Gransnet forums

News & politics

Does anyone believe Nadhim Zahawi?

(297 Posts)
foxie48 Sun 22-Jan-23 13:55:01

I genuinely like to give people the benefit of the doubt if I don't know all the facts but really, does anyone believe NZ made a "careless mistake" with his tax arrangements? If he has paid the reported £4.3m (including a 30% fine) that means he underpaid by over £3m. How can this be a careless mistake? He may have a degree in chemical engineering, so he's fairly numerate but surely he'd have had accountants advising him? The whole things reeks of tax avoidance if it isn't then he should make his returns available to an independent committee or resign. I see BJ is back in the news, I'm still waiting to find out why he travelled to Italy in 2018 to meet the KGB agent Lebedev without his minders when he was Foreign Secretary.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 25-Jan-23 17:03:24

*hard should be *yard

MaizieD Wed 25-Jan-23 18:11:43

GrannyGravy13

Katie59

Never heard of heating stables, horses like a cool fresh environment, it was probably a “careless” declaration

High end eventers and expensive race horses along with up-market livery yards have heated stables, shower stables and solariums to dry the horses after their showers.

At our hard we just put an extra rug on them when the temperature is really low.

I have a feeling that there were some staff living quarters involved, too.

...shower stables and solariums to dry the horses after their showers.

My DD just puts the hosepipe on hers.... then an ancient Thermatex rug to dry him off... grin

Fleurpepper Wed 25-Jan-23 18:42:27

Going off piste here- but do horses really need washing in very cold temps? Mud can just be brushed off. They need natural oils, etc under layer of fur to grow, to keep warm.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 25-Jan-23 19:10:44

I’ll report more when I see it.

Carol Vorderman

Hello. Very busy filming this week but so much more information on ZAHAWI coming in re paid for dealings for oil companies in Iraq while he was an MP. Will report back ASAP

Katie59 Wed 25-Jan-23 20:04:54

Fleurpepper

Going off piste here- but do horses really need washing in very cold temps? Mud can just be brushed off. They need natural oils, etc under layer of fur to grow, to keep warm.

Owners clip their horses out then buy expensive rugs to keep them warm, even to the extent of 2 or 3 rugs, far too much.
The amount some owners spend on their horse pets is just amazing.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 25-Jan-23 20:14:18

Katie59

Fleurpepper

Going off piste here- but do horses really need washing in very cold temps? Mud can just be brushed off. They need natural oils, etc under layer of fur to grow, to keep warm.

Owners clip their horses out then buy expensive rugs to keep them warm, even to the extent of 2 or 3 rugs, far too much.
The amount some owners spend on their horse pets is just amazing.

Our DD competed, our horses had to be clipped otherwise they overheat when exercised and competing.

MaizieD Wed 25-Jan-23 21:11:14

I know this is completely off topic, but we used to have a local establishment which dealt with bringing on Thoroughbred yearlings prior to their sale for racing, and with TB mares and foals. The mares and foals (worth £thousands) all wintered out without a rug in sight. It's owners, who think that because they are cold their horses must be cold, who pile the rugs on...

GrannyGravy13 Wed 25-Jan-23 21:49:49

MaizieD

I know this is completely off topic, but we used to have a local establishment which dealt with bringing on Thoroughbred yearlings prior to their sale for racing, and with TB mares and foals. The mares and foals (worth £thousands) all wintered out without a rug in sight. It's owners, who think that because they are cold their horses must be cold, who pile the rugs on...

Horses for courses as the saying goes.

We had an Arab mare, who was cold 90% of the year at the same time as a friesan who was hot in mid winter.

Different breeds have different needs and a responsible knowledgeable owner will know this.

Fleurpepper Wed 25-Jan-23 21:53:14

Ah well since we have gone completely and totally off piste.

I sincerely believe that pets or animals should only be kept suitable for local conditions, to live as natural and normal a life as possible. No St Bernard's in Mexico, or naked cats in the Alps, for me!

M0nica Wed 25-Jan-23 22:36:59

I know two things about a horse and one of them is rather coarse.

Wheniwasyourage Thu 26-Jan-23 11:56:06

M0nica grin Also, one end kicks and the other end bites. (I do like horses, just don't often associate with them!)

MaizieD Thu 26-Jan-23 12:20:11

Wheniwasyourage

M0nica grin Also, one end kicks and the other end bites. (I do like horses, just don't often associate with them!)

They honestly don't do either unless they've been really badly treated or handled at some time.

effalump Thu 26-Jan-23 12:40:44

I doubt that NZ actually sits down and sorts out his own taxes. He will have a whole bunch of people doing it for him so he'll probably have a 'fall guy' somewhere. There is no such thing as an honest politican.

Grantanow Thu 26-Jan-23 13:05:22

Sunak is reported to be 'livid' about the whole sorry affair.

Petera Thu 26-Jan-23 13:18:38

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

25Avalon Thu 26-Jan-23 14:22:03

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

Then he went on to say there were careless errors which could be penalised. Not sure I understand all of this. So much conjecture.

Fleurpepper Thu 26-Jan-23 16:49:41

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

but his errors were not innocent, so not relevant!

Petera Thu 26-Jan-23 17:05:50

25Avalon

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

Then he went on to say there were careless errors which could be penalised. Not sure I understand all of this. So much conjecture.

Yes, what he said was that a penalty could be imposed for not taking reasonable care, "careless errors" and "innocent errors are two different things. "

Katie59 Thu 26-Jan-23 17:21:45

25Avalon

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

Then he went on to say there were careless errors which could be penalised. Not sure I understand all of this. So much conjecture.

They did not believe it was an “innocent” error, a wealthy businessman and polititian would be hardly likely to overlook a transaction of that size even if it was tucked away offshore.

It’s the usual HMRC tactic slap a penalty on, they can appeal if they think it’s unfair

MaizieD Thu 26-Jan-23 17:23:10

Petera

25Avalon

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

Then he went on to say there were careless errors which could be penalised. Not sure I understand all of this. So much conjecture.

Yes, what he said was that a penalty could be imposed for not taking reasonable care, "careless errors" and "innocent errors are two different things. "

Being 'careless' in tax inspector terms is failing to take the care that any reasonable person would take. Apparently...

Fleurpepper Thu 26-Jan-23 17:28:07

Petera

25Avalon

Petera

"HMRC boss tells MPs ‘innocent errors’ are not penalised"

Then he went on to say there were careless errors which could be penalised. Not sure I understand all of this. So much conjecture.

Yes, what he said was that a penalty could be imposed for not taking reasonable care, "careless errors" and "innocent errors are two different things. "

and deliberate 'errors' yet another!

ronib Fri 27-Jan-23 07:48:55

I have just been reminded that historically Inland Revenue would invite politicians and their spouses to review their tax returns.

This invitation was not extended to other mortals. My feeling is that politicians have always had preferential tax treatment which doubtless would have annoyed individual tax inspector who were obliged to stay silent.

Nothing new it seems.

ronib Fri 27-Jan-23 07:49:45

Inspectors

ronib Fri 27-Jan-23 08:17:17

Richard North writing in Turbulent Times online today is worth reading.

It just got extremely complicated.

Katie59 Fri 27-Jan-23 08:48:37

ronib

I have just been reminded that historically Inland Revenue would invite politicians and their spouses to review their tax returns.

This invitation was not extended to other mortals. My feeling is that politicians have always had preferential tax treatment which doubtless would have annoyed individual tax inspector who were obliged to stay silent.

Nothing new it seems.

It’s not that long ago that you could go to your local tax office and they would help you fill in your tax declaration. Now everything is online, if you make an obvious mistake or it is greatly different from years before, the system will flag it up and they will query the tax return.
Unfortunately that does not pick up omitted transactions and can be several years before they are revealed.