Gransnet forums

News & politics

Coronavirus Testing

(169 Posts)
Chestnut Thu 23-Jan-20 18:36:28

Four Chinese patients have been taken to hospitals in Scotland and Northern Ireland to be tested for the killer coronavirus after returning from China with flu-like symptoms. The unidentified patients are thought to be from Wuhan, the city at the heart of the outbreak which has killed 18 people.

Why are people travelling when I understand they have been told not to? They should close down the airports in that area.

Callistemon Fri 24-Jan-20 19:38:31

This idea of testing for a temperature at airports etc is ridiculous. You can be infected and infectious for about 48 hours before you show any sign of symptoms like fever.

I am just relating what happened at HK Airport when another virus was rampant, and we were checked as we went through. Someone we know was stopped (at Singapore) and sent to hospital there before being allowed to travel on.

Urmstongran Fri 24-Jan-20 19:49:44

Bet you’re glad to be in Switzerland Gagajo.
??
Good call.

Urmstongran Fri 24-Jan-20 20:29:16

2 confirmed cases in France tonight but some good news just now in the Guardian:

“This time the aim is to have a viable vaccine in production within as little as 16 weeks – although testing for safety and efficacy will take longer.

One advantage is that the new coronavirus, 2019-nCoV, belongs to the same family as the severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars), for which a vaccine was developed following the 2002 outbreak. “Certainly that information will give us a head start,” said Prof Brendan Wren, dean of the faculty of infectious and tropical diseases at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (LSHTM).”

sluttygran Fri 24-Jan-20 21:44:11

This is very worrying of course, and I understand that people are anxious, but why angry?
Viruses are unpredictable and mutate frequently, and though the majority are not dangerous, a pandemic is still the greatest threat to human life.
Quarantine doesn't work very well, because as mentioned previously, infected persons can be outside the area and spreading the infection before anyone has realised that there is a problem.
No point being angry, because at present there is nothing anyone can do to change this situation.
Best save your anger for our government who appear to be destroying the NHS. We shall need it's skilled aid if we have an epidemic.

Kalu Fri 24-Jan-20 22:33:39

Re covering nose and mouth reminds of childhood and the necessity to do just that with a scarf as we made away around outside in a thick awful tasting fog. Not an unusual or rare sight.

Nanna58 Fri 24-Jan-20 22:38:56

No one here has yet been found to be infectious. I’m immune suppressed , but still I think we need to take a big breath before we panic.

Tweedle24 Fri 24-Jan-20 22:39:07

I heard on the radio that the Chinese are now obliged by law to wear masks if going into public places such as hairdressers or restaurants.
Two comments: how does one eat if wearing a mask?
Masks need to be changed regularly as they are no longer effective if they get damp. I have travelled on long haul flights with Asians wearing masks and not changing them for hours on end.

Kalu Fri 24-Jan-20 22:51:13

Tweedle I have worked with surgeons who have operated for hours without the necessity to change masks. This, in an infection free environment being one of the main priorities.

M0nica Sat 25-Jan-20 17:29:26

I think the Chinese have acted in a responsible manner. Within a week or two of the disease appearing they have placed the source city in quarantine, shut down places of public congregation and stopped travel, even though it is Chinese New Year. Imagine how the inhabitants of Manchester would react if someone shut the city down and forbade travel four days before Christmas! The quarantine has now been extended to other cities and the province.

Temperature tests tell you nothing, both people in the UK found with temperatures have been discharged because they had something else, not this illness and lack of a temperature is no guarentee that the person has not got the illness but has yet to show signs.

We know that the health authorities are tracing up 2,000 people who have flown into this country from the area over the last few weeks, not an easy thing to do, because you do not ask people coming through an airport what their destination address is, and some will have left the country already.

I understood that instructions to anyone thinking they have the disease is to contact the health services by dialling 111 or ringing a doctors surgery.

I am not sure what else the Chinese or British authorities can do.

MadeInYorkshire Sat 25-Jan-20 17:48:19

Coincidently there is a working biochemical laboratory in Wuhan, that studies the world's most dangerous pathogens and viruses ......

pbs.twimg.com/media/EO_7ozLW4AQI4Ub?format=jpg&name=4096x4096

Tend to believe that poor chap in Wuhan than the Chinese Authorities - looks like they missed a zero off their numbers

tickingbird Sat 25-Jan-20 17:51:31

They eat some pretty revolting stuff over there and many live in close proximity to chickens, pigs, mice etc. They have these markets with live animals being killed on the spot. Is it any wonder these viruses get a hold over there. They have such a huge population and although there is wealth there is also extreme poverty and many people living in very cramped, overcrowded areas. The death toll is rising and a doctor has now died. They are trying to build two hospitals in a week! Let’s just hope it doesn’t become a pandemic.

M0nica Sat 25-Jan-20 18:56:00

tickingbird the interesting point is that what you say about China could apply to Africa and South America. Places with large populations, eating food we are unfamiliar with and would not want to eat. Poverty and starvation can make people desperate. Shipwreck sailors have been known to eat the corpses of shipmates and animals are sold live in markets on these continents.

Ebola and HIV have come out of Africa, but these seem to have been transfers from monkeys to humans rather chickens and domestic fowl. But these respiratory diseases seem only to come out of China, not sure why.

In South America, European invaders introduced measles, smallpox and syphilis.

tickingbird Sat 25-Jan-20 19:20:55

Monica please don't turn this into a racist issue. Although it isn't really relevant the Chinese do some horrific things to animals and sometimes eat live animals - not insects but small mammals. Not necessarily out of poverty either. It's sometimes seen as a sign of wealth. It seems to be the common denominator is animals. HIV is supposedly from the green monkey, bird flu and I read something about SARS but can't remember it now. It does seem strange that the respiratory illnesses seem to come from China.

Labaik Sat 25-Jan-20 19:30:45

They say this virus has only just become active but I read quite a few weeks ago about some sort of plague somewhere in China. I made a mental note of it because a member of my family is travelling there later this year. But no more was said about it. Is there a link?

M0nica Sun 26-Jan-20 00:07:06

tickingbird I am not turning it into a racist issue. I was just pointing out that it is puzzling that these specifically respiratory infections arise only in China when two other continents have similar conditions. The diseases that have arisen in Africa are very different.

If the vector that leads to these infections can be isolated, then means of preventing them making the jump from animal to human and then human to human, can be developed.

Many foods that start as the food of poverty become the food of wealth. Oysters for example. Caviar is probably another. I would never defend anyone eating live animals, but small mammals are regularly predated and eaten live by their natural predators.

tickingbird Sun 26-Jan-20 05:45:53

Monica I take your point. Scarily, from a quick look at the news this morning it seems to be much worse than first thought. More have died and many more infected if reports are accurate.

BlueBelle Sun 26-Jan-20 08:15:25

I think we should all calm down and stop this awful blame game. So far everyone tested in UK has tested negative so that’s good news The Chinese have acted very quickly they are on shut down in Wuhan and are now building the second large hospital to contain the epidemic (would we act as fast ???)
We could have acted as quickly and set up some form of 7 day isolation to travellers from Wuhan
The Chinese are very mask orientated not necessarily to prevent illnesses but from the awful air quality from such an industrial country
Half the illness of the world were inflicted by our travels C19th we really do have to get things in or respective
Maybe the most people dying are elderly or people with lung troubles already we just don’t know

With all the unrest, division the climate problems and unhappiness in the world perhaps these spreading illnesses (and the swarm of locusts I read about recently) are a sign that just like the dinosaurs we re going to be extinguished

MawB Sun 26-Jan-20 08:36:30

M0nica it is not at all wrong to identify certain cultures as the source of epidemics such as this threatens to be. The link with cultural traditions and practices cannot be ignored
Epidemiologists are not yet in full agreement about the precise animal culprit but there is no doubt the outbreak originated from a local “wet” market selling dead and live animals.
The outbreak resulted from an animal-to-human species-jump – as do three of four new human infectious disease epidemics. HIV/Aids, Ebola, Zika and bird flu, as well as previous Sars and Mers coronavirus outbreaks, each originated in animals.
Most animal viruses are quickly eliminated by human defences. But it takes just one new viral strain and a vulnerable human host to catalyse an entirely new disease outbreak.
Wet markets put a variety of live animals in proximity to large numbers of handlers, sellers and customers. The resulting contact of humans each year provides millions – if not billions – of opportunities for new strains of coronavirus, influenza or viruses to make their way into us.
We might wonder if wet markets are such a threat to public health, why not ban them? The Chinese government tried this in 2013 and the banned ones were quickly replaced by a raft of potentially more dangerous black markets.
Wet markets are important sources of affordable food for growing urban populations. They are embedded in cultures economies throughout Asia. Making wet markets safer while over time shifting consumer preferences to better sources provides a sensible alternative to an outright ban. Following the 2003 SARS outbreak, Hong Kong took a series of measures to strengthen regulation of wet markets and their animal supply chains.
Among these were disinfection, reducing faecal contamination, and hygienic slaughtering. Consumers were educated on safe handling of wet market purchases. Similar measures have been implemented in Thailand, Vietnam and Bangladesh.

Sparklefizz Sun 26-Jan-20 09:19:18

BlueBelle you start your post by telling us all to calm down, and then end it by suggesting we are all going to be extinguished!! Very soothing, I'm sure.

gmarie Sun 26-Jan-20 10:36:01

Just finished reading this thread and checked my news feed before going to sleep (it's 2:30 a.m. here). A short update had just been posted a minute prior:

A person in Orange County has tested positive for the novel coronavirus, according to the Orange County Health Care Agency's Communicable Disease Control Division. The case involved a traveler from Wuhan, China.

Orange County is here in California. Makes me a bit nervous as I have respiratory issues. Ah well, worrying is pointless I guess.

Urmstongran Sun 26-Jan-20 12:03:06

These wet seafood markets that sell exotic live animals need tighter, enforceable regulation. Wealthy Chinese are photographed eating bat wings. Bat soup is popular for example.

With the Chinese NY upcoming I daresay there was more ‘produce’ available than usual.

GrannyGravy13 Sun 26-Jan-20 12:29:46

On the BBC news channel this morning they said that unlike other coronaviruses this one seems to be contagious in the "incubation" stage also.

Taking travellers temperatures at airports and stations will not help if this report is accurate.

TerriBull Sun 26-Jan-20 13:11:25

I started a thread a couple of days ago entitled "AIBU to think that some things just shouldn't be eaten" apropos of a picture I'd seen on line of a Chinese woman eating bat soup, complete with a whole bat on the side. Clearly the woman in question was Chinese and the setting was China. No racism was intende. The thread was pulled on the grounds that it was against the spirit of GN, I was baffled at the time and asked head office to elucidate. Their reply was something along the lines that "I had made a generalisation that could be interpreted as racist". Now it seems that umpteen posts here are saying much the same as what I said when I started that thread. One commenting about the state of market places in China where meat, fish and livestock are sold. One of the newspaper reviewers on Andrew Marr's show made pretty much the same comment about the bat soup and on the news it was reported that there may be a link to bats and the disease. General observations about certain foodstuffs eaten in China that could be linked to the virus are all over the news where it's obvious that they are reporting the news for what it is and sometimes a nod to cultural sensitivies cannot play a part in that. I therefore don't understand the rationale in HO's assertion. Clearly I was the first to draw attention to a "too hot to handle topic" but now it's out of the bag, at least be consistent in pointing the same thing out to other posters hmm

Momilsom Sun 26-Jan-20 13:16:26

I’m afraid this is what happens in a country where animal welfare is atrocious and they torture and skin animals while alive prior to butchering them . That includes dogs. And then sell them in their meat markets to be eaten ! It makes me so angry

Opal Sun 26-Jan-20 13:24:29

Terribull - no way should your post have been deleted. Another case of claiming something is racist, when it clearly isn't.