Gransnet forums

News & politics

Nicola ... again. Shut up woman! Are you for real?

(324 Posts)
Urmstongran Thu 10-Mar-22 20:20:14

Joe Biden won’t. Boris Johnson won’t. Ben Wallace won’t. Nor will, as far as we know, every other leader of a Nato member country. However, it is clear that Nicola Sturgeon just might.

Might do what, you ask? Consider backing a Nato no-fly zone over Ukraine, that’s what. Even if such an action risked a major escalation of the West’s dispute with a nuclear-tipped Russia.

The First Minister thinks that having warplanes, including British ones, taking on, and possibly shooting down, Vladimir Putin’s planes is worth “serious consideration”.

It’s a truly astonishing suggestion that was being described by enemies and one-time supporters alike as another piece of grandstanding by someone who appears to be desperately seeking a niche for herself on the international stage.

volver Sat 12-Mar-22 10:17:19

Remain?

Are you mixing your referendums up?

Anyway, no. Contrary to Yooner belief we're not all paranoid and think that the referendum was fixed. Most of us know we have to make a better case next time.

Glad to see you made use of the Scottish Education system before running off down south when you'd had your fill.

Mollygo Sat 12-Mar-22 10:09:53

Well exactly. But most supported remain last time, so of course it must have been the fault of a dastardly plan by those who didn’t want Scotland to leave or those ignorant Scots who didn’t see how they were being misled etc, etc, etc.
If I’d had the vote, I’d have voted for Scotland to leave. I’ve already benefited from the short move to live in Scotland and get free Uni education for my DC and I haven’t got any more family who need it.

volver Sat 12-Mar-22 09:41:30

Oh, and not all the Scots have to support independence for it to happen. Just most of us have to support it. That's how it works.

volver Sat 12-Mar-22 09:39:55

I, and all the independence supporters I know (which is quite a lot) have never doubted the democracy of the operation of the 2014 referendum.

We lost because not enough people were convinced of the arguments and because there was a No campaign based on fear and uncertainty. That I know for a fact as well.

Mollygo Sat 12-Mar-22 09:36:32

No, I chose the wrong word that’s all. I was just being supportive of Scotland leaving the UK if that’s what all the Scots want.
The outcome of the last referendum wasn’t wholly acceptable any more than Brexit. The only things the two had in common was that the ‘losing’ side thought the result was unfair and that it hadn’t been done in a democratic way.

volver Sat 12-Mar-22 08:21:43

We've already got devolution.

Did you miss that?

Mollygo Sat 12-Mar-22 08:19:48

Aveline makes a good point about numbers in Westminster, but Paddyanne54, I’d support your devolution however soon it could be arranged.

Marydoll Sat 12-Mar-22 08:16:10

paddyann, I understand exactly what you mean about an English parliament.
As Aveline has made clear, it is a UK parliament, however, as the majority of MPS are English and it is a very large majority, Scots MPS will be voices crying in the wilderness and have little or no influence. For that reason, you could say that it is an English parliament, with one country having the majority vote.

At least with devolution, we can have some influence in how our country is run.

Aveline Sat 12-Mar-22 07:01:47

Scotland has a much smaller population than England. Westminster, is the United Kingdom parliament and all parts of the United Kingdom are represented there with seats in proportion to their population. It is not an English parliament.

paddyann54 Fri 11-Mar-22 23:53:51

Behind Westminster are your *Urmstongrans" who think WE should SHUT UP AND SIT DOWN ...because they obviously know more about Scotland and her people than we do .

paddyann54 Fri 11-Mar-22 23:49:48

Westminster is an English Parliament.
England has 533 seats
Scotland has 59 seats
Wales has 40 seats
NI has 18 seats
There is no way any country other than England can WIN any vote ,never has been never will be .
Thats the main reason why I believe in Independence ,I dont want to have to obey rules laid down by my neighbour ,Thats NOT Democracy .
For all you incensed about Ukraine losing its Independence ,spare a thought for us ...we had our stolen /sold out by a few aristos for English gold .Time we got it back and made our own laws and rules and even our own mistakes .We cant do any worse than th WM government has been doing in our name for over 300 years
I despair of the "unionists" who cant see how wrong the whole set up is and want to keep us tethered to a government who only want us for our natural recourses ,the ones they've been using to keep the UK afloat for centuries .

DaisyAnne Fri 11-Mar-22 23:22:58

Marydoll

He is the MP whom Jacob Rees-Mogg dubbed a lightweight. I never thought in my wildest nightmares dreams, that I would find my self agreeing with that odious man. wink

He should know Marydoll.

Callistemon21 Fri 11-Mar-22 22:58:33

I'm sure I read it but can't remember what it said.

GillT57 Fri 11-Mar-22 22:15:53

Well I wandered off to replenish my wine glass and came back to find that someone has been deleted. Bugger. I always miss the good bits. Whose feathers were ruffled?

GillT57 Fri 11-Mar-22 22:07:22

volver

Well while we're waiting for the answer that never comes, can we just diverge briefly into that pillar of righteousness that is Douglas Ross? He’s withdrawn his letter asking Johnson to resign. It would be wrong for him to leave during war in Europe, he says. But he wanted Sturgeon to resign in the middle of a pandemic and he thought that Johnson wasn’t even good enough to lead in time of peace, let alone war. Twitter is not being kind. ?

Right, back to the topic in hand.

He's got a mouth like a cat's bum. Allegedly

Callistemon21 Fri 11-Mar-22 21:30:20

The weather couldn't have been worse but the company was great, Coastpath!
Wales was still there when we went home.

We will be back very soon!

Coastpath Fri 11-Mar-22 21:26:36

Callistemon21

Coastpath

A tourist once asked me if the coast they could see across the Bristol Channel from Somerset was France.

Coastpath we've been to England today and, looking across the Channel, it was as if Wales had sailed away into the Atlantic
It was nowhere to be seen.

Wales has a habit of drifting off when it feels like it. One day so clear I can see houses and the wind turbines turning on the cliff tops and then next day nothing! I hope it's not something we've said. smile

And yes, I knew exactly what you meant. Hope you had a lovely day in Somerset and sorry we couldn't have laid on better weather for you.

Lucca Fri 11-Mar-22 21:25:38

Urmstongran

Bore off volver.
Again.

Oh the wit and repartee

Urmstongran Fri 11-Mar-22 20:44:56

You got deleted!! Goodness, someone’s trigger happy tonight.
Sorry for you Lucylastic that was a harsh call whoever reported you. x

Urmstongran Fri 11-Mar-22 20:38:18

Lucylastic (love the name!)
Will do. We’re just about to eat. ?

Callistemon21 Fri 11-Mar-22 20:37:42

Mark Drakeford leads from the rear!
He waits for the reactions, the evidence before he speaks.

Urmstongran Fri 11-Mar-22 20:36:07

You think Pantglas?
I like to think Drakeford has more sense.

Callistemon21 Fri 11-Mar-22 20:33:11

GrannyGravy13

There are several restaurants in London who have put chicken kiev on the menu and all proceeds are going to Ukrainian charities.

That's a great idea!

Rees-Mogg hits out at chicken kiev name change - 'We've no gripe with Russian culture!

I got it the wrong way round.
However, he doesn't know his Russian culture or his French cuisine does he.

JaneJudge Fri 11-Mar-22 20:32:50

is she for real?

Lucylastic Fri 11-Mar-22 20:32:05

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.