Gransnet forums

News & politics

Should HS2 be scrapped?

(34 Posts)
mumofmadboys Tue 14-Sep-21 14:24:28

Yes definitely

Candelle Tue 14-Sep-21 14:21:55

Yes. Absolutely.

Bringonthegks Tue 14-Sep-21 14:20:33

Bit torn on this one. It seems such a lot of money and disruption when the whole rail infrastructure needs to be improved. On the other hand I live in a town which will greatly benefit in terms of jobs and the local economy etc.

Smileless2012 Tue 14-Sep-21 14:11:51

Definitely think of how that money could be spent on the NHS and improving Social Care.

Dinahmo Tue 14-Sep-21 14:07:49

Yes

ayse Tue 14-Sep-21 13:59:39

Surely it would be better to upgrade all our train lines to use them for freight. There are still lots of derelict goods yards that could be used for such a purpose, not to mention the chopping down of ancient woods etc.

Yes, HS2 should be stopped.

pinkquartz Tue 14-Sep-21 13:56:44

yes

GillT57 Tue 14-Sep-21 13:53:35

Absolutely yes. All this destruction of the countryside, people's homes, just to shave a few minutes off a train journey?

love0c Tue 14-Sep-21 13:47:21

Seems one hell of a lot of money to be spending on something that will benefit a few? Far better things to spend it on to benefit many?