Gransnet forums

News & politics

Do leaflets help you to vote?

(36 Posts)
Mollygo Mon 03-May-21 19:58:51

We currently have a Labour Council.
I’ve had leaflets from:
Green Party-will make things greener and work to provide more charging points for the electric car I can’t afford.
Labour-will do a long list of things (including all the things they haven’t done whilst they’ve been in charge of the council.)
Conservative-will do a long list of things, starting with fixing road surfaces, not just topping up potholes.
Lib-Dem haven’t posted leaflets-saving paper?
Which of these is most convincing? I’m not asking for how people will vote, just an opinion on the leaflets.

Mollygo Tue 04-May-21 18:11:42

Congratulations annodomini, both for getting elected twice and for your party having a good record.
Just as a matter of interest, before elections I do read them and put their ‘what we will do’ on a spreadsheet so I can compare their performance with what they offered or promised. Then they are recycled so that they do at least some good.

annodomini Tue 04-May-21 17:23:14

I have, in the past, spent many hours stooped over a keyboard, compiling election leaflets. I must admit that I always suspected what a number of you have said: that leaflets didn't influence you; and they quickly ended up in the bin! However, I managed to get elected twice though I think my agent wrote my leaflets. My party's record on our council spoke for itself.

varian Tue 04-May-21 16:44:18

MaizieD

Well, I hope people in Southend are shocked by the message from their tory MP. More or less says that if they don't vote for a tory council the government won't give them any money.
I wonder if that is illegal for an election leaflet?

Government facing legal challenge over ‘pork-barrel’ levelling-up fund funnelling cash to Tory areas

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/levelling-up-fund-pork-barrel-good-law-b1826803.html

timetogo2016 Tue 04-May-21 14:17:21

My grey bin loves them.

suziewoozie Tue 04-May-21 14:16:35

MaizieD

Well, I hope people in Southend are shocked by the message from their tory MP. More or less says that if they don't vote for a tory council the government won't give them any money.
I wonder if that is illegal for an election leaflet?

I was truly shocked by this - not that it would happen ( because it has been happening and will continue to do so) but that they now feel they can act with such impunity so openly. But then, what a role model they have

Mollygo Tue 04-May-21 13:05:41

MaizieD

Well, I hope people in Southend are shocked by the message from their tory MP. More or less says that if they don't vote for a tory council the government won't give them any money.
I wonder if that is illegal for an election leaflet?

Certainly hope it’s illegal. I think, if it’s not fake news, that David Ames will live to regret it. If it prompts constituents to do the opposite of his suggestion, any shortage of money will be loudly proclaimed by the council.

Witzend Tue 04-May-21 11:55:58

We’ve had a whole booklet for Thursday - for the mayor and 2 different London assembly members.

So many candidates, with their ‘vote for me!’ blurbs!

I already knew who I was going to vote for, though - none of the ‘fringe’ candidates but the (depressingly) least worst of the others. Which isn’t saying much, but I’d never not vote or spoil my ballot paper.

MaizieD Tue 04-May-21 11:49:31

Well, I hope people in Southend are shocked by the message from their tory MP. More or less says that if they don't vote for a tory council the government won't give them any money.
I wonder if that is illegal for an election leaflet?

Alegrias1 Tue 04-May-21 09:19:02

Lovetopaint037

Urmstongran

??

The SNP had two Scottish-born actors on a live stream today telling Scots to vote for independence. One lives in New York and the other lives in Las Vegas.

I thought as you and Sean Connery also came to mind. He had a lot to say about what Scotland should do although living in the States. Why actors should be taken notice of when spouting politics is a mystery to me or why they think they are important enough or have the right to tell us how to vote just because we see them on the tv or on a film.

Well David Bowie felt the need to ask Naomi Campbell to tell us to stay in the union in 2014 so I guess anything goes.

BTW - Sean Connery lived in the Bahamas.

Aveline Tue 04-May-21 08:57:11

Liz46 your local man sounds great. I wish we had more like him.

MrsEggy Tue 04-May-21 08:44:14

With smaller parties (I joined one once) it's not a question of not bothering. Leaflets cost money, and need many volunteers to deliver them.

Lovetopaint037 Tue 04-May-21 08:43:46

Urmstongran

??

The SNP had two Scottish-born actors on a live stream today telling Scots to vote for independence. One lives in New York and the other lives in Las Vegas.

I thought as you and Sean Connery also came to mind. He had a lot to say about what Scotland should do although living in the States. Why actors should be taken notice of when spouting politics is a mystery to me or why they think they are important enough or have the right to tell us how to vote just because we see them on the tv or on a film.

Greyduster Tue 04-May-21 08:17:38

No, they go straight in the bin.

Casdon Tue 04-May-21 07:48:15

The Conservative party send their communications for the elections through the post, and it really annoys me that as the householder (I’m a widow), their letters are always addressed to my son who lives with me, and I’m the second name on the letter. He’s 24, but it’s assumed because he’s male that he owns the house - really, in this day and age?!
I’ve had about 20 leaflets through from the other parties, we’re in a marginal seat so being bombarded. I do read them, but not persuaded to change my mind.

Liz46 Tue 04-May-21 07:37:25

It's a no brainer for me. Our local Lib-Dem man is always around and has been for many years. He has set times to stand outside local shops and people can go and talk to him.

He is on the local Facebook group and always reacts to problems that people post.

One of our neighbours wants to build five detached houses in his garden which would badly impact us and the councillor is helping us to fight it.

TBH I only vote Lib-Dem in the local elections.

suziewoozie Tue 04-May-21 07:34:53

I glance at the leaflets but I can’t imagine any content that would impact my vote. I’m sometimes amused by what they think would matter to me or what I might believe. It’s LD all the way not based on any leaflet but on their dogged work throughout the year, regular updates, their engagement with local people, causes, answering correspondence and so on.

Lin52 Tue 04-May-21 07:02:35

Not really, I look at past actions of people, and what is going on at the moment, broken promises, and huge overspends, uneccessarily, will be a big no no for any individuals party.

ElaineI Mon 03-May-21 21:35:14

Already voted so no. Straight in recycling bin.

Aveline Mon 03-May-21 21:26:57

We had a very good independent MSP up here and I was happy to vote for her but sadly she has now died. Its back to tribalism.

Galaxy Mon 03-May-21 21:23:13

Of course independents are political as well . They just hide it.

Alima Mon 03-May-21 21:15:13

No, leaflets don’t actually help me vote though I do generally read them before they go in recycling.

Alima Mon 03-May-21 21:13:53

Aah, that is why they are saying Martin Compson is being trolled on Twitter.

M0nica Mon 03-May-21 21:06:13

The problem with local politics being entirely independents, is that once elected they have to agree among themselves, who will do what, and even if there is broad agreement on one or two policies, there as sure as hell will be deep differences on many issues. Trying to organise a council containing nothing but independents would be like herding cats.

Sometimes the Insdependents are a group - like a rate payers alliance.

I find my vote tends to go with the party I support because, even at local level I am opposed to the other parties policies.

Alegrias1 Mon 03-May-21 21:01:42

Urmstongran

??

The SNP had two Scottish-born actors on a live stream today telling Scots to vote for independence. One lives in New York and the other lives in Las Vegas.

Well the version I saw had several actors, plus Val MacDiarmid. Val MacDiarmid is a national treasure and she lives in Kirkcaldy so cannot be challenged on such matters.?

Also one of the actors was Steve Arnott in LoD so nobody gets to disrespect him due to his services to Sunday night drama ?

Septimia Mon 03-May-21 20:46:56

I firmly believe that local councillors should be Independent and not toe any party line. Their job is to represent what the people want at the local level. Party politics should play no part!

Consequently I shall be voting for our Independent candidates, although I could possibly be swayed if they were totally useless - but they're not!

The Police and Crime Commissioners shouldn't be aligned to political parties either.