Gransnet forums

News & politics

Will Israel comply to the ICJ ruling?

(195 Posts)
Cadenza123 Sat 27-Jan-24 14:29:36

No I don't think that Israel will comply while they have the backing of the US.

GrannyGravy13 Sat 27-Jan-24 13:20:37

UNWRA (United Nations Relief and works agency) USA, Canada and now U.K. have suspended all funding to this organisation working in Gaza after revelations that aid workers employed by UNWRA took part in the heinous attack of 7/10/23.

Grantanow Sat 27-Jan-24 12:57:32

Whitewavemark2

This ruling is about genocide in Gaza, by Israel.

Hamas were not under consideration.

Whataboutery cuts no ice.

The Court saw fit, in the context of South Africa's application, to call for HAMAS to release the hostages. I don't think that is 'whataboutery'. The Court's problem in dealing with HAMAS is that it is not a signatory to the treaty governing the Court.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 27-Jan-24 12:14:59

This ruling is about genocide in Gaza, by Israel.

Hamas were not under consideration.

Whataboutery cuts no ice.

silverlining48 Sat 27-Jan-24 10:48:41

Israel won’t take any notice of the judgment.

Hamas been asking for a ceasefire

Thousands of Palestinians will continue to die.

Captured Israelis also risk death simply by being in Gaza and constant Israeli Bombardment.

Most ordinary people wherever they are just want a safe, peaceful life for them and their families but are subject to decisions are made by those in power. It’s a total tragedy.

Bella23 Sat 27-Jan-24 10:48:22

I hope that Holocaust Day will make all sides reflect on what they are doing to innocent people.

GrannyGravy13 Sat 27-Jan-24 10:46:07

I hope that whoever is still managing to get arms to Hamas and its supporters is stopped.

I would like Hamas to give some of their stashed supplies to the innocent citizens of Gaza.

I would like Egypt to open the Rafa crossing to let aid through.

Oreo Sat 27-Jan-24 10:44:26

It isn’t genocide.

Glorianny Sat 27-Jan-24 10:43:14

I don't know if Israel or Hamas will comply with the ruling (although I do wonder if the hostages are still alive and if anyone knows where they are)
I do hope the UK will stop supplying arms to Israel so facilitating this genocide.

Jaberwok Sat 27-Jan-24 10:43:01

What about a court requirement that Russia ceases their invasion of Ukraine? Yes? No! thought not! Such hypocrisy! As for the poor hostages, those that are alive that is; will Hamas comply? I think not. So stalemate it is.

GrannyGravy13 Sat 27-Jan-24 10:28:13

I doubt very much that Hamas will comply with the ICJ and release the hostages.

Oreo Sat 27-Jan-24 10:21:32

Another me too here.

Anniebach Sat 27-Jan-24 10:20:51

Quote Grantanow Sat 27-Jan-24 10:09:44
Will HAMAS comply with the Court's requirement they free the hostages?

I too ask this question

merlotgran Sat 27-Jan-24 10:15:46

Grantanow

Will HAMAS comply with the Court's requirement they free the hostages?

This!

NotSpaghetti Sat 27-Jan-24 10:11:54

No. He will just go on as he has been doing.
I heard the reply too petra.

Grantanow Sat 27-Jan-24 10:09:44

Will HAMAS comply with the Court's requirement they free the hostages?

Grannybags Sat 27-Jan-24 09:47:58

Never unfortunately

petra Sat 27-Jan-24 09:44:11

Listening to Netanyahus reply to the court, not a hope in hell.

Smileless2012 Sat 27-Jan-24 09:35:09

I very much doubt it, I'm sorry to say.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 27-Jan-24 07:20:45

So the ICJ has stopped short of demanding a complete ceasefire, saying that Israel has a right to defend itself, but has ruled that South Africa does indeed have a plausible case under the Genocide Convention 1948. The ICJ roughly agreed with all 9 points of the South African case.

So the call is for Israel to immediately

Stop killing Palestinians civilians

Take immediate and effective action to give humanitarian aid to the civilian population, including water, food and medical aid.

Amongst other issues.

Will Israel comply?

They have a month to report back to the ICJ.