Gransnet forums

News & politics

Very little of the Brexit wall remains it seems to me

(44 Posts)
Callistemon21 Thu 11-May-23 10:49:06

The Civil Service is rather like the BBC - it helps keep us sane.

I said the other day that it doesn't really matter if Ministers do change Departments - they should be listening to their civil servants, who are qualified to give the best and most sound advice and will rapidly bring them up to speed, if they are prepared to listen.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:46:56

👍

GrannyGravy13 Thu 11-May-23 10:44:16

Whitewavemark2

Ok - but I wasn’t calling her “the blob” merely using it as a quote.

But if you interpreted it that way - I apologise - and hope it is now just one wrong😄😄

Sorry Whitewavemark2 I have absolutely no problem with critiquing anyone’s politics or actions, I just feel uncomfortable with personal insults whoever they are.

If that was not your intention I apologise 😘

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:41:46

Mum😄😄😄😄

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:41:06

Ok - but I wasn’t calling her “the blob” merely using it as a quote.

But if you interpreted it that way - I apologise - and hope it is now just one wrong😄😄

GrannyGravy13 Thu 11-May-23 10:36:18

Whitewavemark2

GrannyGravy13

Contest their politics not call them names…

I was quoting Andrea Leadson herself - yesterday she called the civil servants “the blob” - they have no recourse of reply. Easy target for someone trying to find someone to blame.

Two wrongs do not make a right.

Calling a group of people a blob is childish.

Calling an individual a blob is both childish and insulting.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:34:41

GrannyGravy13

Contest their politics not call them names…

I was quoting Andrea Leadson herself - yesterday she called the civil servants “the blob” - they have no recourse of reply. Easy target for someone trying to find someone to blame.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 11-May-23 10:29:29

Contest their politics not call them names…

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 10:18:49

Perfectly clear, thanks.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:16:20

Sorry that sentence was badly constructed. I hope you can make sense if it!

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 10:15:48

Over 60% now want to reverse Brexit, and just over 30% still are in favour. Rest not sure what to think.

And some people still shout 'but it is a democratic choice' - even though it has been proven absolutely clearly that a) it was based on lies b) no-one knew what form Brexit would take c) there was massive interference from abroad - to such an extent that the Electoral Commission would have had to cancel it, had it not be just advisory.

And still they shout 'Democracy' - so so Trump like.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 10:15:40

Don’t listen to people like Andrea “the blob” Leadson - it is only the hard line brexiters, who refuse to listen to the electorate that are casting around for someone to blame.

The government is slowly waking up to the idiocy.

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 10:12:41

It is because trashing them would cause even more massive damage, not because of Civil Servants (although they may be a minor factor- and because they know the damage it will cause).

ronib Thu 11-May-23 09:54:50

My problem is that I don’t know which laws have been retained and which abandoned and the rationale. I don’t have the resources or time to work out how 3000 laws remain intact on the statute book. Any more sound information?

Oreo Thu 11-May-23 09:41:55

Am unsure about this Whitewavemark2 I didn’t want Brexit either but think the slowness is down to civil servants, not their fault but there are so many EU laws to be untangled this will take a long time to do.
As to changing any laws to be in step with the EU which one was it? Perhaps one that was wanted?
I also doubt there will be free movement of people ever again but there could be room to make sure certain people, scientists for example are able to come and go freely.
A lot of Brexit remains then really doesn’t it, not a little however much people may want it to be otherwise.

Dinahmo Thu 11-May-23 09:31:33

Keeping us sane - that's why the govt are trashing the BBC and the Civil Service - they don't want us to understand exactly what they are doing to the country.

Grantanow Thu 11-May-23 09:27:23

The awful right wing media are blaming the Civil Service blob for the backpedaling on trashing EU laws but it's quite obvious Sunak has come to recognise the utility of the vast amount of EU-based regulation and the efficiency drag that attempting to repeal all of it would have on his failing government. Lobbying by business has finally got through to the Tories except for the loony section of backbenchers. The Civil Service is rather like the BBC - it helps keep us sane.

nanna8 Thu 11-May-23 06:47:46

Politicians can be pretty dumb. Either that or they have vested interests which are, of course, undeclared. It always struck me that Brexit was for very rich British businessmen who were behind the scenes manipulating the populace and playing on fears.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 06:03:19

So, the great trashing of EU law is now being quietly put to bed.

Meet reality brexiters! Year after year, month after month and day after day, people, businesses and politicians have been treading the path to no 10 to try to make the Tories to see sense. Like children they have shaken their heads and refused to listen until stark reality stares them in the face. They even quietly changed a law to March in step with an EU change.

I also note that the checks are being delayed yet again.

So little of Brexit remains - that even the EU is willing to chat with the U.K. about trade, potential easier movement for people etc.

I wonder how many thousands of billions this has cost?