Gransnet forums

News & politics

Death of a two year old in substandard social housing

(233 Posts)
Dinahmo Tue 15-Nov-22 20:31:49

The young boy died from the effects of poisoning from mould in his home.

After a narrative conclusion was recorded at Rochdale coroner’s court, lawyers for Awaab’s parents read a statement in which they accused the social housing provider, Rochdale Boroughwide Housing (RBH), of doing nothing over a number of years to treat the mould problem that killed their son.

“We cannot tell you how many health professionals we have cried in front of and Rochdale borough housing staff we have pleaded to expressing concern … We shouted out as loudly as we could,” they said.

They accused RBH of not caring and said they had no doubt they were treated that way “because we are not from this country and less aware of how the systems in the UK work.

For those who aren't aware, many of the so called housing associations were formed in the noughties by local authorities selling off their housing stock to the staff who originally were responsible for running the housing departments. Because of the rules for taking staff the various jobs had to be advertised. I had an interview for one job in Suffolk Coastal and it was obvious from the start that they were just going through the motions.

Those running these associations are in it for the profits I think and they are further candidates for control being handed back to the local authorities.

Glorianny Tue 15-Nov-22 20:42:32

RBH is actually a mutual society owned by its employees and tenants. I've tried to find accounts, but think they are non-profit making.https://www.rbh.org.uk/about-us/

Glorianny Tue 15-Nov-22 20:42:53

www.rbh.org.uk/about-us/

sodapop Tue 15-Nov-22 20:46:44

Seems to be a huge nationwide problem of sub standard rented accommodation. It's a real concern as more and more people are renting now.

Dinahmo Tue 15-Nov-22 20:54:32

Glorianny

RBH is actually a mutual society owned by its employees and tenants. I've tried to find accounts, but think they are non-profit making.https://www.rbh.org.uk/about-us/

I didn't know that, but therefore it is even more shocking that this has happened.

Witzend Tue 15-Nov-22 20:56:55

When I first heard about this, I assumed that it was down to a private landlord’s - or should I say slumlord’s - callous neglect. The fact that it was a housing association property makes it doubly shocking IMO.

Farzanah Tue 15-Nov-22 20:57:33

That is so sad. I don’t think this problem is restricted to social housing either. I hope this child has not died in vain and more action will be taken when tenants bring poor conditions to landlords attention. ITV ran a campaign about substandard housing earlier this year and some conditions were not suitable for anyone to live in.

Iam64 Tue 15-Nov-22 21:00:23

The radio 4 coverage I heard referred to poor or non existent communication between those expressing concern that housing was affecting this little boys health. It seems a midwife, health visitor and doctor were aware but didn’t coordinate or share information.
Its shocking that this could happen in social housing.

Glorianny Tue 15-Nov-22 21:02:09

One of the problems is that we have a lot of housing built before central heating was common. They were ventilated through fireplaces and chimneys. Closing up those points and over heating houses means that mould thrives. One of the solutions is to open a window regularly, of course no one wants to do that because the house gets cold. It is a very difficult problem to deal with. Drying washing inside contributes to the problem.

Urmstongran Tue 15-Nov-22 21:21:32

I find it shocking and reprehensible that with all of today’s technology - emails for example - that various departments still seem unable to share concerns needing urgent attention in a robust manner. Too many ‘open ended’ or ineffectual communications. It’s dispiriting and in this case, tragic.

growstuff Tue 15-Nov-22 21:22:36

Iam64

The radio 4 coverage I heard referred to poor or non existent communication between those expressing concern that housing was affecting this little boys health. It seems a midwife, health visitor and doctor were aware but didn’t coordinate or share information.
Its shocking that this could happen in social housing.

The Manchester Evening News has more details of the lack of communication:

www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/ways-tragic-two-year-old-25509480

VioletSky Tue 15-Nov-22 21:23:26

This is awful

When we moved in, I took off a vent to paint and there was no hole underneath

This was in a chimney

They cut this sort of corner and people live like this and die like this despite paying more than enough rent to have a properly maintained home

It's disgusting, they should face charges

Urmstongran Tue 15-Nov-22 21:27:46

The home where this baby lived his short life.

Mistyfluff8 Tue 15-Nov-22 21:35:06

I had this for a patient of mine The landlord got furious with me because I repeatedly wrote letters to the council to get patients with newborn babies rehoused as there was mould in the flat Just interested in rent

Caleo Tue 15-Nov-22 22:03:18

Is the mould caused by a leaky building, or is it caused by poor ventilation? We really need to know. If it's poor ventilation it's bad housekeeping that caused the mould.
Obviously there are may people who don't know how to ventilate and heat a house or flat. The landlord should deal with informing the tenant how to maintain the house properly. Did the housing authority do this?

There is going to be an increase in problems of dampness due to people unable to afford to heat and dry their indoor spaces.

Caleo Tue 15-Nov-22 22:07:13

PS I wonder it this is a clear case for the issuing of de-humidifiers.

growstuff Tue 15-Nov-22 22:18:13

The landlords did claim it was a "lifestyle" issue, but they had 600 other tenants with the same issues. They also found that the extraction fan in the bathroom wasn't working properly. Many flats don't have windows in the bathroom, so this could have been an issue.

Caleo Tue 15-Nov-22 22:21:40

Growstuff, then the landlords needed to educate the tenants about how to ventilate and heat the flats.

If they can't afford the heating then that is a separate issue.

JenniferEccles Tue 15-Nov-22 22:30:19

The report did say the problem with mould was caused by poor ventilation in the property.
What we don’t know is whether the tenants were aware (or were made aware) of the importance of opening windows in rooms such as the kitchen and bathroom, especially when cooking or showering.

25Avalon Tue 15-Nov-22 22:32:40

There are plenty of other cases of families living in disgusting mouldy housing throughout the whole UK. It is a disgrace and needs addressing. Hopefully this tragic case will highlight that and something gets done. I’m not sure it should be regarded as just being racist when it is so widespread. Whatever. It needs rectifying pdq before another child dies.

Yammy Tue 15-Nov-22 22:36:16

This is disgusting and there should be regulations and checks to stop it from happening. Poor little chap he never had a life.

VioletSky Tue 15-Nov-22 22:36:33

There is no way that amount of damp was caused by one family unless they left the shower on 24/7, never had a radiator on and never opened a door

That's ridiculous

Callistemon21 Tue 15-Nov-22 22:38:44

Extractor fans
Mould-resistant paint
Dry lining walls?
Checking damp-proof courses.

Surely it's not that expensive or difficult? It just needs more action and less bureaucracy and hand-wringing.

Poor little boy, he looked so happy and healthy.

Caleo Tue 15-Nov-22 22:47:30

Violet Sky, my 60s semi which is really well built gets damp due in large part to my drying washing indoors without a drying machine.

I keep the back door open most of the day to air the place.

Flats don't have back doors , and usually lack gardens for drying washing outdoors. There is a housekeeping issue that needs to be dealt with, and will involve some money being spent on drying facilities for people in flats who have no drying machines or money to run them.

Margiknot Tue 15-Nov-22 22:50:24

It’s time this issue was highlighted. I think I heard on the news that the mould was caused by poor ventilation in the flat. I suspect that many buildings (particularly modern flats and older properties divided into small flats) have poor ventilation. I wonder if there should be some sort of information campaign - to help us all (developers, landlords, residents) understand how to balance warmth humidity and ventilation.