to a more lucrative career he's doing it because he's a socialist and he cares about people. As for all the remarks about his looks, he's old. It's ageism to criticise hm for that. If it were anyone else GNers would be shouting out about it. As it is it seems anything can be said about him. It is weird that older people can criticise someone for being old!

Grany Wed 30-Oct-19 15:38:58

It's time for real change

twitter.com/PeterStefanovi2/status/1189470989043884032?s=20

Vote Labour and Corbyn

Anniebach Wed 30-Oct-19 15:36:14

They didn’t want to vote in the last election ?

Callistemon Wed 30-Oct-19 15:27:00

growstuff
I am astonished that at least 90,000 under 34 year olds were not registered to vote and have only just woken up to the fact that they can shock

Unless it is actually that number of 18-21 year olds?

Callistemon Wed 30-Oct-19 15:22:12

Ah, sweet, MaizieD, but too young to vote
Is he a grandad yet?
If he resigned he could have more time on his hands and could join GN.

Callistemon Wed 30-Oct-19 15:18:48

Re the OP
No, I think that that neither Corbyn nor Watson are a good bet but it's too late to do anything about it.
Would Corbyn resign anyway?

Oopsminty Wed 30-Oct-19 15:17:12

Corbyn seemed to be very popular with the younger generation

Callistemon Wed 30-Oct-19 15:15:18

middle-aged white malenesss

I suppose Starmer is middle-aged although he seems relatively young to me.

Not McDonnell - it would just be a continuation of elderly male stale and he is too controversial to appeal to those who might consider voting Labour and would be the ones to swing the vote.

jura2 Wed 30-Oct-19 15:08:09

ahahahaha

MawB Wed 30-Oct-19 15:03:06

it is such a pity that people so rarely read a title and discuss its content and just shoot from the hip willy nilly. A pity

Just as well the autocorrect didn’t omit “hip”Jura gringringrin .

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 14:50:22

But thousands won't win an election. Labour needs millions of voters - in the right places. I'm sorry to say that I don't think I've ever come across anybody who would vote for Labour now who's voted for somebody else in the past. I've come across plenty who wouldn't vote for Corbyn. Maybe there will be enough people who've never voted before to save the day.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 30-Oct-19 14:32:17

Momentum, raised £100000 in 12 hours since the election announcement.

That represents thousands of people.

The Tories can raise that in an instant from just one person. That person hopes for tax cuts and the ability to increase their wealth.

That £100000 represents people hopes and aspiration for a fairer and kinder society.

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 14:17:42

Wow! Just seen that over £90,000 under 34 year olds registered to vote on Tuesday alone. If registrations carry on at this rate, they could have quite an influence on Labour's overall total. It depends, of course, where they are. If they're from people in places which are already strongholds for any party, they won't make much difference. They're an unknown for the moment.

As mentioned above, many younger people seem to find the grandad look appealing, so who knows?

Amagran Wed 30-Oct-19 13:44:47

And BTW, saying spoken like a real idiot is not a good look either.

petra Wed 30-Oct-19 13:44:21

I have to admit that I sometimes get distracted by her eyebrows.

I'm tempted to email her ?

Amagran Wed 30-Oct-19 13:42:00

Grapefruitpip, you are absolutely right. Whether we like it or not, visuals do matter. We only have to think how Ed Milliband for example was brought down. On this front, the Tories (who I do not support!) are much more savvy than the other parties, and Johnson is the past master at working the visuals. Corbyn, on the other hand, however sensibly he speaks, will always make older people think of Steptoe. And it is not a good look!

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 13:37:15

BTW My personal feeling is that if Starmer were Labour leader that Labour would romp home. I suspect he will be one day.

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 13:35:40

Nothing jura. I was attempting to be ironic. Sorry!

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 13:35:05

I agree with Grapefruit too. Appearance does matter (unfortunately). In 2010, Gordon Brown gave the impression of being a grumpy old bear (even though he wasn't), compared with the much younger Cameron and Clegg.

I don't really think Corbyn's appearance and age count against him that much. I certainly know some young Labour supporters who find the grandad image quite appealing. He certainly doesn't fit the mould of ex-SPADs with sharp suits and smart haircuts.

jura2 Wed 30-Oct-19 13:33:18

it is such a pity that people so rarely read a title and discuss its content and just shoot from the hip willy nilly. A pity.

I mean, what does Bailey's make up or eyebrow shape has anything to do with title of thread, let alone anything else?!?

growstuff Wed 30-Oct-19 13:30:28

Long Bailey has strange eyebrows and wears too much make up, but the reason I don't think much of her is that she really doesn't come over as the sharpest knife in the box and doesn't have a "human touch".

Anniebach Wed 30-Oct-19 13:14:43

I understand what you meant grapefruit

Yehbutnobut Wed 30-Oct-19 13:13:43

Spoken like a real idiot does jar slightly. Being a bit of a pendant can I suggest ‘spoken like a true idiot’ kind of scans better?

#justsaying

grapefruitpip Wed 30-Oct-19 13:09:43

I await an apology before reporting. Fed up with it really.