Israel, Hamas and now Hezbollah

Whitewavemark2

BBC web-site

Israel was warned by Egypt of potential violence three days before Hamas' deadly cross-border raid, a US congressional panel chairman has said.
House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee head Michael McCaul told reporters of the alleged warning.
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu described the reports as "absolutely false".
Israeli intelligence services are under scrutiny for their failure to prevent the deadliest attack by Palestinian militants in Israel's 75-year history.
"We know that Egypt has warned the Israelis three days prior that an event like this could happen," Mr McCaul told reporters following a closed-door intelligence briefing on Wednesday for lawmakers about the Middle East crisis, according to AFP news agency.

It’s all alleged Whitewavemark2 nobody has come out and made a statement that there was definite intelligence of when, what and where.

If they had bombarded Palestine with multiple missile strikes and ground troops, the outrage and condemnation would be stratospheric.

Sorry, WW2 already reported this.

GrannyGravy13

Fleurpepper

Not at all. the opposition parties have been warning about this for many months. And Egypt gave clear warnings about a very serious imminent attacks days before- and these were all ignored. Of course, Netanyahu denies this.

Can you please post a link or point us in the right direction to your allegations Fleurpepper

I have not seen this on any news programme, newspaper or radio station.

I have no idea if it's true, but it was reported quite widely.

www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-67082047

Oreo

I would think Israel is used to rumours of attacks on them, it’s a way of life.

Yes, there are always rumours, but if Israel had pre-empted the attack by Hamas and acted on a rumour can you imagine the outrage of the Palestinian sympathisers…

BBC web-site

Israel was warned by Egypt of potential violence three days before Hamas' deadly cross-border raid, a US congressional panel chairman has said.
House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee head Michael McCaul told reporters of the alleged warning.
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu described the reports as "absolutely false".
Israeli intelligence services are under scrutiny for their failure to prevent the deadliest attack by Palestinian militants in Israel's 75-year history.
"We know that Egypt has warned the Israelis three days prior that an event like this could happen," Mr McCaul told reporters following a closed-door intelligence briefing on Wednesday for lawmakers about the Middle East crisis, according to AFP news agency.

There were rumours of an increase in Hamas activity but no conclusive evidence of the extent of the attack or when it would happen.

I would think Israel is used to rumours of attacks on them, it’s a way of life.

Fleurpepper I have just found an article in The Guardian referring to Egypt warning Israel of an imminent attack.

This has been refuted by the Israel Government and USA as fake news.

It’s worse than sad I’d say!

Fleurpepper

Not at all. the opposition parties have been warning about this for many months. And Egypt gave clear warnings about a very serious imminent attacks days before- and these were all ignored. Of course, Netanyahu denies this.

Can you please post a link or point us in the right direction to your allegations Fleurpepper

I have not seen this on any news programme, newspaper or radio station.

Fleurpepper

GrannyGravy13

Fleurpepper

The opposition in Israel has been aware of strong intelligence/evidence that serious attacks were about to be committed. They repeatedly asked Netanhayu's Governement for emergency meetings to ensure they were totally prepared. But they refused.

The walls from Palestine were destroyed in broad day light by massive bulldozers, etc- and there was a good 30 km between the wall and the kibbutz were the attacks took place? How on earth were they able to do so without being stopped and attacked on the ground or from the air?

This is what the opposition is asking in Israel. HOW WAS IT POSSIBLE'?

Evidence that they knew beforehand please Fleurpepper

Absolutely no Government would sit back on their laurels if they had intelligence of an attack on their citizens.

Yes, you'd think so. So why did they?

So you haven’t got any evidence.

It’s rather sad to post conspiracy theories at a time when a country is currently fighting two separate groups of terrorists.

Not at all. the opposition parties have been warning about this for many months. And Egypt gave clear warnings about a very serious imminent attacks days before- and these were all ignored. Of course, Netanyahu denies this.

You have no knowledge at all about this Fleurpepper
I think you’ve been taken in by conspiracy theorists.

GrannyGravy13

Fleurpepper

The opposition in Israel has been aware of strong intelligence/evidence that serious attacks were about to be committed. They repeatedly asked Netanhayu's Governement for emergency meetings to ensure they were totally prepared. But they refused.

The walls from Palestine were destroyed in broad day light by massive bulldozers, etc- and there was a good 30 km between the wall and the kibbutz were the attacks took place? How on earth were they able to do so without being stopped and attacked on the ground or from the air?

This is what the opposition is asking in Israel. HOW WAS IT POSSIBLE'?

Evidence that they knew beforehand please Fleurpepper

Absolutely no Government would sit back on their laurels if they had intelligence of an attack on their citizens.

Yes, you'd think so. So why did they?

slaughtered, butchered, burned alive, raped

Absolutely tickingbird.
And we can add beheaded and kidnapped.
There are no words to describe the abhorrent behaviour of the disgusting pieces of ……..
who committed these atrocities.

Fleurpepper

The opposition in Israel has been aware of strong intelligence/evidence that serious attacks were about to be committed. They repeatedly asked Netanhayu's Governement for emergency meetings to ensure they were totally prepared. But they refused.

The walls from Palestine were destroyed in broad day light by massive bulldozers, etc- and there was a good 30 km between the wall and the kibbutz were the attacks took place? How on earth were they able to do so without being stopped and attacked on the ground or from the air?

This is what the opposition is asking in Israel. HOW WAS IT POSSIBLE'?

Evidence that they knew beforehand please Fleurpepper

Absolutely no Government would sit back on their laurels if they had intelligence of an attack on their citizens.

Glorianny

I’ve been wondering where certain posters were over the last 9-10 days. Some are usually very vocal on the N&P threads. I did wonder if the massacre by Hamas and the outrage of most on here had put them off posting their normal hard left anti Israel vitriol. I knew the apologists would arrive at some point.

Perhaps that s why Hamas acted.

Acted? Acted? Slaughtered, butchered, burned alive, raped.

Thanks for showing us what I already knew.

the eradication of the Palestinian is the Israeli government aim

The eradication of the Jewish race is the aim of Hamas, and unfortunately many others.

The opposition in Israel has been aware of strong intelligence/evidence that serious attacks were about to be committed. They repeatedly asked Netanhayu's Governement for emergency meetings to ensure they were totally prepared. But they refused.

The walls from Palestine were destroyed in broad day light by massive bulldozers, etc- and there was a good 30 km between the wall and the kibbutz were the attacks took place? How on earth were they able to do so without being stopped and attacked on the ground or from the air?

This is what the opposition is asking in Israel. HOW WAS IT POSSIBLE'?

I think I know what Hamas want in the immediate future, but when we had terrorist attacks in London, in particular on 7th July 2005 with over 50 left dead, followed by other attacks in London which killed others, the Manchester Arena bombing killing 22 people, the twin towers attack with 3000 plus dead, the attack on a beach in Tunisia, the awful Parisian shootings leaving 130 dead, plus the Charlie Hebdo shooting leaving 12 dead, along with a multitude of so called ‘lone wolf’ attacks all over Europe, after all this I genuinely wonder what exactly the radicalised terrorists want, and how well they are supported by their friends and colleagues. Hamas, ISIS, the Taliban, the fanatics in Iran and Saudi. They all apparently want a Jew free world, and also preferably a Christian free world, because we are all infidels. The Coptic Christians were slaughtered unmercifully in Egypt by ISIS.
I don’t know what the answer is. Some on here seem to think they know the answer to the Palestinian situation, but what about everything else? I think it’s simplistic to think that if this, or that, or the other happened, it would all be well. Israel is unfortunately, only the tip of the iceberg.

So I will ask you yet again PaddyAnn54
what should the Israeli Government do?

Hamas are guilty of murder, rape, kidnapping and many other atrocities committed on 7/10/23 should they just be forgotten?

It’s Hamas that are using innocent civilians as human shields.

Hamas will not give up, not return hostages,
what else can Israel do?

The eradication of Palestinians is the Israeli GOVERNMENT aim ,is that to be excused .They've been working towards it for decades with NO interference from the western world.
I have already said that I march for Palestine as do many Scottish jews ,my cousin who married a jewish woman and converted amongst them .Its not antisemitic to support Palestine we are against only the government of Israel not the people .
I have seen no posts supporting Hamas on here ,no antisemitism just people offering some support to Palestinians who have been treated appallingly for decades .There is no excuse for the Hamas attack but the Israeli reaction IS a war crime and must be condemned

GrannyGravy13

Glorianny

GrannyGravy13

Joe Biden is flying into Israel tomorrow, makes me think that Israel will not start their ground offensive before then.

There is no way that POTUS would be flying in if there was a risk to his life.

Whitewavemark2 unfortunately the ordinary people have no sway apart from at elections. Gaza hasn’t had elections since 2007 I think, at least Israel has regular elections.

Does that mean that as long as a far right government, which will and does introduce and pass legislation, which will damage and discriminate against certain people, based on their ethnic origins and their religious beliefs, is an elected government that is OK? Isn't that approving of fascism?

It’s up to the individual where they put their X Glorianny

Hamas have been launching missiles into Israel for years, is it any wonder that Israel tried to clear parts of Gaza of its inhabitants who as we know harbour the terrorists, some willingly.

Of course it is up to the individual but many Jews will tell you that the far right extremist parties which represent sections of Judaism which are extreme and not representative of most Jewish people are favoured and beginning to dominate in Israel. They do not want Arabs in the country, they do not approve of Christians, they operate "Family friendly" policies which basically means they are against gay freedoms. They are a scary bunch and they have gained ground this year. Perhaps that s why Hamas acted.

Well it’s about time one of the prophets came down from the mountain and reinforced Thou shalt not kill - to all faiths.
Or maybe the Pope or other religious leaders? If Moses is unavailable….

Iam64

It’s difficult not to agree with tickingbird, that the eradication of the Jews isn’t the end game for these terrorists

Well their aims originally stated in 1988, were apparently to re-gain possession of their holy land, and the only way they could see this happening was to eradicate the Israelis from Palestine.

There is nothing in these stated aims to suggest that they would not stop there, although I’m sure it is open to debate,