Gransnet forums

News & politics

Labour will be a major reforming government

(280 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sat 13-May-23 10:05:55

According to the headline report in the guardian today.

Starmer “if you think that our job in 1997 was to rebuild a crumbling realm, that in 1964 it was to modernise an economy overly dependent on the kindness of strangers, in 1945 to build a new Britain, in a volatile world, out if the trauma of collective sacrifice, in 2024 it will have to be all three”

Starmer then went on to pad out some of the policies he intends to introduce, including investment in a green agenda, expansion of NHS staff, votes at 16, fundamental reform of workers rights, recognise people’s need for stability, order, security.
“We must understand that there are precious things-in our way of life, in our environment, and our communities - we must protect, preserve and pass on to future generations.

The Tories do nothing to protect our rivers and seas, our NHS, or families or nation”

MayBee70 Sat 13-May-23 19:20:05

Primrose53

Anniebach

If all downhill after John died how come Labour won 3 consecutive general elections ?

I should have said “in my opinion”. Yes Blair and Brown got in but OMG what a mess they made!!

Lied about Iraq
Created the detested bedroom tax
Sold hospitals to the private sector
Brought in disability assessments
Created the hated zero hours contracts
Created a generation of dependancy
Created Tuition fees
Signed over 100 PFI contracts

That’s just to be going on with.

Does creating a generation of dependency mean actually helping people that need help?

Primrose53 Sat 13-May-23 19:16:41

Casdon

Primrose53

Anniebach

If all downhill after John died how come Labour won 3 consecutive general elections ?

I should have said “in my opinion”. Yes Blair and Brown got in but OMG what a mess they made!!

Lied about Iraq
Created the detested bedroom tax
Sold hospitals to the private sector
Brought in disability assessments
Created the hated zero hours contracts
Created a generation of dependancy
Created Tuition fees
Signed over 100 PFI contracts

That’s just to be going on with.

Some poetic licence employed…. Shall we do a similar list for the Tories so you can compare them Primrose53?

Might be better to start your own thread as this one is about the Labour party. 🙂

Ilovecheese Sat 13-May-23 19:05:46

I keep seeing that Starmer said that Labour are the real Conservatives now. Did he really say that? Although it wouldn't surprise me if it is true.

MaizieD Sat 13-May-23 19:04:26

Ilovecheese

I thought it was the Tories that brought in the bedroom tax?

So did I. But don't let's spoil the fantasy.

What interests me is why the tories haven't righted some of these perceived 'wrongs' during their 13 years in power.

Ilovecheese Sat 13-May-23 18:58:03

I thought it was the Tories that brought in the bedroom tax?

Casdon Sat 13-May-23 17:24:11

Primrose53

Anniebach

If all downhill after John died how come Labour won 3 consecutive general elections ?

I should have said “in my opinion”. Yes Blair and Brown got in but OMG what a mess they made!!

Lied about Iraq
Created the detested bedroom tax
Sold hospitals to the private sector
Brought in disability assessments
Created the hated zero hours contracts
Created a generation of dependancy
Created Tuition fees
Signed over 100 PFI contracts

That’s just to be going on with.

Some poetic licence employed…. Shall we do a similar list for the Tories so you can compare them Primrose53?

Primrose53 Sat 13-May-23 17:17:26

Anniebach

If all downhill after John died how come Labour won 3 consecutive general elections ?

I should have said “in my opinion”. Yes Blair and Brown got in but OMG what a mess they made!!

Lied about Iraq
Created the detested bedroom tax
Sold hospitals to the private sector
Brought in disability assessments
Created the hated zero hours contracts
Created a generation of dependancy
Created Tuition fees
Signed over 100 PFI contracts

That’s just to be going on with.

Sparklefizz Sat 13-May-23 15:06:36

Kandinsky

*we need an honest, hardworking person who puts the welfare of the common man and women before that of his/her wealthy cronies*

Well therein lies the rub.

He’s not really sure what a woman is.

I couldn't vote for him for this reason.... and for several others.

Anniebach Sat 13-May-23 15:05:33

If all downhill after John died how come Labour won 3 consecutive general elections ?

Grantanow Sat 13-May-23 14:59:26

There are so many problems facing the UK (including the economic consequences of the self-inflicted catastrophe of Brexit) that Labour will find it difficult to deliver significant improvements in a 5 year term. Achieving second 5 years may therefore prove very doubtful so I am beginning to see a move to PR as highly desirable to avoid another disastrous Tory government full of cranks and opportunists.

Kandinsky Sat 13-May-23 14:56:12

we need an honest, hardworking person who puts the welfare of the common man and women before that of his/her wealthy cronies

Well therein lies the rub.

He’s not really sure what a woman is.

NanaDana Sat 13-May-23 14:35:43

Whitewavemark2

But presumably you will still vote? And all we voters have to go on is what politicians say, and whether we agree with the general drift.

I certainly don’t vote for personality. Look where voting for Johnson got us!!

If the question is directed at me, Wwm2, the answer is yes, as always, as I'm a firm believer that bad M.P.'s are often those who are elected by people who don't vote.

MayBee70 Sat 13-May-23 14:15:10

Primrose53

It was all downhill for Labour after John Smith’s tragic death and I never voted for them again. Never will either and that is coming from someone who grew up in a Labour household, a Labour road, a Labour village and a Labour district!

Dare I ask which party you do want in government then?

AGAA4 Sat 13-May-23 14:13:20

Anything is better than our current government but labour is in control here in Wales. Enough said.

Primrose53 Sat 13-May-23 14:00:30

It was all downhill for Labour after John Smith’s tragic death and I never voted for them again. Never will either and that is coming from someone who grew up in a Labour household, a Labour road, a Labour village and a Labour district!

Primrose53 Sat 13-May-23 13:56:55

Bossyrossy

We don’t need a charismatic, charming PM, Kandinsky, we need an honest, hardworking person who puts the welfare of the common man and women before that of his/her wealthy cronies. Starmer is a man who cares about the people. He didn’t get his knighthood for nothing.

The last true Labour man was John Smith. Fine politician and a gentleman. Nobody since has come even close.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 13-May-23 13:23:25

Personally I would rather it was nationalised, but if it isn’t then this is a good start to getting control of our air and water.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 13-May-23 13:22:19

Here is what Labour are saying about our air and water

“Support the environment and act on sewage

Improve people’s access to both urban and rural green space
Consider expanding national parks and creating new ones and ensure the public have the right to experience, enjoy and explore nature
Ensure that there are sufficient responsibilities and protections to manage and conserve our natural environment for all
Pass a Clean Air Act, establish a legal right to breathe clean air and place new duties on ministers to ensure air quality guidelines are met.
Use regulatory powers to keep consumer bills down and ensure that water companies – rather than the public – pay for their failures
Set mandatory targets to halve water leaks…Strike off company directors who continually breach and ignore their responsibilities
Ensure illegal activity is punished and ensure payments of dividends are linked to key performance metrics
Introduce mandatory monitoring of sewage outlets and automatic fines for sewage discharges, with a penalty for outlets that do not have monitoring in place.
Set ambitious targets to cut sewage outflows”

MayBee70 Sat 13-May-23 13:14:53

Germanshepherdsmum

It’s very easy to say what any idiot knows people want to hear.

That’s why he’s tapping into the racist xenophobic vote. Oh, hang on a minute, that’s not him, it’s the current government….

MaizieD Sat 13-May-23 13:14:19

Germanshepherdsmum

Don’t all politicians?

What do you suggest we have instead of politicians, GSM?

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 13-May-23 13:09:36

Don’t all politicians?

GagaJo Sat 13-May-23 13:09:03

Germanshepherdsmum

It’s very easy to say what any idiot knows people want to hear.

As the Tory populists do every. single. time.

Bossyrossy Sat 13-May-23 13:07:07

We don’t need a charismatic, charming PM, Kandinsky, we need an honest, hardworking person who puts the welfare of the common man and women before that of his/her wealthy cronies. Starmer is a man who cares about the people. He didn’t get his knighthood for nothing.

Chocolatelovinggran Sat 13-May-23 12:51:37

I'm with WWM . I don't vote for a party on the basis of the charismatic personality of their leader. That is how this country ended up with Mr Johnson. Some people seem to confuse the role of a PM with winning " I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here".

HousePlantQueen Sat 13-May-23 12:41:43

Unfortunately my confidence in any politician or political party actually following through on their promises is at an all time low

You are not the only one to say this GrannyGravy, and this is the damage that the Tories, in particular Johnson and Truss, have done. Not just to their own Tory brand, but to politics in general. This is unforgiveable.