Gransnet forums

News & politics

Very little of the Brexit wall remains it seems to me

(45 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 06:03:19

So, the great trashing of EU law is now being quietly put to bed.

Meet reality brexiters! Year after year, month after month and day after day, people, businesses and politicians have been treading the path to no 10 to try to make the Tories to see sense. Like children they have shaken their heads and refused to listen until stark reality stares them in the face. They even quietly changed a law to March in step with an EU change.

I also note that the checks are being delayed yet again.

So little of Brexit remains - that even the EU is willing to chat with the U.K. about trade, potential easier movement for people etc.

I wonder how many thousands of billions this has cost?

Whitewavemark2 Fri 12-May-23 08:17:25

It seems that Badenoch has a reputation for arrogance, being patronising and condescending amongst fellow parliamentarians, just as growstuff described.

I’ve never really taken much notice of her, but I figure her leadership ambitions will not be fulfilled if she doesn’t wind here neck in.

Grantanow Fri 12-May-23 01:07:28

Business has been lobbying the Tories since Brexit not to ditch all the EU derived laws. The essential point is that efficient export to and import from the EU is greatly helped by having common regulations so that goods and services meet the same requirements. Rees-Mogg's idea of a bonfire of EU regulation was never going to fly and Badenoch has just grounded it. Most of the EU derived laws were approved at the time by UK Ministers at the EU Council, not imposed on us by faceless bureaucrats in Brussels as Brexiteers would have us believe.

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 18:20:24

Ah but they didn't need experts, did they???

growstuff Thu 11-May-23 18:05:26

One person who would be perfectly justified in saying "I told you so".

www.youtube.com/watch?v=ic8A7KXFkKY

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 17:07:42

👀

RSPCA (England & Wales)
@RSPCA_official
🐾 🐔 We hugely welcome the UK Government’s U-turn on their plans to scrap the retained EU legislation, which could have wiped out 44 animal welfare laws, including bans on battery hens and using growth promoters on farm animals!🙌

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 17:00:25

NONE of the four nations (as a whole) voted to leave the EU by the way. 73% did NOT vote for Brexit; only 27% did (or 37% of the electorate). But the way the Referendum was set up by Cameron, it only needed ONE vote over 50% of those that cast a vote to tip us over the edge. In the end it was a highly marginal 1.9%.

And people say it was democratic- especially now we all know how it was achieved.

MaizieD Thu 11-May-23 16:56:25

ronib

Sorry about the diversion to chickens - what I meant to say was that with so many thousands of EU laws and regulations, how is the average citizen supposed to know what they are? If you can’t work that out, what is the point of having them in the first place?
Yes chickens definitely in our deeds!

The laws that contain EU related content do not constitute the larger part of UK law. You'd be amazed at how much law there is on the Statute Book...

This might give a feel for how much UK 'law' exists

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-13569604

ronib Thu 11-May-23 15:38:31

Sorry about the diversion to chickens - what I meant to say was that with so many thousands of EU laws and regulations, how is the average citizen supposed to know what they are? If you can’t work that out, what is the point of having them in the first place?
Yes chickens definitely in our deeds!

Dinahmo Thu 11-May-23 15:19:47

MayBee70

GrannyGravy13

Whitewavemark2

Ok - but I wasn’t calling her “the blob” merely using it as a quote.

But if you interpreted it that way - I apologise - and hope it is now just one wrong😄😄

Sorry Whitewavemark2 I have absolutely no problem with critiquing anyone’s politics or actions, I just feel uncomfortable with personal insults whoever they are.

If that was not your intention I apologise 😘

Wasn’t it Leadsom who eluded to Theresa May being unable to have children?

Yes - one of the reasons for her being referred to as Loathsome.

MayBee70 Thu 11-May-23 15:18:44

I think I only remember things that really really annoy me!

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 14:48:38

MayBee70

GrannyGravy13

Whitewavemark2

Ok - but I wasn’t calling her “the blob” merely using it as a quote.

But if you interpreted it that way - I apologise - and hope it is now just one wrong😄😄

Sorry Whitewavemark2 I have absolutely no problem with critiquing anyone’s politics or actions, I just feel uncomfortable with personal insults whoever they are.

If that was not your intention I apologise 😘

Wasn’t it Leadsom who eluded to Theresa May being unable to have children?

Your memory is fantastic - fast becoming an oracle 🙂

Callistemon21 Thu 11-May-23 14:39:34

Fleurpepper

Your deeds have nothing to do with EU Law however.

In rural France, many people still keep a few chickens and a rooster. There have been restrictions recentlyall over EU due to avian flu- a totally different matter.

I don't think I said it it was, I thought it had moved on to chatting about how many people keep chickens.

HousePlantQueen Thu 11-May-23 14:28:40

It was interesting to listen to Skidmore on Peston last night; when the ERG faction were mentioned during a discussion about the new controversial laws regarding 'stopping the boats'....he just rolled his eyes.

MayBee70 Thu 11-May-23 14:27:14

GrannyGravy13

Whitewavemark2

Ok - but I wasn’t calling her “the blob” merely using it as a quote.

But if you interpreted it that way - I apologise - and hope it is now just one wrong😄😄

Sorry Whitewavemark2 I have absolutely no problem with critiquing anyone’s politics or actions, I just feel uncomfortable with personal insults whoever they are.

If that was not your intention I apologise 😘

Wasn’t it Leadsom who eluded to Theresa May being unable to have children?

Fleurpepper Thu 11-May-23 14:25:58

Your deeds have nothing to do with EU Law however.

In rural France, many people still keep a few chickens and a rooster. There have been restrictions recentlyall over EU due to avian flu- a totally different matter.

Callistemon21 Thu 11-May-23 14:21:37

Whitewavemark2

That can’t be an EU law though. Every other person in Europe seems to keep chickens.

And no few small numbers in the U.K.

😁
I don't think that's strictly true now, it might have been when I was in France about 60 years ago, but even then the family I was with didn't have chickens.

We are not allowed to keep chickens here either, it's in the deeds.
Although I've sometimes wondered whether to test the system but we have a wandering fox round here.

vegansrock Thu 11-May-23 14:17:58

I wonder if Brexit and Tory supporters realise that immigration is now at an all time high.

ronib Thu 11-May-23 13:17:47

Don’t think Jacob Rees Mogg is pleased so perhaps a very convoluted exercise by Kemi Badenoch /Sunak to keep his faction out ?

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 12:02:00

I should have explained that Badenoch is responsible for withdrawing the bill to reverse EU law. I suspect she tried to sneak announcement of it in The Telegraph rather than in parliament which is her statutory duty. She didn’t want to get it in the neck from the hard line brexiters.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 11:53:32

Blimey Lindsey Hoyle has found some neither regions and absolutely laid into Badenoch over her behaviour - asking her “who does she think she is talking to”

Whitewavemark2 Thu 11-May-23 11:39:41

That can’t be an EU law though. Every other person in Europe seems to keep chickens.

And no few small numbers in the U.K.

ronib Thu 11-May-23 11:17:04

Seems not a Boris initiative but introduced by Liz Truss. Say no more?

ronib Thu 11-May-23 11:11:26

Ps not entirely true.. I know that we can’t keep chickens in our garden.

ronib Thu 11-May-23 11:08:29

MaizieD It did occur to me recently that with all these thousands of laws in existence, do I dare move out of my front door? I haven’t a clue as to what I may or may not do.
Ian Dunt’s book is arriving tomorrow!
Was the original bill a Boris brainwave ? Yes quite extraordinary times.

MaizieD Thu 11-May-23 10:57:11

ronib

My problem is that I don’t know which laws have been retained and which abandoned and the rationale. I don’t have the resources or time to work out how 3000 laws remain intact on the statute book. Any more sound information?

The whole lot were retained, ronib. As far as I'm aware none have been superceeded.

So far nearly 5,000 of our laws that were affected by the EU have been identified by those hard working civil servants whom the tories are demonising, and there are probably more.

It was always a completely irresponsible proposal, though typical of the staggering irresponsibility of Brexit and all that has arisen from it.

Not only irresponsible but the original bill handed over massive powers to the Executive, in complete contravention of the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty. It really proposed to bypass any scrutiny by MP s and Lords. I.e. to do away with their prime function.