Gransnet forums

News & politics

Gender? Sex? Help me out please.

(866 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

volver Tue 15-Mar-22 14:50:07

Now I might be asking for trouble but I’m looking for information.

On two threads active today about politics, we’ve had posts very quickly about gender politics. I’m a bit in the dark and I tend to stay off the gender politics threads as they tend to get heated. (Yes, this is me, really. wink)

So I’m looking for information on this issue and why people are so fired up about it. No judgement please, I am just trying to understand this.

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 18:13:13

I agree VS. My dating pool is diverse, as my partners have been.

Don't knock someone till you've tried them has always been my motto. There have been some 'interesting' dates.

Galaxy Wed 16-Mar-22 18:11:12

Do you think lesbians exclude men from their dating pool because of something they dont agree with them about.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 18:06:59

I haven't excluded women from my dating pool because of anything I dislike or don't agree with about them.

Actually women aren't excluded from my dating pool but I was making a point

Galaxy Wed 16-Mar-22 18:04:39

Oh and if lesbians are bigoted for excluding men from their dating pool then so is every straight woman on here who has excluded women from their dating pool.

Galaxy Wed 16-Mar-22 18:02:41

Its really deep seated homophobia, and pretending dating and going out with a friend is the same thing doesnt hide it. Its the type of homophobia that we all heard in the 90 ' s its so depressing.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 17:58:29

Granhgravy they still are trans

Its who they are on the inside, the process of transition just changes the outside

GrannyGravy13 Wed 16-Mar-22 17:52:14

VioletSky

You are mistaken if you believe being trans is a choice.

We are fortunate that in the U.K. that it is possible to transition, in many countries it is illegal and they do not have the right to choose to do so.

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 17:49:00

GrannyGravy13

VioletSky

granygravy all those things are choices not appearance

That is what the thread is about, choices.

?

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 17:48:14

You are mistaken if you believe being trans is a choice.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 16-Mar-22 17:45:02

GagaJo

Racism is a choice.

Sexism is a choice.

Homophobia is a choice.

Doesn't make them right.

Who on this thread has said any of the choices you have mentioned are right Gagajo ?

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 17:43:12

Racism is a choice.

Sexism is a choice.

Homophobia is a choice.

Doesn't make them right.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 16-Mar-22 17:41:53

VioletSky

granygravy all those things are choices not appearance

That is what the thread is about, choices.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 17:30:36

granygravy all those things are choices not appearance

GrannyGravy13 Wed 16-Mar-22 17:27:34

I wouldn’t date anyone with any if the following known characteristics

Racist
Habitual Liar
Philanderer
Thief
Extreme religious beliefs

I do not have a problem with anyone knowing this, and I would say it to anyone who asked.

We do not have to date someone just to make someone else feel comfortable or happy.

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 17:25:46

VS, I remember when I lived overseas, a friend said to me, 'I don't find Asian men attractive.' I remember looking askansce at her. She had no idea she was being racist. Obviously, she 100% had the right to date who she wanted. But to couch it in racism was wrong.

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 17:23:53

Doodledog

GagaJo

You really don't like women, do you?

Is there any need to make personal comments? Can't we stay focused on the topic rather than resorting to personal insults?

It’s neither a personal comment nor an insult. It is an observation based on the number of times ‘oh but women do that too’ is used to defend the indefensible.

'An observation' that just happens to be rude. We could all make 'observations' like that but manage to restrain.

This is one of the reasons these threads derail because of posters unable to distinguish between discussion and getting personal.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 17:18:04

Dickens I think I can see why you have responded as you have but, that's not what I was saying...

You were being honest and trying to make a point

It's just that is a point that doesn't need making out there in general life though does it? So it's not really necessary to say

Anyone that I don't find attractive someone else will so why would I make any demographic feel bad about themselves by stating what I don't find attractive? Why would I make any 1 individual feel bad by saying it to their face? I certainly am not wonderful or beautiful enough that anyone else is beneath me in attractiveness anyway.

We can keep our personal preferences to ourselves and instead of saying "i would never date xyz" simply say, we all have the freedom to chose who we have a relationship with

I'm saying

I won't ever agree with people saying "I won't date people who..."

I agree people get to choose who they have relationships with

Same thing but a different approach

Dickens Wed 16-Mar-22 17:05:33

VioletSky

If someone wouldn't date an overweight person, I wouldn't question that that is the truth. I would question if they were saying that to an overweight person..

That's the difference.

OK so you (blanket statement) would not ever date a trans person? Was it necessary to say it when you could just not do it?

It's quite a big difference if you think about it

Well. I told the truth when I said I had never been attracted to overweight men. That of course doesn't mean quite the same as "I would never date an overweight man" because I might have, if I'd met one I liked.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 16:54:05

If it helps, I like nice people

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 16:52:55

GagaJo

No VS. Quite. And we oldies already have the unfortunate label for being behind the times.

I know right

GagaJo Wed 16-Mar-22 16:49:24

No VS. Quite. And we oldies already have the unfortunate label for being behind the times.

Doodledog Wed 16-Mar-22 16:48:54

GagaJo

*You really don't like women, do you?*

Is there any need to make personal comments? Can't we stay focused on the topic rather than resorting to personal insults?

It’s neither a personal comment nor an insult. It is an observation based on the number of times ‘oh but women do that too’ is used to defend the indefensible.

VioletSky Wed 16-Mar-22 16:45:32

volver some platforms haven't set any limits yet on how its acceptable to talk about trans people.

Given the rate of escalation I've noticed, even just over the last 6 months, that's going to have to change eventually.

No one is going to want to be the last "safe space" for discrimination

GrannyGravy13 Wed 16-Mar-22 16:39:45

GagaJo

We're going down the rabbit hole now. Blaming people for medical wait times.

I am not blaming anyone for anything Gagajo just pointing out the medically obvious fact that if a human being has a penis and testicles i.e. male genitalia then they are a man.

If you know or can prove different please post a link to the evidence

volver Wed 16-Mar-22 16:39:43

Yes, apologies Iam64. Its not funny, you're right.

Its disappointing.