Gransnet forums

News & politics

I know I'm a republican but...

(57 Posts)
vampirequeen Wed 24-Mar-21 10:59:07

...surely the most ardent royalist will find it hard to explain this. Please don't turn this into a generalised republican/royalist row. Just focus on this one issue.

How will this help Scotland feel part of the UK thus reducing the calls for independence?

Did the Queen have this sort of conversation with herself? “One is so upset about poor William and our Scottish subjects at the moment. What can one do to make them feel better? One will give William a new job title. Hmmm what could it be? One cannot make him the Head of the Church of England because that is one's job. What about Wales? Oh no they have already got Charles. One knows!!! One will kill two birds with one stone. One will make William happy again and make the Scots feel wanted. William can be the new Lord High Commissioner of the Church of Scotland!”

Callistemon Thu 25-Mar-21 13:41:38

JaneJudge grin

Callistemon Thu 25-Mar-21 13:40:39

trisher

Interestingly C of E Bishops still sit in the House of Lords. The Established church is still that.

Yes, 26 of them and all from England as the only Established Church.

JaneJudge Thu 25-Mar-21 13:37:47

Callistemon

As I said, I got lost somewhere along this thread confused
Perhaps JaneJudge is aka Geri Halliwell?

I might not even be on the right thread. It's been one of those mornings.

grin grin grin

I am not Geri Halliwell. I do drive past the church she got married in though, even though I was under the impression she was a Jehovah's witness

trisher Thu 25-Mar-21 13:33:16

Interestingly C of E Bishops still sit in the House of Lords. The Established church is still that.

MaizieD Thu 25-Mar-21 11:45:12

Henry VIII removed his kingdom from the power of the Vatican, making himself the Supreme Governor. The Queen inherits that position, but she does not have, (or want, I am sure) any power over the ways that services in the Cof E are conducted, or what the congregation does in bed, or any of the Pope's almost supernatural-seeming powers. She is a kind of Chairman of the Board to the bishops and archbishops who run the organisation.

Thanks for that explanation, Elegran.

I rather think that Henry VIII had quite a lot of say in how the Church in England was conducted! But appreciate that his successor doesn't.

Eloethan Thu 25-Mar-21 11:36:42

It's ridiculous and totally irrelevant to the majority of people's lives.

Elegran Thu 25-Mar-21 10:23:38

"the Queen is not the head of the Church of England

No, she's the Supreme Governor. Is there a difference or is this just semantics?"

The head of all Christian churches is Christ (although the trinity of God the father, God the son, and the Holy Spirit is regarded as all a "three-in-one" entity)

In His physical absence, He put the governance of the early Roman Catholic Church onto his trusted disciple, Peter. Peter became in effect the first Pope and handed down authority to subsequent pontiffs. One of the Pope's names is "The Vicar of Christ" - vicar in its original meaning of susbstitute or stand-in, as in "A filmed car-chase is a vicarious thrill". The vicar of a parish was originally the stand-in for the rector, who was often a son of a local bigwig and too posh to take care of the parish himself.

As Christ's substitute, the pontiff can make all kinds of rules and regulations about worship and morals, and can (and does!) pontificate on matters concerning the personal and public behaviour of his flock.

Henry VIII removed his kingdom from the power of the Vatican, making himself the Supreme Governor. The Queen inherits that position, but she does not have, (or want, I am sure) any power over the ways that services in the Cof E are conducted, or what the congregation does in bed, or any of the Pope's almost supernatural-seeming powers. She is a kind of Chairman of the Board to the bishops and archbishops who run the organisation.

NotSpaghetti Thu 25-Mar-21 10:06:33

Apparently the Queen appoints on the advice of the prime minister

Previously The Princess Royal (twice), The Duke of Rothesay, The Duke of York and The Earl of Wessex have all been appointed, also the Duke of Buccleuch and Queensbury.

Callistemon Thu 25-Mar-21 10:01:28

As I said, I got lost somewhere along this thread confused
Perhaps JaneJudge is aka Geri Halliwell?

I might not even be on the right thread. It's been one of those mornings.

MaizieD Thu 25-Mar-21 09:57:39

Sorry, should have read more of the thread. But as no-one has explained, perhaps you'd be so good as to enlighten us, JJ

MaizieD Thu 25-Mar-21 09:56:04

JaneJudge

Kapitan is obviously stalking me and knows I have been sitting in my lounge in my underwear wearing a crown from cracker repeating 'the Queen is not the head of the Church of England' hmm

I do hope it's Union Jack underwear, JaneJudge...

the Queen is not the head of the Church of England

No, she's the Supreme Governor. Is there a difference or is this just semantics?

Alegrias1 Thu 25-Mar-21 09:49:51

On another thread someone has compared the Queen's 10th great grandchild's name to a bathroom floor. Imagining the Queen's inner dialogue seems quite tame compared to that.

Sorry to have mentioned another thread. grin

vampirequeen Thu 25-Mar-21 09:45:40

grin JaneJudge

JaneJudge Wed 24-Mar-21 18:04:33

Kapitan is obviously stalking me and knows I have been sitting in my lounge in my underwear wearing a crown from cracker repeating 'the Queen is not the head of the Church of England' hmm

Callistemon Wed 24-Mar-21 17:39:03

Well, I got lost somewhere along the thread
Am I the only one?

AmberSpyglass Wed 24-Mar-21 17:26:37

How are these comments mocking?!

Kapitan Wed 24-Mar-21 17:07:08

I think that mocking the Queen is sick and disgusting, Have you got nothing better to do?

Callistemon Wed 24-Mar-21 16:21:51

I think I need to lie down in a darkened room. It's all getting too much for me.
Or at least in a sunny conservatory. I'd invite the vicar round for a cuppa and quiz him but we're not allowed.

JaneJudge Wed 24-Mar-21 16:18:18

Callistemon

JaneJudge

The Queen isn't the head of the Church of England grin

No just the Supreme Governor, ie titular Head, - is that not Head enough?

grin grin
someone will be along to explain to you soon hopefully

Bodach Wed 24-Mar-21 16:00:39

"There is a "Church of Scotland" which is certainly not Anglican, but Calvinist." Absolutely correct, Elegran - at least it's supposed to be. On a visit to Edinburgh a couple of years ago, I went along to St Giles' Kirk on Sunday morning, expecting to sing the old psalms and hymns I learned in my Highland youth, ask forgiveness for my 'debts' rather than my 'trespasses', and enjoy a lengthy traditional Calvinistic roasting from the pulpit. Not a bit of it! Instead, I got a mish-mash of modern trendiness and high church mumbo-jumbo. Bring back John Knox, I say....

trisher Wed 24-Mar-21 15:09:42

Just wondering Charles 1 was captured by the Scots and held prisoner until they sold him to the Parliamentarians who of course executed him, should Will take care? x

Callistemon Wed 24-Mar-21 15:00:29

Prince William is this year's "ambassador" from the Queen to the summer Assembly of the Church of Scotland. Next year, someone else will take a turn. Don't panic. It isn't a Royal takeover bid.

Thanks, Elegran
I'm not panicking! I do understand the role as ambassador.

I was misled by other Google attempts last week where it said that the NI Church and Church in Wales are not established (which I knew), unlike the churches in England and arguably that in Scotland.

lemsip Wed 24-Mar-21 14:51:42

vampirequeen Please don't turn this into a generalised republican/royalist row. Just focus on this one issue.

Where did you think this might go then?

Elegran Wed 24-Mar-21 14:45:28

Callistemon There is no "Anglican Church of Scotland".

There is a Scottish Episcopal Church (with bishops) which is part of the Anglican communion and recognises the Archbishop of Canterbury as president of the Anglican Instruments of Communion, but without jurisdiction in Scotland per se. Episcopalians today constitute well under 1 per cent of the population of Scotland, making them considerably smaller than the Church of Scotland. (Wikipedia)

There is a "Church of Scotland" which is certainly not Anglican, but Calvinist. That is the leading church in Scotland, and any official public prayers are said by someone of that denomination, but it is not the established church in Scotland, intertwined with Government and Society, as the C of E is in England.

Prince William is this year's "ambassador" from the Queen to the summer Assembly of the Church of Scotland. Next year, someone else will take a turn. Don't panic. It isn't a Royal takeover bid.

Callistemon Wed 24-Mar-21 14:44:38

JaneJudge

The Queen isn't the head of the Church of England grin

No just the Supreme Governor, ie titular Head, - is that not Head enough?