Gransnet forums

Education

It's Scheiße, merde and mierda from me! 💩 💩 💩

(5 Posts)
MartavTaurus Fri 21-Aug-26 11:13:15

76% gets you a grade 9 in English GCSE

78.5% gets you a grade 9 in Physics

But the grade boundary for French GCSE is 89.5%

88% for German

87.5% for Spanish

Where is the bloody incentive for the high ability students to choose modern foreign languages at GCSE?

(Excuse my French in the last paragraph!)

Witzend Fri 21-Aug-26 11:36:58

Well, I know I’m biased, since I was good at languages and rubbish at physics, so if I’d taken that at (then) O level I’d have struggled to scrape a bare pass.

Again I’m probably biased, but I do think the sciences are generally harder than modern European languages. I’d make an exception for anyone having a go at Mandarin, though…

danielmnovak Fri 21-Aug-26 11:36:59

I can see why this looks odd. The boundary itself does not mean French is harder than English, but for a pupil choosing subjects, seeing nearly 90% required for a grade 9 does send a pretty clear message.

There is also a wider issue here. If a student look at those numbers he will thought that a language is a risky choice when they could take another subject with a lower grade 9 boundary. That looks counterproductive when schools are already trying to encourage more pupils to study languages.

nanna8 Fri 21-Aug-26 11:58:30

Here you get extra credit for getting a foreign language qualification at VCE ( our version of A level ). It helps get you into uni, extra marks. One of my daughters got an almost perfect score because she had German as one of her subjects.

MartavTaurus Fri 21-Aug-26 12:00:24

nanna8

Here you get extra credit for getting a foreign language qualification at VCE ( our version of A level ). It helps get you into uni, extra marks. One of my daughters got an almost perfect score because she had German as one of her subjects.

👍
That's interesting.